~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

LOS ANGELES POLICE COMMISSION

NEWS BRIEFINGS

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

At the Special Police Commission Meeting on December 20, 2007:

The Commission unanimously approved a Special Order entitled"Confidential Financial Disclosure Policy and Procedures for Gang Enforcement Detail and Narcotics Field Enforcement Section Units Established." 

The unfortunate circumstances of the Rampart corruption scandal led to the City of Los Angeles entering into a Consent Decree with the United States Department of Justice on June 15, 2001.  This Consent Decree was a direct result of a pattern of practices that represented loose management over officers, and specifically those who deal with valuable contraband or cash.  Paragraph 132 of the Federal Consent Decree states,"The LAPD shall require regular and periodic financial disclosures by all LAPD officers and other LAPD employees who routinely handle valuable contraband or cash.  The LAPD shall periodically audit a random sample of such disclosures to ensure their accuracy.  When necessary, the LAPD shall require the necessary waivers from such officers."

Police Commission President Anthony Pacheco stated, "The Police Commission has the utmost faith and confidence in the fine men and women of the LAPD.  The unilateral implementation of a Financial Disclosure Program is not a sign of the lack of confidence in the sworn officers, rather a matter of compliance with the Consent Decree. This is one more step in making the Los Angeles Police Department the best law enforcement agency it can be."

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

At the Police Commission Meeting on December 18, 2007

Commission Business - Commissioner Robert Saltzman met with Captain Scott Sargent, and separately with Arif Alikhan and Steve Olivas from the Mayor's Office. He also toured the Skid Row area with officers from Central and he was very impressed with the professionalism of the officers working there and the amount of respect they garner from people living there. Commissioner Alan Skobin attended the Board Meeting of Peace Officer's Association of Los Angeles County, the fundraiser at LAPD Museum for Officer Tony Salazar, who was recently seriously injured on duty, the Mayor's Holiday Reception at the Getty House, the Los Angeles Police Protective League Holiday Party, the Chief of Police's Holiday Party, and the LAPD Sponsored Toy Giveaway and Holiday Party for the San Fernando Valley.  He also held meetings with Council Members Huizar and Zine regarding public safety issues, including replacement Astro radios and Hotel Enforcement.  In addition, he had a ride along with Air Support Division.  Commissioner Andrea Sheridan Ordin continued her many efforts on the homeless issue in the downtown area.  She was pleased to report that a second law clinic was provided to the residents of skid row by local law firms to assist them in clearing their records. In addition, Commissioner Ordin attended several holiday functions including that of the Los Angeles Women's Police Officers Association, the Commission staff, the Central City Association, the Los Angeles Protective League, and the Chief's Holiday Party.  Commissioner John Mack met with separately with Assistant Chief Paysinger and Mayor Villaraigosa to discuss various issues.  In a ddition, he attended many holiday events!  Commissioner Anthony Pacheco requested updates on several items including the MacArthur Park incident, the Department's Community Relations program, and the Explorer program.  Similar to other Commissioners, Commissioner Pacheco has attended many holiday events.

Chief's Report -  Assistant Chief  Sharon Papa reported on the continued decrease in crime.  Violent crime is down by 8.1% compared to the same time last year.

Executive Director's Report - Richard Tefank reported that Item 7D has been pulled from the Agenda, and the Commission Investigation Activity Report for the month of November was included for review.

Police Administrator Laura Filatoff presented the Department's Proposed Budget for Fiscal Year 2008/2009.  She stated that the Budget was organized in terms of priorities, yet there are mandatory costs, such as salaries that must be met.  The top priority is the purchase and installation of In-Car Video Cameras.  The $1.5 billion budget was approved with the understanding that the City is in difficult fiscal times, and that items could likely be pulled.

The report relative to the "Sworn Classification Essential Functions," was continued.  Commissioners Skobin and Saltzman were assigned to look at this matter further.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

At the Police Commission Meeting on December 11, 2007

Commission Business -Commissioner Alan Skobin met with LAPD Fiscal personnel regarding the upcoming budget, with Downtown L.A. Business Owners regarding First Amendment Marches and Rallies, with Council President Eric Garcetti regarding various issues including Astro radio replacement and In Car Video Cameras, and with Captain John Sherman regarding the upcoming Valley Station, and its impact on area boundaries. He attended numerous events including the Chief's Community Forum Summit, the Devonshire Area fundraiser for Officer Ambry Owens, the  Oscar Joel Bryant  holiday party, the Police Relief Association holiday party, the Command Officers Association holiday party, the Police Memorial Foundation holiday dinner, and the Independent Cities holiday reception. In addition, he chaired the meeting of the Department of General Services Office of Public Safety Oversight Committee, and attended and spoke at the recent LAPD Recruit Graduation.  Commissioner Andrea Sheridan Ordin particpated in numerous events including the Community Police Advisory Board Co-Chair Luncheon.  She was impressed with the excitement expressed by the attendees about their community improvement projects throughout the City.  Commissioner Ordin has also been working with the Inspector General's Office on the expedited release of the Categorical Use of Force Abridged Summaries on LAPDOnline.org.  Commissioner Robert Saltzman continued with his orientation to the Police Commission through various meetings and briefings.  Commissioner John Mack, along with Commissioner Ordin, met with Mayor Villaraigosa and Councilmember Garcetti to discuss Consent Decree issues.  In addition, he attended the Chief's Community Forum Summit.  Commissioner Anthony Pacheco met with Chief Bratton to discuss various issues, with the staff from the Mayor's Office, and he also met with Assistant Chief Paysinger.

Chief's Report -  Assistant Chief  Earl Paysinger reported that the Department is approaching its goal of 5% reduction for major crimes in the year of 2007.  At this time, major crimes are down by 4.4% compared to this time last year, equating to 5,500 fewer victims of crime.  Gang crime, which has been targeted by the Department, is down by 3.5%. Commissioner Pacheco congratulated the Department on these impressive statistics.

Senior Clerk Typist Beverly Pitts was named the Police Commission Employee of the Month for October, 2007.  She has done an outstanding job in controlling the complaint files, and in addition, she has performed the timekeeping task when needed for the Office of the Inspector General.

Police Administrator Thom Brennan reported on the Fire/Life Safety issues in Parker Center.  He stated that all improvements have been made and the Department is focusing on maintenance issues for the remaining 18 months of occupation in Parker Center.  The problem of rodents in the rear of Parker Center is being addressed in a variety of ways.  All new structures are still on schedule.  The next building to open will be the Valley Bomb Squad Facility in January, 2008.  All structural steel is in place for the new Police Administration Building, and the outside curtain will soon be installed allowing for interior work to progress regardless of weather conditions.  This building is scheduled to open in May, 2009.

The Second Amendment to the Agreement between the City of Los Angeles, and Motorola Incorporated for Voice Radio Switch and Dispatch Integration Services, was approved.  Commissioner Skobin was assigned to follow this project.  Upon completion, the new package to be provided by Motorola will enhance the dispatchers' ability to route and handle calls.  In addition, it will provide 24 additional dispatcher work stations.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

At the Police Commission Meeting on December 4, 2007

Commissioner Mack opened the meeting by welcoming new Police Commissioner Robert Saltzman.  Commissioner Saltzman responded by saying that he was looking forward to the many challenges of being a Police Commissioner.

Commission Business - Commissioner Andrea Ordin reported that she participated in several meetings and conversations, including a meeting with the Department and the Inspector General regarding retaliation complaints.  She also commented that much of Police Commissioners' work is actually outside of the public meetings.  Commissioner Alan Skobin participated in meetings with Commander Webb to discuss the use of force adjudication process, with Deputy Chief Perez to discuss the preventable traffic collision discipline process, with Councilmember Zine to discuss police issues, attended the retirement for Detective III Emmett Bader, and assisted in some of the negotiations for demonstration locations for the ongoing Writers Guild strike. Commissioner Robert Saltzman reported that he has participated in rather extensive training so far.  He toured the Joint Regional Information Center, drove police vehicles and conducted the Pursuit Intervention Technique, among other hands-on training experiences.  He also attended the Gay and Lesbian Leadership Institute's 23rd Annual Conference, which served as a good opportunity for public agencies to do outreach with other government officials, all of which can be helpful in law enforcement recruitment process. In addition, Commissioner Saltzman introduced one of his guests, USC Gould School of Law student Shervin Lalezary, who was present.  Commissioner John Mack was on holiday last week, however he was honored to attend the funeral services for Homer Broome, LAPD's first African American Captain and Commander.  Mr. Broome was referred to as a pioneer and trailblazer in Department history.

Chief's Report -  Assistant Chief  James McDonnell reported on the creation of a CLEAR team in Southwest, and on the Direct Report Retreat. Crime statistics continue to decline and reflect a 3.5% decrease in gang-related crimes, compared to this time last year.

Executive Director's Report - Richard Tefank noted that the report for item 8E on the agenda has been revised.  He also said that he attended the Direct Report Retreat and felt that the information was very beneficial.

Inspector General's Report - Andre Birotte, Jr. participated in the Mobile Field Force Training last week along with meeting with Commissioner Robert Saltzman.  He is continuing to fill vacancies in his office.  He reported that he and his staff are continuing to examine the incidents that occurred on May 1st at  MacArthur Park

The Commissioners presented the Police Meritorious Service Medal to Police Officer III+3 Richard Nagatoshi for his outstanding work in procuring and maintaining Bomb Squad vehicles and equipment. The Police Commission Unit Citation was awarded to Captain I Justin Eisenberg, Sergeant II+3 Michael Salinaz, Detective II+ Jim Joy, Detective II+3 Ron Capra, Detective I+3 Doug Stice, Detective I+3 Brandon Martin, Detective I Jack Blanchard, Detective I Kevin Korne, Police Officer III+3 Jackie Hickey, Police Officer III+3 Don Thompson, Police Officer III+3 Tony Huerstel, Police Officer III+3 Richard Nagatoshi, Police Officer III Steve Kuranishi, Lieutenant II Gary Lynch, Detective II Ray Morales, Detective II Al Silvas, and Detective II Mike Kozak, for their collective work in burning 60 sticks of active dynamite on site and averting a major catastrophe.

The Office of the Inspector General's report relative to the Annual Categorical Use of Force incidents for the Calendar Year 2006, was approved.  Incidents such as these have decreased in recent years and it was suggested that improved training might be the reason.  Assistant Inspector General Nicole Bershon will report back with possible correlating factors such as the number of officers per year, and assaults on officers.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

At the Police Commission Meeting on November 20, 2007

Commission Business - Commissioner Alan Skobin reported that he attended the Asian Pacific Islander Community Forum meeting, along with Commissioner Pacheco, the La Ley mixer, and participated in an Official Police Garage program.  Commissioner Shelley Freeman reported that she met with Sheriff Baca, West Hollywood Councilmember Jeffrey Prang, and former Police Commissioner Dean Hansell regarding the Explorer issue. She also met with new Police Commissioner Robert Saltzman.  Commissioner John Mack was travelling a great deal yet still attended the recent recruit graduation ceremony, met with Deputy Chief Garner and Executive Director Tefank regarding a personnel matter, and also met with State Senator Mark Ridley Thomas.  Commissioner Anthony Pacheco attended the“Friends and Families” event annually presented by the K-9 Unit.

Chief's Report -  Assistant Chief Sharon Papa reported that an officer had been run over by a suspect before the meeting and that Assistant Chief Paysinger was responding to the scene.  She listed crime statistics and stated that homicides are down by 17.3% compared to the same time last year.  She also reminded everyone to not leave parcels or valuables within view inside a vehicle during the holiday season, or at any time.

Executive Director's Report - Richard Tefank reported that Robert Saltzman had passed through Public Safety Committee and is scheduled for confirmation in City Council on November 21st (Commissioner Saltzman has since been confirmed).  He also reported that the Commission Investigation Division activity report was included for review and that meetings are being set with the Human Relations Commission and Personnel Department regarding various issues. 

Inspector General's Report - Andre Birotte, Jr. introduced Police Performance Auditor III Amanda Dyson, and he also reported that he spoke at a criminal justice class at West Los Angeles College.

Police Commissioner Shelley Freeman was honored by her fellow Commissioners with a certificate of appreciation and the Police Commission Distinguished Service Medal.  All Commissioners expressed their gratitude to Commissioner Freeman for her more than two years of devoted service as a Commissioner.  She, in turn, thanked her fellow Commissioners and the Department, and listed several accomplishments of this Commission, including increased transparency, streamlining the use of force investigation process, assisting the Chief with his goals, promoting active and diverse recruitment, moving toward compliance on the Consent Decree, striving toward improvement on Skid Row, improving the resources for the Office of Inspector General, working through several high-profile cases, officer safety improvements, and the reappointment of Chief Bratton.  She also mentioned issues that she would still like to see accomplished such as the need for more officers, cameras in the patrol cars, working hand-held radios for all officers, and a complete review of each officer's action during the MacArthur Park May 1st incident.

Commander James Cansler reported on the diversity of police officer applicants in the hiring process.  This item will come back to the Commission after further meetings with the Personnel Department.

The Department's report relative to the Police Explorer Program and administrative issues was approved with the understanding that additional information will be provided at the December 18th meeting. Commissioner Freeman outlined some of the history with the Department and Learning for Life, which is an organization that provides structure for the Police Explorer Program throughout the country.  She highlighted that Learning for Life is an organization under the Boy Scouts of America, and the Boy Scouts have a stated policy of discrimination against gays and lesbians.

The report relative to the ordinance, policy, and procedures in respect to the acceptance of donations for the Police Department was continued to December 18th.

Deputy Chief Mark Perez  reported on the current status of the personnel investigations and adjudication process relative to the MacArthur Park incident.  He stated that transcribers are now present at interviews to expedite and clarify the process.  Twelve new complaints have been received.  It is still his goal to refer cases the District Attorney in December.


Employee News

Police Performance Auditor III Amanda Dyson has joined the Office of the Inspector General. She has been with the City of Los Angeles for 12 years and has worked at the Controller's Office and Community Development Department.  She is a Certified Internal Auditor, Certified Governmental Financial Manager, and In-Progress - Certified Fraud Examiner.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

At the Police Commission Meeting on November 13, 2007

Commission Business - Commissioner Alan Skobin reported that he attended the fundraiser for Detective Mike Selleh's family. Approximately 500 people attended.  He also met with the Assistant to the Commanding Officer of Office of Operations on a variety of issues. He reported that he has continued working on the ASTRO radio issue and he feels that there is now a viable plan, including funding, being developed.  Commissioner Andrea Sheridan Ordin attended a Legal Aid Foundation fundraiser honoring Brad Brian.  She also traveled to Miami meeting with several former United States Attorneys.  Commissioner Anthony Pacheco met with Chief Bratton to discuss several issues.

Chief's Report -  Chief William Bratton reported on the crime statistics stating that homicides are down by 16.1% compared to the same time last year.  Larger classes are now being accepted into the Academy for recruit training.  He was proud to announce that recruits will now receive a signing bonus up to $5,000.  The bonus will be retroactive for all recruits currently in the Academy.

Executive Director's Report - Richard Tefank announced that a reception will be held on Tuesday, November 20th, from 8:00 am to 9:15 am, in Room 618, to thank Commissioner Shelley Freeman for her outstanding work as a Police Commissioner.  Unfortunately, November 20th will be Commissioner Freeman's last day as a Commissioner.  Mr. Tefank also introduced Mr. Robert Saltzman, who has been nominated by the Mayor for the open Police Commissioner position.  He is scheduled for confirmation by the City Council on November 21st, clearing the way for his first Police Commission meeting on December 4th.

Department staff reported on the feasibility of the Department of Transportation investigating all reportable City property-involved traffic collisions.  The DOT reviewed the proposal and determined that it did not meet their main objective, which is to control traffic in the City.  Department staff provided another option which is to have Community Service Representatives perform the investigations, taking sworn officers away from the function.  Commissioner Skobin praised staff on this innovative approach and the report was received and filed.

The Commission approved the Digital In-Car Video System agreement with International Business Machines.  While there were some delays due to bidder protests, the cameras will be installed in the South Bureau first. Chief Information Officer Tim Riley and Commander Kirk Albanese explained some of the features of the system including triggers for the cameras such as lights and siren activation, removal of shotgun, use of back seatbelt, and self-activation.

Employee News

Management Assistant Kenneth Keene has joined the Permit Section. Twenty years ago, Kenneth was with LAPD at Rampart and transferred to Valley Bureau.  He then left the city to develop a neighborhoods in transition model for churches.  He has been an ordained Minister for 25 years and currently serves as senior pastor of a local congregation.

Management Assistant William Huang has joined the Permit Section.  He is a recent graduate from Cal Poly Pomona majoring in Computer Information Systems.  After graduation, he worked at Disney Consumer Products as a member of the Global Support team.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

At the Police Commission Meeting on November 6, 2007

Commission Business - Commissioner Alan Skobin visited the Hertzberg-Davis California Forensic Science Center.  He was very impressed with capabilities of the center and the people working there. He asked the Department prepare a report on the Department's forensic capabilities and current backlog in all categories including fingerprint, DNA, and blood analysis.  He also asked the Department report back on the status of his request that all SWAT officers be assigned take home vehicles. In addition, Commisisoner Skobin attended and participated in several events including the monthly meeting of the Official Police Garage Association, the Golden Badge Foundation awards, the Actors and Others fundrasier where the LAPD Animal Cruelty Task Force was acknowledged, the LAPD Reserve Foundation “Twice a Citizen” awards dinner, the Latino Law Enforcement Officers Association Annual Picnic, and the Parker Foundation Golf Tournament dinner. Commissioner Andrea Sheridan Ordin attended the Mental Health Advocacy 30 Year Celebration along with the swearing in ceremony for the new United States Attorney for the California Central District.  Commissioner Shelley Freeman participated and chaired the Alzheimer's Association Walk and met with Chief Bratton regarding the Explorer issue.  Commissioner John Mack met with Police Administrator Gerald Chaleff, and participated in the pre-meeting breakfast.  Commissioner Mack also asked the the private investigator issue be placed on a future agenda for closed session.  Commissioner Anthony Pacheco was out of town for the majority of the week, but asked that the community relations presentation be scheduled for a future agenda.

Chief's Report - Assistant Chief McDonnell reported on the continuing decline of crime statistics.

Inspector General's Report - André Birotte, Jr., announced that a new Police Performance Auditor will be joining his staff next week.  Staff from his office had the opportunity to meet with brigadier generals from Egypt to discuss and share experiences.

Deputy City Attorneys Anne Tremblay and Jonathan Cristall were presented with the Police Commission Distinguished Service Medal for their work in the Newton Area Nuisance Abatement program.  City Attorney Rocky Delgadillo commended the two attorneys and stated that their work has provided a model for other projects in his office. Sergeant Michael Apodaca of the Ombuds Office was presented with the Police Meritorious Service Medal for creating the LAPD Cancer Support Group. Police Officers Jeffrey Williams and George Lewis were presented with the Police Distinguished Service Medal for their work on the Bad Boys Identity Theft operation, which resulted in numerous and pending arrests of gang members.

All agenda items were approved including the personal services agreement with LoJack Corporation for stolen vehicle recovery network services, the Gang Enforcement Detail Status Report, 3rd Quarter, 2007, and the Official Police Garage (OPG) future rate changes and recommendation to increase existing OPG towing and storage rates for 2008.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

At the Police Commission Meeting on October 30, 2007

Commission Business - All Commissioners attended Chief Bratton’s Reappointment Ceremony on October 25th, and congratulated him upon his next five-year term. Commissioner Alan Skobin attended the dinner celebrating Chief Bratton’s reappointment, a fundraiser for the Van Nuys Area Station Fund, the North Hollywood Open House, Central Traffic’s annual “Cops for Tots” car show, and a fundraiser sponsored by an LAPD officer and his family to raise funds for an orphanage in Nicaragua. Commissioner Andrea Sheridan Ordin attended and addressed the Annual LAPD Women’s Conference, where there were approximately 1,000 attendees. Commissioner Shelley Freeman continued in discussions regarding the Explorer matter, and also commented that she saw that the Las Vegas Police Department is in the process of purchasing 600 new cameras for their taser guns. She felt that it was a good reminder as this Department awaits in-car video cameras. Commissioner John Mack and Executive Director Richard Tefank met with Jeff Schlanger from Kroll and Associates. He and Mr. Tefank also met with Councilmember Bernard Parks to discuss Department issues.

Commissioner Skobin provided an update on meetings with various City department officials regarding preventative maintenance of existing ASTRO radios and acquisition of new ASTRO radios for Department personnel. This is critical for both officer safety and service to the public, and the acquisition of new ASTRO radios for all officers is a high priority for the entire Police Commission.

Chief’s Report - Chief Bratton thanked all Commissioners for the opportunity to serve an additional five years. He reported that recruit class sizes have now increased to 60 to 70 students per class. In the near future, the Department will make a presentation on overtime and how it is used throughout the Department. Studies on deployment and civilianization are also forthcoming. Next week, Chief Bratton will be in Washington D.C., to accept an award from Governing Magazine.

Executive Director’s Report - Richard Tefank reported that the in-car video status report will be presented on November 20th. In addition, the racial profiling complaint matrix will be presented on that date also.

Deputy Chief Mark Perez presented a verbal status report of personnel investigations of officers involved in the MacArthur Park incident. He stated that there are a total of 316 complaints being investigated, and the Department is reviewing all video from the incident and initiating its own complaints. He anticipates the investigations to be complete by January, 2008. When questioned why some of the more obvious cases could not be forwarded now, he responded that many cases impact each other. To assume that one case is closed now would be a mistake as more information from another case could change the outcome. The Commission asked for another status report on this topic in one month.

The Commission approved the Hunter-La Ley Consent Decree Annual Report for the Fiscal Year 2006/2007, for transmittal to the Office of the City Attorney.

The Commission approved the Department’s and the Inspector General’s Discipline Reports for the Second Quarter, 2007.

Detective Eric Moore and Captain Ann Young presented their report relative to decriminalizing the registration process by hotel and motel workers. Commissioner Skobin had examined this issue and had recently been in the field with officers assigned to this detail. He supported the Department’s recommendation to oppose the decriminalization of 41.49 LAMC. The report was approved for transmittal to City Council.

Commission Business - Commissioner Alan Skobin attended the Chief’s Hispanic Community Forum meeting, the Italian Lawyers’ Association meeting, Mayor Villaraigosa’s reception for Commissioners, and the Chatsworth/Northridge Rotary Club meeting. He was the keynote speaker at the annual meeting of the Mid-Valley Community Police Council. Commissioner Skobin also observed an ICE operation in the San Fernando Valley, along with a K-9 Unit training event. He met separately with Mission Area Senior Lead Officers, representatives from the Official Police Garages, and the Commanding Officer of Commercial Crimes Division. Commissioner Shelley Freeman continued the discussion relative to the Explorer issue, and various personnel matters. Commissioner Andrea Sheridan Ordin attended and addressed the Chief’s Hispanic Community Forum meeting, the recent graduation ceremony for recruits, and the annual Domestic Violence Awareness press conference. Commissioner John Mack met with Mayor Villaraigosa and Deputy Mayor Alikhan regarding Department issues. Commissioner Anthony Pacheco expressed concern for all those impacted by the recent wildfires in the area. He also reported that participated in the 30 Year Pin Ceremony for Department employees, met with Reverend John Hunter of First AME Church, and met with the members of Fire Station #62.

Chief’s Report - Chief Bratton reported on crime statistics and stated that overall violent crime has been reduced by 46% in the last five years. He attended the International Association of Chiefs of Police (IACP) Conference in New Orleans, and Department events including the 30 Year Pin Ceremony. He also announced several command staff promotions and transfers.

Executive Director’s Report - Richard Tefank announced that the contract regarding in-car video cameras should be before the Commission shortly.

Inspector General’s Report - Andre Birotte attended the Chief’s Hispanic Community Forum meeting, and the IACP conference. He introduced a new employee, Special Investigator II Michael Hyams.

Systems Analyst II Carlos Gonzalez, from the Inspector General’s Office, was named the Police Commission Employee of the Month for September, 2007.

Several donations benefitting the Department’s Explorer program were accepted and approved by the Commission. Commissioner Shelley Freeman stated that she did not wish to hold any funding back from the program but is still concerned over the connection between the Explorer program and the Boy Scouts of America.

The Commissioners discussed the report regarding the incident occurring at MacArthur Park on May 1st. Questions were raised regarding the lack of dispersal orders, the level of command presence, and the possible rotation of Metro officers.

Deputy Chief Perez provided an overview of Internal Affairs procedures. He was asked to return in one week to outline the status of personnel investigations of officers involved in the MacArthur Park incident.

Commander Rick Webb discussed possible trends reflected in the Annual Complaint Report. The Commissioners expressed concern over the lack of sustained racial profiling complaints. Executive Director Tefank, Commander Webb, Commissioner Skobin, and Commissioner Ordin will examine the process and recommend protocols that will address the Commissioners’ concerns.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

At the Police Commission Meeting on October 9, 2007

Police Administrator Gerald Chaleff and Deputy Chief Michael Hillmann outlined the Department's actions during and after the MacArthur Park incident on May 1st.  In a very candid and thorough review, communication errors were outlined which eventually led to the undesirable circumstances.  Lessons learned were in the areas of planning, tactics, command and control, situational awareness, training and individual responsibility.  Twenty-three recommendations were presented in the report including the creation of Incident Management and Training Bureau, the clear printing of numbers and/or names on officers' helmets, an annual review of tactics, and new technology such as sound trucks.

Commission President Pacheco reiterated that this was the first of a series of reports, both public and internal, that would be produced about the incident.  The Commissioners attended a press conference with the Mayor immediately following the Commission meeting to further address the recommendations.

The Department's report is available for review on LACP.org --> May Day 2007 Report

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

At the Police Commission Meeting on October 2, 2007

Commission Business - Commissioner Alan Skobin, Chaired a meeting of the Office of the Public Safety General Services Police Oversight Committee.  In addition, he attended numerous meetings and events including the San Fernando Valley Coalition Against Gangs Fundraiser, the National Latino Peace Officers Association event - La Ley chapter, the LAAPRAC and LAPPL Picnic, the San Fernando Valley Faith Coalition meeting, a Hollywood PALS benefit, the Armand Arabian Award Luncheon honoring Deputy Chief Michael Moore, the Rape Treatment Center Annual Brunch, the Police Foundation True Blue dinner, and the West Valley Area Reunion.  He also taped an edition of “Your Police Commission,” discussing employee relations.

Commissioner Andrea Sheridan Ordin spoke with UCLA Professor Gary Blasi regarding his recent study of Skid Row law enforcement efforts.  She also participated in the first Legal Clinic held at the Union Rescue Mission. This pilot program is a consortium of the City Attorney's Office, Legal Aide, and three private law firms who have agreed to provide legal service to Skid Row residents.  In addition, Commissioner Ordin participated in the Los Angeles Bar Committee on Diversity meeting, and she taped an edition of “Your Police Commission,” addressing Skid Row issues. 

Commissioner Shelley Freeman participated in several personnel-related conversations, met with civilian union representatives regarding the grievance process, received a positive report from Councilmember Jack Weiss' office regarding lewd conduct issues in Hollywood, attended the Police Foundation True Blue event, and the Rape Treatment Center Brunch which benefits victims of rape.  She stated that all guests were complimentary of the LAPD's relationship with the Center, yet concerned about the 10,000 rape kits yet to be tested.  She also announced the upcoming L.A. Valley Pride Festival on October 14th at the CBS Studio in Studio City. 

Commissioner Anthony Pacheco, along with Commissioners Ordin and Mack, attended the Los Angeles Women Lawyers Association annual installation dinner where Assistant Inspector Nicole Bershon was sworn in as President.  He attended an event honoring Assistant Chief Paysinger, Fire Chief Barry, and Water and Power Commissioner Hogan-Rowles, along with the Watts Gang Task Force.  He commended the community members in that area for their successful crime prevention strategies.  He also participated in an Autism training seminar which is designed to train volunteers who will go to roll calls to train officers on the best ways to recognize and work with individuals with Autism.  In addition, he met with members of the Los Angeles Police Protective League to discuss various matters.

Chief's Report - Chief William Bratton reported that violent crime is down by 8.1% compared to this time last year, and 46.7% compared to this time five years ago.

Report of the Executive Director - Executive Director Richard Tefank announced that Commission Investigation Division's Monthly Report has been submitted, and that the Police Commission agenda reports should be available online within 60-90 days.

Report of the Inspector General - André Birotte, Jr. introduced Special Investigator II Brian Buchner.  He stated that he was very proud of Nicole Bershon's appointment as President of the Los Angeles Women Lawyers Association. The Office of the Inspector General participated in the National Association of Civilian Oversight of Law Enforcement in San Jose, and subsequently, Mr. Birotte has been asked to join their Board of Directors.

Captain Cansler reported on the status of the Department's many recruitment efforts.  He was asked to report back on the 4,726 individuals who are in the “pipeline” waiting to begin training, and provide information where they are in the “pipeline,” along with their diversity.

Commander Albanese reported on the Department's process and methodology for deploying police resources. As stated before, there are 24 factors, such as calls for service, travel time, and level of violence, used to determine deployment on a constant basis.  At this time, the Department-wide response time is seven minutes, and the Department is working on ways to decrease that time.

Deputy Chief Moore reported on deployment in the San Fernando Valley. He stated that the methodology used is sound and appropriate given the needs of the Valley Bureau.  The current system allows for immediate response to Part One Crimes and also allows for quality of life issues.

The report on the progress of the Professional Standards Bureau's Racial Profiling investigations subsequent to the implementation of the new protocol was continued to clarify which cases were before and after the placement of the new protocols.  In addition, the Inspector General was asked to report back in 45 days with an audit of randomly picked cases.

The Hunter- La Ley reports for Third and Fourth Quarters, Fiscal Year 2006/2007, were approved.  The Commissioners did express concern regarding some of the consistent ranks, such as Police Officer III, that do not meet compliance.  However, there is overall compliance.

The Southeast Area Gang Enforcement Detail Command Accountability Audit was approved.  While the audit reflected some inconsistencies, Assistant Chief Paysinger reiterated his commitment to reach 100% on these audits. Commissioner Pacheco stated that he is equally concerned with management's responsibility to gain compliance, as he is with the officers' ability.

Public Comment - Several individuals spoke on the Safer City Initiative in the Skid Row area.

Employee News

Brian Buchner joined the Office of the Inspector General as a Special Investigator II.  He has a Master's Degree in criminology and criminal justice from the University of Missouri-St. Louis.  Brian was a Police Officer in the Ocean City Police Department in Ocean City, Maryland and then went to work at the Police Assessment Resource Center analyzing police policies and practices and models of civilian oversight around the United States.  Most recently, Brian worked for the Corporation for Supportive Housing working with the Los Angeles County Sheriff's Department to design a housing program for homeless inmates.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

At the Police Commission Meeting on September 18, 2007

Commission Business - Commissioner Alan Skobin, along with Sheriff Lee Baca, spoke at a memorial for September 11th first responders, participated in a press conference with the National Latino Peace Officers Association regarding child safety, attended the Foothill Boosters Association Golf Tournament, and met with Commander Cansler regarding the Reserve Program.  Commissioner Skobin also acknowledged audience member Detective III Lou Koven.  Both Detective Koven and Commissioner Skobin served as Explorers together 40 years ago. Commissioner John Mack, along with Commissioner Pacheco and Executive Director Tefank toured the Joint Regional Intelligence Center in Norwalk. Commissioner Mack held several phone conversations with Deputy Mayor Alikhan regarding Consent Decree issues, and he also met with Vinnie Malcolm, General Manager at KTLA.  Commissioner Anthony Pacheco attended and spoke at Friday's recruit graduation.  He commented that the Los Angeles FBI Director, Steve Tidwell, was in attendance, reflective of the Department's good working relationship with the FBI. Commissioner Pacheco, along with Commissioner Mack, also met with Command Staff at the pre-meeting breakfast.  Commissioner Andrea Sheridan Ordin continued working on staffing issues related to the Inspector General's Office.

Chief's Report - Assistant Chief James McDonnell reported on the tragic killing of a 23 day-old baby.  There were approximately 50 witnesses to this horrific crime, and he is hoping that someone will come forward with information on the suspect.  Violent crime is down by 7.8% compared to this time last year.  Recruitment continues to be strong, and there are 374 recruits in the Academy.

Report of the Executive Director - Executive Director Richard Tefank announced that the Department's report on the May Day incident in MacArthur Park will be presented at the Police Commission meeting on October 9th, at 8:30 am, in the Public Works Boardroom.  Commissioner Pacheco inquired when the presentation on Community Relations would occur.  Mr. Tefank stated that the training component of that presentation is still in progress, but near completion.  Commissioner Pacheco also asked that the Department make a presentation on the Autism Awareness Roll Call Training, which will begin in October.

Report of the Inspector General - André Birotte, Jr. reported that he was invited by Lt. Rick Dedmon of Force Investigation Division, to a seminar presented by the California Narcotics Officers Association.  The seminar featured Lt. Col. David Grossman from the US Army, and he discussed combat, stress, and decision making as it relates to local law enforcement.

Police Administrator Thom Brennan reported on the status of all construction projects within the Department. The structural steel for the new Police Administration Facility will be in place by the end of this year, and the project is still scheduled for completion by May of 2009. 

Captain Dave Baca and Sgt. MacWillie provided an update of the Automated Photo Red Light Enforcement Program.  There are currently 25 intersections in the City of Los Angeles equipped with the newer digital video cameras.  The report was approved for transmittal to City Council, however Commisisoner Skobin asked the Department to report back and address the 40% of photos captured that do not result in violations.

Executive Director Richard Tefank outlined the status of authorized personnel positions for the Office of the Inspector General for Fiscal Year 2007-2008.  After the current openings are filled, a mid-year budget request in December is a possibility. However, if that request were to be successful, actual staffing relief would not occur until early 2008.  Options were discussed such as loans and pro-bono assistance, yet all appreciated the importance of maintaining an independent investigative body that is not associated with other entities, or the Department itself.  Commissioners Ordin and Skobin agreed to continue to look at short and long-term approaches to providing adequate staffing for the Inspector General.

The Audit Recommendation Status Report, First Quarter, 2007-2008, was approved.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

At the Police Commission Meeting on September 11, 2007

Commission Business - Commissioner John Mack participated in a meeting with Deputy Mayor Arif Alikhan regarding Consent Decree matters, and the African American Forum meeting.  He also was interviewed by KTLA regarding their 60 years of broadcasting in Los Angeles.  Commissioner Alan Skobin attended the Jack Webb Awards benefiting the Los Angeles Police Historical Society, participated in the Motel Detail operation with Detective Support Vice Division in South Bureau, viewed a DUI checkpoint with numerous arrests, and participated in meetings regarding the continued enhancement of the Reserve Program.  Commissioner Anthony Pacheco also participated in the African American Forum meeting, held various media interviews, and participated in the pre-meeting breakfast.

Chief's Report - Chief William Bratton reported that violent crime is down by 7.9% compared to this time last year.  He stated that it may be possible that this year will end numbers comparable to 1970 in terms of homicides.  He also attended the Jack Webb Awards and the African American Forum meeting.  He was pleased to announce that Christina Ripatti was the Jack Webb Awards.  He also stated that the May Day report will now be presented to the Police Commission on October 9th. The report will also be available on LAPDOnline.org on that date and a presentation will be given to the City Council's Task Force on that evening.  The report will be approximately 80-100 pages.  He announced that he will be lifting the moratorium on the impounding of cars of unlicensed drivers.  This clarification will take effect on Wednesday, September 12, 2007.  Commissioner Pacheco added that the Department will also be responding to the City Council request for more information on this item next week.

Report of the Inspector General - Andre Birotte, Jr. reported that he spoke to the incoming class at the Delinquency Control Institute at USC, hosted a guest speaker at the Office of the Inspector General who is a recently retired Inspector from the Northern Ireland Police Department, and attended the African American Forum meeting.  His office is also conducting interviews for Police Performance Auditor positions. Staffing issues continue to be a problem for the Office of the Inspector General.  This issue will be agendized for the Commission's formal action.

Lt. II Rick Wall and Captain Ann Young presented the Semi-Annual Consent Decree Mental Illness Project Status Report.  This project has actually become a model for other agencies to follow and been extremely successful in mitigating potential disasters with mentally ill patients. SMART Teams are now an essential part of any negotiating situation. However, the Mental Evaluation Unit struggles with the inability to hire staff, lack of vehicles, and lack of technical support.  This item will return with a Department report outlining ways to obtain full staffing and equipment for this Unit.

Deputy Chief Kenny Garner described the deployment of LAPD officers at Los Angeles International Airport.  Since 2001, when the terrorist attacks in New York occurred, LAPD has deployed 22 officers at LAX, feeling that it is a priority in terms of safety for the City of Los Angeles.  Commissioner Pacheco suggested that he and others meet with representatives from Los Angeles World Airports to address some continuing questions such as the status of study that was to be completed related to this issue and also reimbursement to LAPD for the services of those officers.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

At the Police Commission Meeting on August 21, 2007

Commission Business - Commissioner John Mack attended the retirement celebration for Commander Jim Voge along with the most recent Recruit Graduation. Commissioner Andrea Ordin attended the retirement celebration for Deputy Chief Caylor Lee Carter and also discussed various Department issues at the pre-meeting breakfast. Commissioner Anthony Pacheco also participated in the pre-meeting breakfast and worked on a variety of Department issues last week.

Chief's Report - Chief William Bratton reported that violent crime is down by 8.0% compared to this time last year.  He stated that it may be possible that this year will end with less than 400 homicides, which would be a significant improvement.  He stated that recruitment continues to improve.

Report of the Executive Director - Richard Tefank stated that the Controller's Office is currently conducting an audit of the Official Police Garage contract awarding process and payment of fees to the City by the Official Police Garages.

Certificates of Appreciation were presented to Rafael “Ralph” Casillas, FOX News Reporter Tony Valdez, Captain Rich Wemmer, retired Sr. Photographer J.D. Caboor, Principal Photographer Larry Fugate, Sr. Photographer David Gomez, Photographer II Hopyoung Park, Photographer II Jon Gesch, Audiovisual Technician Steven Sloan, Audiovisual Technician Daniel J. Morehead, Audiovisual Technician Shawn Gabra, Audiovisual Technician Ata Kirmani, and Audiovisual Technician Ken Saba.  These individuals all participated in the production of the “Rafael“Ralph” Casillas Shooting Video,” which is an excellent training tool for officers when confronted with an officer involved shooting situation.

The Foothill and North Hollywood Command Accountability Performance Audits were both approved.  In both cases, there were areas of concern that reflected the correct action being taken but not documented. Deputy Chief Michel Moore stated that he felt there was no intention of wrong doing in any of the circumstances.  Nevertheless, he is asking each station to take steps to reach 100% compliance in the next audit.

Employee News

Detective I Steve Griffin has joined Commission Investigation Division. He has been with the Department for 23 years and has worked Central Division, Hollywood Division on two occasions, Southeast Division, Operations South Bureau CRASH, and Hollenbeck Division.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

At the Police Commission Meeting on August 14, 2007

Commission Business - Commissioner Shelley Freeman reported that she participated in several personnel-related meetings, met with individuals from the Human Relations Commission to discuss the Juvenile Justice program, and met with individuals from the Los Angeles Police Foundation to discuss various donations.  She also held numerous conversations regarding the Explorer program's relationship with the Boy Scouts of America. Commissioner John Mack participated in the National Night Out event at Wilshire Area.  He stated that it was extremely well-organized and well-attended.  On a much sadder note, he attended the memorial service for Officer David Rodriguez.  Commissioner Andrea Ordin also attended that memorial service and commented that Officer Rodriguez was obviously a very focused man who provided for family members.  Last week, she also participated in a meeting discussing present and past litigation regarding personnel matters.  Commissioner Alan Skobin attended the Rosary for Officer David Rodriguez, and expressed condolences over the passing of  Police Officer Bob Cantrell. Commissioner Skobin also attended National Night Out events at Mission and Foothill Areas. He commented on the large number of community members at both events.  Commissioner Skobin also worked throughout the week on the project related to the replacement of radios.  Commissioner Anthony Pacheco also participated in the meeting with the Human Relations Commission, and he attended the National Night Out event Pacific Area, which was predominately designed for kids.

A moment of silence was held for Police Officer III Bob Cantrell.

Chief's Report - Assistant Chief Earl Paysinger thanked the community for the outpouring of sympathy over the Department's recent losses. He reported that violent crime is down by 8.0% compared to this time last year.  That equates to 1,481 fewer violent crimes.  While the Valley Bureau is still above last year's figures, the statistics are starting to slowly come down.  There are currently 393 recruits in the Academy.

Report of the Executive Director - Richard Tefank regretted to announce that Lt. Dawson's mother passed away last week.  He also reported that the City Attorney's Office filed two cases against predatory tow operators based on the new state law, which went into place in January. Commission Investigation Division was critical in providing the information to the City Attorney's Office.

Report of the Inspector General - Andre Birotte, Jr. reported that interviews for the Special Investigator position are continuing. He added that he and his staff are reviewing the circumstances involved in the Officer Involved Shooting case which resulted in the death of Mathew Powell.  This case should be ready for the Commission's review in four to six weeks.

Lt. Doug Miller, the new Commanding Officer of Community Relations Section, was introduced to the Commission.

Commander David Doan discussed the Department's policy as it relates to participation in U.S. Drug Enforcement Agency (DEA) enforcement at medical marijuana dispensaries.  Commander Doan stated the Department supports state law which allows for such dispensaries.  The Department also participates in several task forces with the DEA and other governmental agencies.  The U.S. Attorney only accepts a small number of cases regarding medical marijuana per year, therefore the DEA only focuses its enforcement efforts on those dispensaries known to have ties to organized crime, excessive sales, or nuisance issues.  The LAPD provides security support for the DEA when there are enforcement events. While Commander Doan did not have specific percentages of time that the Department spends on this kind of work with the DEA, he felt that it was not excessive.  He will return with specific percentages.

Captain Rob Hauck and Sgt. Dan Gonzalez presented the Department's process and methodology for deploying police resources.  Deployment is primarily generated from a computer program that considers 25 factors including calls for service, square mileage of area, conditions, etc. This system is refreshed every three months.  However, the Department will often manually adjust deployment based on immediate needs.  The Commission asked that the Department return with a more detailed methodology that emphasizes decreased response time throughout the City. All agreed that while the entire Department is understaffed, it is extremely important to ensure that the resources are distributed appropriately and fairly. 

Commissioner Skobin outlined the efforts he and the Department have made toward improving the radio system now, and also in the future. First, a preventative maintenance program is now in place that serves the entire City instead of one Bureau at a time.  Second, funding has been identified for the installation for 2,700 in-car radios.  Third, the Department is hopeful that a grant will fund the replacement of all Astro radios.  And fourth, Commissioner Skobin strongly urged to have each officer assigned his or her own radio, which will benefit the Department and community in many ways and serve as a “force multiplier.”  This item was continued for additional information and status updates. 

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

At the Police Commission Meeting on August 7, 2007

Commission Business - Commissioner Alan Skobin reported that he attended the memorial service for Detective III Michael Selleh.  He was very moved by the ceremony as he had met with Detective Selleh several times.  He attended roll call at Mission Area to meet with officers who were also feeling the loss of this well-liked detective.  Commissioner Skobin also attended the Latin American Law Enforcement Association's annual installation dinner, met with Council Member Richard Alarcon to discuss shootings in the Northeast Area, and met with command staff regarding the need to replace the ASTRO radios.  Commissioner Andrea Ordin worked internally preparing for several meetings.  She was pleased with the amount of media coverage on the memorial service for Detective Selleh.  The expansive coverage reflected his professionalism and family orientation. Commissioner Ordin asked for an update on the MacArthur Park incident for an upcoming Commission meeting.  Commissioner Anthony Pacheco also attended the services for Detective Selleh, and he visited the North Hollywood Area to meet and talk with officers about the loss of Officer David Rodriguez.  He also met with command staff prior to the Commission meeting.

Chief's Report - Chief William Bratton thanked the Commissioners for the condolences expressed upon the passing of his mother.  He reported that violent crime is down by 8.0% compared to this time last year.  The Department continues to exceed recruitment goals of 50 new hires per month.  Additional effort is being placed on recruiting African Americans.  The Chief reminded all that tonight is National Night Out and each of the 19 Areas will be hosting a program.  He provided a brief overview of the MacArthur Park incident stating the first of four reports will be presented to the Commission by mid-September.  Lately, attention has been focused on the Valley.  Chief Bratton commented that the Department still continues to deploy officers based on the needs of the Area, and while the Department is understaffed, the city is still considered one of the safest in the country.  Reports on this issue and the need for new radios will be presented to the Commission next week. Commissioner Skobin asked if the department is considering the possibility of perishable skills following the initial Mobile Field Force Training, and Chief Bratton commented that this would be left to Chief Hillmann.  Commissioner Ordin questioned the lower number of women in the most recent recruit class, and Chief Bratton stated this was an aberration.

Report of the Executive Director - Richard Tefank reported that the City Attorney's Office will present a one year review of the Safer Cities Initiative in the Skid Row area next week.  Commissioner Mack had previously requested an update on the status of in-car video cameras. The Department is still in the negotiation phase with the provider, IBM. When the negotiations are complete, the contract will be presented to the Commission for approval.

Report of the Inspector General - Andre Birotte, Jr. reported that he and his staff continue to work on MacArthur Park investigations.  His office has one more vacancy, which he plans to fill soon.  Commissioner Mack inquired if the interviews of individuals involved in the MacArthur Park incident are going well.  Mr. Birotte stated that he believed they were, and that the interviews were candid and getting at the real issues.

The Department's report approving a $480,000 grant award entitled,“Juvenile Justice Crime Prevention Act,” was approved.

The Department's report and Inspector General's report relative to the Complaint, Form 1.28, Investigations Audit, Phase II, Third Quarter, Fiscal Year 2006/2007, were approved.

The Department's report and Inspector General's report relative to the Ethics Enforcement Section Quarterly Report, First Quarter, 2007, were approved.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

At the Police Commission Meeting on July 31, 2007

A moment of silence was held in memory of Detective Mike Selleh, Officer David Rodriguez, and June Bratton.

In a unanimous vote, the Police Commissioners elected Commissioner Anthony Pacheco to the President position and Commissioner John Mack to the Vice President position.  All Commissioners thanked Commissioner Mack for his service as the President, and Commissioner Alan Skobin for his service as the Vice President for the last two years.  President Pacheco stated that he was honored to hold the President post and looks forward to continued service to the City of Los Angeles and the men and women of the Department.

Officer Daniel Jara and Officer John Biondo were presented by Deputy Chief Charlie Beck for their heroic work in saving the life of a young woman by administering CPR over the weekend. Sgt. Adrian Moody also assisted in this heroic effort, but could not be present at the Commission meeting.

The Commission continued the item relative to a donation in the amount of $5,000 to the Southwest Area to establish a Southwest Explorer Post at Crenshaw High School.  Concerns arose regarding the connection between Learning for Life, the umbrella organization for the Explorer program, and the Boy Scouts of America.  Commissioner Freeman and several individuals spoke about the stated discriminatory policy of the Boy Scouts regarding gay individuals and expressed concern that Learning for Life is an extension of that policy.  The Commission asked that the Department return with answers to the following questions: What is the efficacy of the Explorer program?  Are there openly gay youth in the Explorer program?  Are there openly gay officers working in the Explorer program?  What is the cost of the program?  In addition, the Commission asked that a review of all donations be provided to the Commission.

Commission Business - Commissioner Andrea Ordin participated in continued meetings and discussions with the City Attorney's Office regarding the homeless and law services.  Commissioner Alan Skobin met with District Attorney Steve Cooley and the Chief of Bureau Investigations regarding the positive working relationship between the LAPD and the District Attorney's Office.  He also met with Assistant Chief Earl Paysinger to discuss the deployment needs throughout the city.  Commissioner John Mack attended the National Urban League's Annual Conference in St. Louis last week.  He also participated in the Lafayette Square Homeowner's Association Meeting with Commander Garner and Captain Nathan.  Commissioner Anthony Pacheco reiterated his appreciation to Commissioners Mack and Skobin for their leadership.

Chief's Report - Assistant Chief Sharon Papa described the sad details of the accidents that took the lives of Detective Selleh and Officer Rodriguez, and she thanked the California Highway Patrol for outstanding assistance in both circumstances.  She also reported on the death of retired Sgt. Ruben Whittington who was awaiting tow service on the freeway when an assailant shot him.  She also stated that while crime is normally higher in the summer months, the trend in Los Angeles continues to go down.  Compared to this time last year, violent crime is down by 8.1%.

Report of the Executive Director - Richard Tefank reported that Commissioner Freeman has been working on the essential job functions project which will be presented to the Commission soon.  He stated that the information on donations and the Explorer program will be scheduled for August 14th.  Yesterday, he and staff had the opportunity to see a demonstration of a proposed false alarm tracking system.  The Department continues to work on the request for proposals process for such a system.  Mr. Tefank also introduced and announced the promotion of Stephanie Herron to Sr. Management Analyst II in the Commission's Personnel Group.

Report of the Inspector General - Andre Birotte, Jr. introduced new employees Sr. Clerk Typist Vera Killpatrick and Special Investigator II John Kelley.

The report regarding the feasibility and cost of using Senior Detention Officers for prisoner release at the Los Angeles County Courts was continued to August 14th, for more information.  This study outlined the need for the Department to provide these services due to the rising costs of the Sheriff's Department doing so.

The Commission continued the report regarding the ASTRO radios and a request for funding to replace the Department's hand-held radio inventory for the Fiscal Year 2008/2009 budget. While the update represented progress in repairing the existing radios and finding alternative funding for new radios, the Commission urged the Department to enhance the report to consider the immediate and dire need for properly functioning radios.  Commissioner Skobin asked that the Department consider filing a Supplemental Budget Request, and to also consider using the remainder of the Penalty False Alarm Trust Fund to buy new radios.  In addition, he suggested that it be considered that each officer be issued his or her own radio.

Captains Sargent and Green from 77th Area discussed the findings and actions taken relative to the recent 77th Area Gang Enforcement Detail Command Accountability Performance Audit.  The Commissioners commended the Captains on the level of improvement that has been achieved since the audit was performed.  All Commissioners agreed that while all audit results need to be monitored carefully, it is important to consider the work of officers who are trying to do the right thing.  Therefore, measuring the efficacy of the forms and the system itself, also needs to be on-going.

Employee News

Stephanie Herron was promoted to Sr. Management Analyst II in the Commission's Personnel Group.  Congratulations Stephanie!

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

At the Police Commission Meeting on July 24, 2007

Commission Business - Commissioner Andrea Ordin participated in the Multi-Agency Gang Initiatives meeting and was impressed with the level of cooperation and enthusiasm shown by all participants.  Commissioner Anthony Pacheco has been traveling on business for the last two weeks, however, he continued to follow pending issues.  He also joined Commissioner Ordin for the Multi-Agency Gang Initiatives meeting. Commissioner Shelley Freeman attended a meeting led by staff from Councilmember Jack Weiss' office regarding lewd conduct incidents in the Hollywood Area.  She was happy to report that these incidents have decreased.  She also attended the Chief's Gay Lesbian Bisexual Transgender Forum meeting, along with the Mayor's breakfast with leaders from the GLBT community.  Commissioner Alan Skobin joined a Crime Reduction Enforcement Warrant (CREW) Task Force.  This task force is a highly organized group of officers that are temporarily taken off non-emergency radio calls to concentrate on crime trends in predetermined areas.  Through this coordinated effort, this particular task force netted hundreds of arrests.  Commissioner Skobin expressed his interest in this methodology becoming a permanent feature.  He also met with officials from the Drug Enforcement Administration to discuss the agency's mobile enforcement museum exhibit.  This portable exhibit will soon be coming to the Los Angeles area, and the LAPD has been involved in this process.  Finally, Commissioner Skobin met with a Police Commissioner from the Hawaii Police Department to discuss issues of mutual concern.

Chief's Report - Chief William Bratton reported that violent crime is down by 8.1% compared to this time last year, which is significant because this is the first time this year that the statistic has surpassed 8%.  As mentioned in previous news conferences, he reminded all not to leave valuables in vehicles as this is an enticement for theft.  He also mentioned the Multi-Agency Gang Initiatives meeting and reported that these meetings will continue.  There are 405 recruits in the Academy and classes are averaging 60 recruits.  He reported that the Department will probably cut back on a purchase of Taser guns to accommodate the increase of 44 anti-terrorist officers.  The Commissioners agreed that this was a difficult, but appropriate decision.

Report of the Executive Director - Richard Tefank reported that item 7b was continued until next week.  He also stated that he and Commission staff had met with staff from the City Clerk's Office to discuss placing reports related to the Commission agenda on the Internet.  In addition, on-demand videos of Police Commission meetings will be available.  As the software is already in place, these new features should be online within 90 days.

Report of the Inspector General - Nicole Bershon reported that she viewed the first session of the 21st Century Mobile Field Force Training, the Office of the Inspector General continues to interview Special Investigator applicants, and staff continues to interview individuals regarding the MacArthur Park incident.

The Department's report relative to the Narcotics Analysis Laboratory Trust Fund expenditure for the purchase of 19 standard computer workstations for Scientific Investigation Division, was approved.

The Department's report relative to the Criminal Case Filing Rates of Individuals Arrested, Second Quarter, 2007, was approved.

Employee News

Management Assistant Rod Betancourt has joined the Alarms Section, Commission Investigation Division. Rod's professional experience includes being a Recruiter/Senior Personnel Consultant for Medix Staffing Solutions, a Corporate Recruiter for TelePacific Communications, a Senior Loan Funder for Provident Funding, and an Office Manager for South Metropolitan Medical Clinic.  He is also a real estate agent and investor, and he holds a B.A. in Political Science and a B.S. in Business Administration from Pepperdine University.

Special Investigator II John Kelley has joined the Office of the Inspector General.  John is retired from the Anaheim Police Department after 28 years of police service.  At the time of his retirement, he was the Lieutenant-in-Charge of the Internal Affairs Bureau. He has been an adjunct faculty member at Fullerton College since 1996 and continues to teach in an adjunct capacity in the Administration of Justice Program. He has a B.S. in Organizational Management and an M.P.A., both from the University of La Verne.

Senior Clerk Typist Vera Killpatrick has joined the Office of the Inspector General.  She has been with the City of Los Angeles, and the Los Angeles Police Department, since 2001.  She has worked at Van Nuys Records and also at Commercial Crimes Division.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

At the Police Commission Meeting on July 17, 2007

Commission Business - Commissioner Andrea Ordin held meetings with command staff, and the Mayor's Office staff regarding the Consent Decree.  She also continued working with legal firms that will provide legal services to residents of the Skid Row area.  Commissioner Alan Skobin attended two LAPD retirements, and at both events, he was struck with the strong presence of family.  He attended a fundraiser with the Devonshire PALS benefitting the new youth and community center. Devonshire PALS has already raised $2.3 million for this facility.  He also met with Anti-terrorism Unit staff and began working on phase two of the audit of that unit.  Commissioner John Mack participated in an interview for a FOX television special regarding the MacArthur Park incident on May 1st.  He also met with Assistant Chief Paysinger, attended a reception at the home of the British Consul, attended a reception for Emilio Garcia Marquez, and he joined Commissioner Ordin at the Mayor's Office to discuss the Consent Decree.

Chief's Report - Chief William Bratton reported that violent crime is down by 7.4% compared to this time last year.  He will be presenting a six-month report on crime at a press conference later in the day.  As recruit classes continue to be larger and larger, 53 recruits will be graduating this Friday.  Last week, he participated in a program of the Leadership Institute at John Jay College in New York. He reported that the Department is moving forward quickly on the “21st Century Mobile Field Force Training,” that was outlined last week by Deputy Chief Hillmann.

Report of the Executive Director - Richard Tefank reported that the Department has requested that items 8E and 8H be continued.

Report of the Inspector General - André Birotte, Jr. stated that he was also interviewed by FOX for the MacArthur Park special, and he also interviewed with KJLH radio on the responsibilities of the Office of the Inspector General.  His office continues to accomplish tasks with limited staffing as he is trying to work through the tentative hiring freeze. 

Special Investigator II Brian Pellis was presented with a Certificate of Appreciation for his three years of outstanding work and dedication at the Office of the Inspector General.  Brian is leaving to work for a private law firm and he will be sorely missed.

Police Administrator Thom Brennan provided an update on current life/safety issues in Parker Center and the status on construction projects. He stated that all enhancements are complete in Parker Center, however a wheelchair lift still needs to be installed in the rear of the building.  All Prop Q projects are on schedule, and there is a $46 million savings on these projects.  It is his hope to use these savings to fund the construction of a new Northeast Station.  The Police Administration Building is on schedule for completion on May 4, 2009.

The Commission approved the evaluation of the Deputy Probation Officer (DPO) Pilot Program, an agreement between LAPD and the Los Angeles County Probation Department.  This program assigns DPOs to work directly with the six Area Gang Enforcement Details.  Benefits have already been realized from this program such as increased recovered stolen property and the early detection of children being exposed to illegal activity. This program, which was a creation of the San Fernando Valley Coalition on Gangs, was commended by Commissioner Skobin.

Lt. Melissa Zak presented the monthly status report on successful completion of directed training on the final adjudication of Categorical Use of Force incidents.  The Commissioners commended the work done on this issue and commented that it is wonderful to see that when a problem is identified, it can be remedied.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

At the Police Commission Meeting on July 10, 2007

Commission Business - Commissioner Shelley Freeman participated in several discussions related to personnel matters, and also met with Mayor Villaraigosa and staff.  Commissioner Alan Skobin chaired the recent Office of Public Safety Oversight Committee meeting and reported that the group is appreciative of the training that is being provided by LAPD to City public safety officers. He also participated in a ride-along, which led to a situation where the sergeant he was with had to use Commissioner Skobin's radio, as the sergeant's radio did not work.  Commissioner Skobin commended Chief Information Officer Tim Riley for his work on replacing the radio system and reminded everyone of the urgency of this matter.  Commissioner John Mack joined Chief Bratton and command staff for the Community Police Advisory Board Co-Chair Luncheon, and he also joined Chief Bratton to meet with David Hiller from the Los Angeles Times.

Chief's Report - Chief William Bratton reported that Part One crimes are down by 3.3% compared to this time last year, and by 31.1% compared to this time five years ago. Recruitment continues to improve.  He stated that there has been some slippage in Consent Decree compliance, and the reports presented today will address resolutions to that problem.

Report of the Inspector General - André Birotte, Jr. met with the MacArthur Park Task Force.  To accomplish an appropriate level of review of this incident, the Office of the Inspector General is hoping to add additional investigators within 60 days.

Detective III Ben Jones was honored as the Police Commission Employee of the Month for May, 2007.  Ben was instrumental in promoting legislation that has improved the quality of service provided by tow operators throughout the state.  After this legislation passed, he initiated a training seminar on the topic which was attended by numerous law enforcement agencies.  In addition to these outstanding achievements, Ben continues to do a superb job in enforcing the entertainment ordinances.

A presentation was made by the Los Angeles City Domestic Violence Task Force.  Commander Harlan Ward stated that Domestic Abuse Response Team (DART) training is being provided citywide and the Commissioners are invited to attend the next training session in September.  This is the second year that funding for the DART program has been provided for in the City budgeting process.  The DART program will also be formally evaluated this year.  Ms. Carol Tantau provided a history of domestic violence and how the law treats it.  She stated that while domestic violence has always existed, the law has viewed it as an actual offense only since the 1980's.  The Nicole Simpson and Ron Goldman murders brought to light the serious nature of domestic violence.  Following that event, domestic violence reports increased dramatically and have continued to stay constant.

Police Administrators Maggie Goodrich and Gerald Chaleff provided an update on the Training Evaluation and Management System (TEAMS) II. At this point the system is up and running throughout the Department.  More than 1,000 action items have been generated from the system and 600 are complete.  The system continues to improve in terms of user friendliness.

Chief Information Officer Tim Riley provided a status on the processing of police reports and the time frame for copies to be obtained.  He reported that at one point, the waiting period for a police report was 132 days, and the current waiting period is 56 days.  The significant waiting period is attributed to the lack of staff and the inability to fill positions.  This issue will also improve when a new document management system is in place.

Deputy Chief Michael Hillmann outlined the “21st Century Mobile Field Force Training.”  This training will be provided for approximately 7,000 officers and will take place at the Joint Forces Training Base. It will provide a unified approach to crowd management for all officers.

Assistant Chief Earl Paysinger discussed his comprehensive plan to correct deficiencies that were noted in the Command Accountability Performance Audit. Among his other approaches, he will implement a“Quality Assurance Team,” provide additional training for command staff, and reinvigorate the Consent Decree coordinator at each Division.

Police Administrator Gerald Chaleff provided a follow-up review of the Motor Vehicle and Pedestrian Stop Data Collection Audit.  He explained that the PODDS which are used for data collection are not manufactured anymore, and that the information that they have collected has been virtually impossible to analyze.  The Commissioners expressed concern that this experiment has essentially not worked in determining if racial profiling exists, but reemphasized their support for the in-car video system, which will hopefully provide some information on this topic.

The Commission asked the Department to return in 30 days with a report on the steps that have been taken to address the deficiencies noted in the Foreign Language and Telecommunications Device for the Deaf (TDD) Audit.

The Commission asked the Department to return in 45 days with a report on the steps that have been taken to address the deficiencies noted in the Supervisory Performance Evaluations Audit.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

At the Police Commission Meeting on July 3, 2007

Commission Business - Commissioner Shelley Freeman participated in several discussions regarding personnel matters, met with Rabbi Alan Freehling regarding juvenile justice, and participated in the first-ever City Council acknowledgement of Gay Lesbian Bi-Sexual Transgender Pride Month. Commissioner Freeman commended Councilmember Bill Rosendahl for his effort in making this event happen.  Commissioner Anthony Pacheco held numerous discussions with Commission staff regarding several issues including homelessness.  Commissioner Andrea Ordin attended a breakfast meeting with Chief Bratton and command staff.  Last Thursday, she attended the Command Officer Promotion Ceremony, the Central City East Promotional Ceremony for Central Area command staff, and the Los Angeles County Bar Association's installation of officers where attorney Connie Rice was honored.  Commissioner John Mack also attended the Command Staff Promotion Ceremony, and he met with Los Angeles Unified School District Superintendent David Brewer to discuss public safety and educational issues.

Chief's Report - Chief William Bratton reported that violent crime is down by 7.0% compared to this time last year, and by 46.4% compared to this time five years ago. Recruitment continues to improve.

Report of the Executive Director - Richard Tefank reported that the City's Domestic Violence Task Force will make a presentation next week.

Report of the Inspector General - André Birotte, Jr. stated that he hopes to add an additional staff member to the Office of the Inspector General by the end of the month.

Deputy Chief Charlie Beck outlined the events that occurred at Leimert Park on June 23rd.  Tension grew throughout the day with the two groups who were there to protest opposing views on immigration.  By 4:00pm, an impasse had been reached and police officers maintained a line in between the two groups.  Due to the public safety concerns of the moment, the Choose Black America group was not allowed to enter Leimert Park.  An agreement was made for five members of the Choose Black America group to be arrested once they crossed the police line.  This action ended the event and the crowds from both sides dispersed.  Ten individuals, most of whom were at the park on that day, spoke on this issue.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

At the Police Commission Meeting on June 26, 2007

Commission Business - Commissioner Shelley Freeman participated in a meeting with staff from the office of Councilmember Jack Weiss to discuss and revisit the issue of lewd conduct enforcement in the Hollywood Area.  She also attended and participated in the many events related to the US Conference of Mayors.  On Sunday, she attended the dedication of the Noah's Arc exhibit at the Skirball Center, and encouraged all to see it.  Commissioner Anthony Pacheco met with the Mayor and staff, addressed the most recent class of police officer graduates and commented on the diversity represented in that class.  He and Commissioner Ordin also met with the new members of Central Bureau command staff regarding Skid Row issues. Commissioner Alan Skobin, along with Commissioner Mack attended the Community Forum Summit, met with representatives from Learning for Life, and met with staff from Training Bureau to discuss the pursuit policy.  He also participated in a ride-along in 77th and commented on the challenges facing officers in that area. Commissioner Andrea Ordin met with command staff from Central Bureau, as did Commissioner Pacheco, to discuss the Safer Cities Initiative and the need for effective, humane enforcement.  She, along with Commissioners Skobin and Mack attended the Oscar Joel Bryant mixer for recent promotees.  She, as all Commissioners, were quite concerned over some of the significant activities during the weekend. Commissioner John Mack commented that Commissioner Freeman was a major contributor to the success of the US Conference of Mayors and he was honored to join her for the gala event. Commissioner Mack and Ordin both met with the court appointed independent monitor to discuss Consent Decree issues.

Chief's Report - Assistant Chief Earl Paysinger reported that violent crime is down by 6.9% compared to this time last year, and by 46.6% compared to this time five years ago. He talked about two event the prior night where LAPD officers did an outstanding job in apprehending dangerous suspects.

Report of the Inspector General - André Birotte, Jr. met with the court appointed independent monitor to discuss many issues including the MacArthur Park incident.  Mr. Birotte was present at the demonstrations at Leimert Park and in Hollywood.

The Commissioners expressed deep concern over the results of the 77th Area Gang Enforcement Detail Command Accountability Performance Audit. The audit did not raise concerns about legality issues, but did reflect negligence in adherence to the Consent Decree.  The audit revealed that there were problems with documentation of gang-related arrests and searches.  The Commission asked those responsible in 77th Division to return in 30 days to outline what has been done to remedy this situation. 

During public comment, several individuals spoke of the demonstrations in Leimert Park.  Commissioner Mack asked that this item be placed on the July 3rd agenda.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

At the Police Commission Meeting on June 19, 2007

Commission Business - Commissioner Shelley Freeman attended the“Ceasefire! Bridging the Political Divide,” event presented by the USC Annenberg School for Communication at the Getty House. Anthony Pacheco had the opportunity to meet one of the providers for the Skid Row area.  He and Commissioner Ordin continue to coordinate their efforts on that area. Commissioner Alan Skobin attended a rock concert fundraiser for the Los Angeles Police Memorial Foundation, met with Detective Moore regarding the Motel Detail, and discussed details of the June 24th march and rally. Commissioner Andrea Ordin particpated in several meetings regarding homeless issues.  She is still concerned with the Inspector General's ability to meet growing demands with limited staff. Commissioner John Mack met frequently with staff during the past week and also attended the Juneteenth Celebration presented by California State Senator Mark Ridley-Thomas, and met with the Urban League's Blair Taylor to discuss a variety of issues.

Chief's Report - Chief William Bratton reported that violent crime is down by 7.2% compared to this time last year, and by 46.6% compared to this time five years ago. Recruitment is going very well, and at this point, the Department has already exceeded the goal of attaining 650 new officers this year.

Report of the Executive Director - Richard Tefank reported that the Commission Investigation Division Activity Report for the month of May was included for review, and that a report on Community Policing will be presented next week.

Report of the Inspector General - André Birotte, Jr. reported that he has been involved in several reviews of Skid Row issues, and has been participating in interviews related to the MacArthur Park incident.  He introduced the new Assistant Inspector General, Susan Hutson.

The Quarterly Status Report, Third Quarter, Fiscal Year, 2006/2007, was approved.

The proposed fee structure for special services provided by the Los Angeles Police Department was approved for transmittal to the Mayor. Both Sr. Management Analyst II Eva Vega and Sr. Management Analyst I Rene Gomez were commended for their diligent work on this project.

The Police Commissioners convened in closed session and returned to open session to announce their decision to reappoint Chief William Bratton to a second-five year term.  Each Commissioner spoke of their evaluation of Chief Bratton, finding him to be an outstanding leader for the Los Angeles Police Department.  He has succeeded in all areas of the Commission's criteria: providing visionary leadership, respecting civilian oversight, promoting community policing, developing crime reduction strategies, addressing police misconduct and reform, promoting diversity, and demonstrating cultural competence.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

At the Police Commission Meeting on June 12, 2007

Commission Business - Commissioner Andrea Sheridan Ordin, along with Commissioner Pacheco, attended the Mexican American Bar Association scholarship dinner where $130,000 of scholarships were awarded.  She also continued her effort in coordinating large downtown law firms to provide pro-bono law services to Skid Row residents.  She anticipates that this program would begin in the fall.  She is meeting with Central Bureau command staff today to discuss several Central Area issues. Commissioner Alan Skobin attended a promotion celebration for Deputy Chief Sergio Diaz, and a Use of Force Committee meeting, along with Commissioner Pacheco.   In addition, he met with several sworn personnel at various ranks.  He commented on a Police Officer II's suggestion to include possibly making some of the video obtained by the in-car video cameras available for public viewing to provide a balanced picture of police work.  Commissioner Anthony Pacheco met with representatives from the Mayor's Office.  Commissioner Shelley Freeman attended the Anti-Defamation League's Annual Deborah Awards which honors those who have displayed outstanding courage and compassion. Commissioner John Mack met with the Inspector General and staff to discuss the MacArthur Park incident.

Chief's Report - Chief William Bratton reported that violent crime is down by 7.5% compared to this time last year, and by 46.5% compared to this time five years ago.  Assaults on officers are up 31.4% compared to last year.  Chief Bratton spoke at the Annual Police Protective League Delegate Conference, spoke in Washington D.C., in support of the House Gang Crime Bill, participated in the Gay Pride Parade, and later this week, he will be attending the National Hispanic Journalists Conference in San Jose.   He reported that as of June 4th, all LAPD forms are online and available for officers' use.  Chief Bratton is closely monitoring the investigations related to the MacArthur Park incident. A training session for Captains and above was held last week, as a part of the comprehensive training program related to MacArthur Park. 

Report of the Executive Director - Richard Tefank reported that item 7A should be referred to as a “receive and file” item, and item 8L, a proposed fee structure for special services provided by the LAPD, is continued.

Report of the Inspector General - André Birotte, Jr. reported that he has participated in many of the same events previously mentioned.  He also addressed the graduating class of Detention Officers, announced that a new Assistant Inspector General has been hired, and stated that his office is continuing its investigation of the MacArthur Park incident.

The Gang Abatement and Prevention Act of 2007, Senate Bill 456, was approved for transmittal to City Council for the City's official endorsement.

The report regarding photo-sharing software for 9-1-1 operators was approved for transmittal to Public Safety Committee.  This program will be phased in, however the first version which will allow the operator to solicit the caller for a photo, will be in place by the end of the year.

The report regarding the Recall (Bounce) Program was approved for transmittal to Budget and Finance Committee. This program will allow retired sworn personnel to return to work for a period of up to 12 consecutive months.

Police Administrator Maggie Goodrich outlined the proposed Special Orders entitled, “Access Control Policy for TEAMS II Information,” and “Duty to Conduct Individual Performance Assessments.”  Ms. Goodrich was asked to return in 120 days with a status report on the Special Order relative to performance assessments.

During the Public Comment portion of the agenda, several individuals spoke on a Central Area incident involving Faith Hernandez on Skid Row.

Employee News

Welcome to Assistant Inspector General Susan Hutson.  Susan is from Austin, Texas where she worked for several years for the Office of the Police Monitor, recently serving as the Acting Police Monitor.  Susan is a graduate of University of Pennsylvania where she got her Bachelor's degree and Tulane University where she got her law degree.  Susan has been a practicing attorney for 15 years having been a solo practitioner, an Assistant City Attorney in Texas and an adjunct professor.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

At the Police Commission Meeting on June 5, 2007

Commission Business - Commissioner Anthony Pacheco participated in several Department-related conversations.  Alan Skobin attended a Valley Traffic Division traffic safety and car show event, the Association for Los Angeles Deputy Sheriffs' dinner honoring several Deputy Sheriffs and Bob Baker from the Los Angeles Protective League, and the 30 Year Ceremony honoring LAPD employees with 30, 35, 40, and 45 years with the Department.  Commissioner John Mack met with Mayor Villaraigosa and Deputy Mayor Alikhan, participated in the Table Two City Club event, met with Councilmember Janice Hahn and others to discuss a gang intervention proposal, participated in the Keep the Peace/Stop the Violence event, and attended the promotion announcement for several command staff positions.

Chief's Report - Assistant Chief James McDonnell reported that Chief Bratton was currently in Washington DC with the Mayor working on obtaining gang enforcement grants.  Chief McDonnell participated in the annual Dockweiler Beach Memorial Run which honors fallen officers.  This year was very special due to the fact that Retired Officer Christina Ripatti participated in the run.  He also provided a brief update on the MacArthur Park incident.  As the investigation continues, the Department has received 90 non-media complaints of injury and 23 media complaints. Four law suits and 23 damage claims have been filed.  A final report for the public should be complete by the end of the year.  Commissioner Mack asked that the Commission be updated in closed session as soon as next week on this item.

Future Agenda Items - Commissioner Pacheco asked that the report which will presented on June 19th reflecting community relations training for officers new to an Area also include Metropolitan Division and any other specialized units.

Report of the Executive Director - Richard Tefank reported that the Special Fees report will be submitted for next week's agenda.

Report of the Inspector General - Andre Birotte, Jr. reported that he also met with Mayor Villaraigosa and Deputy Mayor Alikhan regarding the MacArthur Park incident.  He also met with By Youth, For Youth.  In addition, his office is still in the process of reviewing hours of video from MacArthur Park.

The report creating a preventable traffic collision policy which employs a point count system similar to that of the Los Angeles County Sheriff's Department, was approved.  Commissioner Skobin originally requested the feasibility of this item and he also presented the proposal.  While the new plan will still provide full accountability, it will change some of the ways traffic collisions are reflected on officers' personnel records.

The Department's report relative to the City Controller's audit of fiscal operations of the Los Angeles Police Department was approved for transmittal to the Mayor.  While all recommendations are being addressed in various stages, the most significant will be the creation of an Office of Fiscal Operations that will be at the Bureau level.  This request will be included in the 2008/2009 budget. 

The Department's 2006 Annual Complaint Report was approved.  Police Administrator Maggie Goodrich and Commander Jim Voge presented the report.  It is the first Complaint Report to come out of the new Complaint Management System.  Commissioners commented that the new format was helpful in obtaining more information but asked for further analysis for the “Neglect of Duty” and “Discourtesy” categories.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

At the Police Commission Meeting on May 29, 2007

Commission Business - Commissioner Andrea Sheridan Ordin attended and spoke at the Recruit Graduation on May 25th.  She has also participated in many conversations and meetings related to the agenda.  Commissioner Alan Skobin attended the May 17th rally at MacArthur Park, and also a reserve officer function.  Commissioner Skobin also asked that a future agenda include an update on the hand held radios, addressing the problems with them and the maintenance schedule. Commissioners Anthony Pacheco and Shelley Freeman both stated that they had been involved in various MacArthur Park incident related items.  Commissioner John Mack stated that he has been out of town, however he maintained contact with Chief Bratton regarding the issues related to MacArthur Park.

Chief's Report - Chief William Bratton reported that overall violent crime is down by 7.6% compared to the same time last year, and gang-related crime is down by 23%.  Unfortunately, the Recruitment budget has been reduced, however larger classes continue to fill the Academy.  Commander Kenny Garner commented that the ethnicity among recruits continues to reflect the diversity of the city.

Executive Director's Report - Richard Tefank reported that City Council received and filed the report regarding the additional take-home vehicles for Special Weapons and Tactics, however another report was requested in 60 days on all authorities for take-home vehicles.

A preliminary status report was presented on the MacArthur Park incident on May 1st.  Chief Bratton provided a history of the events that have occurred following May 1st, such as requests for information from City Council, outreach efforts to the community, personnel changes, and addressing of training issues. 

Deputy Chief Mark Perez from Professional Standards Bureau discussed the ongoing Internal Affairs investigation.  At this time, approximately 25 staff members are working on this one investigation.  At this time, there are 23 complaints from the media and 74 other complaints that are being investigated.  Internal Affairs has been providing all requested material to the Federal Bureau of Investigation and the Office of the Inspector General. He stated that they are prepared with Spanish speaking officers for interviews with Spanish speaking individuals.

Commander Joan McNamara, who is leading the investigation addressing the criminal actions of the agitators in the rally, addressed the Commission.  While the preliminary investigation does not reveal any that any pre-planning of rock and bottle-throwing occurred, it is common for activist groups to train for such activity.  Five arrests were made that day.

Police Administrator Gerald Chaleff briefed the Commission on his role as overseer of the incoming law suits related to the May 1st incident.

Assistant Chief McDonald detailed the events that occurred on May 1st minute by minute through a power point presentation.  He reiterated that this investigation is preliminary and that more information may still be outstanding.  Chief McDonnell talked about agitators at different locations who were throwing rocks and bottles at officers. Subsequently, the response to those actions reflected a lack of command and control and a general confusion among officers of who was in charge. Commissioner Mack asked why the 20 or 30 agitators were not originally controlled.  Chief Bratton agreed that was the major question arising from this incident.  He blamed poor communication for much of the breakdown.

Inspector General André Birotte briefed the Commission on his investigation on the May 1st incident.  His office is working very closely with Internal Affairs on all of the incoming complaints.  He currently has eight employees working on the incident.

Captain Kris Pitcher provided an overview of trends of officer involved shootings for the last five years.  There is currently a pitch in the numbers, yet due to the fact that numbers are relatively low, a spike may or may not be reflective of variables. 

Employee News

Management Analyst II Cory Blake has joined Charitable Services Section.  He has been with the City for approximately 19 years, and has worked at the Controller's Office, Public Works - Bureau of Engineering, Public Works - Bureau of Sanitation, along with LAPD at 77th Division and Civil Rights Integrity Division (CRID). Welcome, Cory!

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

At the Police Commission Meeting on May 15, 2007

Commission Business - Commissioner Shelley Freeman participated in meetings and conversations on personnel and staff report issues. Commisisoner Anthony Pacheco met with Deputy Chief Charlie Beck to discuss South Bureau issues, Commander Pat Gannon to discuss gang issues, and Councilmember Jack Weiss to discuss various policing issues. He has also been reviewing numerous tapes reflecting the May 1st incident.  Commissioner Alan Skobin attended the Valley Community Legal Foundation Dinner honoring LAPD Officers, the retreat for the Los Angeles County Police Officers Association, the Chief's Hispanic Forum meeting, the barbecue benefit for Commander Tatreau's family, and five retirement dinners for retiring officers. He also attended and spoke at the Medal of Valor Ceremony and the Annual Memorial Ceremony.  In addition, he met with Captains Baca and McCarthy regarding the Bandit Taxi Task Force, and he followed up this meeting with a ride-along in both the West and Valley Bureau.  Commissioner John Mack stated that he saddened and moved by the memorial service for Commander Tatreau.  He also stated that he has been in constant communication with Chief Bratton since the May 1st incident, and he has participated in numerous related events.

Chief's Report - Chief William Bratton reported that overall violent crime is down by 7% compared to the same time last year, and gang related crimes are down by 3.5%.  He also reminded the audience of the upcoming Explorer Graduation and the Annual Police Celebrity Golf Tournament, both on Saturday, May 19.   Chief Bratton then provided a status report on the investigations related to the May 1st incident. There are currently four internal investigations being conducted. Assistant Chief James McDonnell is leading the investigation which will result in the After Action Report that will be presented to the Police Commission on May 29th.  Deputy Chief Mark Perez is leading the Internal Affairs investigation.  Deputy Chief Mike Downing will be leading the Major Crimes Section's investigation into the causing factors of the incident.  And Police Administrator Gerald Chaleff will be coordinating the claims made against the Department.  The Chief has made a concerted effort to reach out to as many community organizations as possible to provide and receive information. 

Inspector General's Report - Andre Birotte, Jr. reported on the efforts his office is making related to May 1st.  At this point, he has seven investigators working on “outreach and information gathering.” Commissioner Ordin inquired if staffing would become an issue for Mr. Birotte's office, however he felt that the additional responsibilities could be accomplished without compromising the regular workload.

Commissioner Mack stated that all of the Commissioners are extremely concerned about the May 1st incident, however due to Brown Act requirements, he and Commissioner Skobin will be the point people on behalf of the Commission for this issue.

Police Administrator Thom Brennan reported that the life safety improvements in Parker Center are now complete.  In August, structural beams will begin to be placed for the Police Administration Facility.

The report recommending that each SWAT Officer be provided with a take home vehicle was approved.

The Professional Standards Bureau protocol on racial profiling investigations was approved.  The protocol stipulates a higher level of review for each complaint.

Employee News

Management Analyst I Edwin Evangelista has joined the Alarms Section, Commission Investigation Division.  Edwin is a former schoolteacher with the Compton Unified School District where he taught various grades for 15 years.  Welcome, Edwin!

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

At the Police Commission Meeting on May 8, 2007

In observance of the memorial services for Commander James Tatreau, the Commission meeting began at 2:00pm.  Police Commissioner John Mack opened the meeting by forwarding directly to item 8A, the Department’s verbal report and discussion of the police response to demonstrations at MacArthur Park on May 1, 2007.  The Chief outlined the different investigations being conducted, including a 30 day after action report to City Council, an Internal Affairs investigation, the Inspector General’s investigation, and now the Federal Bureau of Investigation will also be doing a preliminary investigation into the incident.  Chief Bratton also talked about personnel changes related to the incident. Deputy Chief Caylor “Lee” Carter has been demoted to Commander and assigned to home, and Commander Lou Grey has been reassigned to Office of Operations.  Commander Sergio Diaz was named the new Deputy Chief for Central Bureau.  Inspector General André Birotte Jr. discussed how his office would complete the investigation and reminded all in attendance that they may call his office at 213 / 202-5866 with any information. Eighty-five individuals spoke who were either at the MacArthur Park incident or who wished to express an opinion about it. 

The report regarding Professional Standards Bureau protocol on racial profiling was continued for one week, as was the Office of the Inspector General’s report relative to the Discipline Report, Fourth Quarter, 2006.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

At the Police Commission Public Hearing on April 30, 2007

The Police Commission provided an opportunity for the public to provide input into the consideration process for a second term for Chief Bratton.  Elected officials, including Mayor Antonio Villaraigosa, Controller Laura Chick, City Attorney Rocky Delgadillo, Sheriff Lee Baca, District Attorney Steve Cooley, and Councilmember Jack Weiss addressed the Commission and offered their strong support for Chief Bratton*s second term. 

Sixty-nine members of the community spoke.  Forty-six individuals supported Chief Bratton stating that he has made great strides in community relations, crime reduction, reform, and public safety in Los Angeles.  Nineteen individuals commented that they would not like to see Chief Bratton re-appointed stating that he has not effectively addressed the gang issue or provided consistent policing to communities of color. Four individuals did not state a definite opinion.

Commission President John Mack thanked the audience for its participation and also thanked those who had chosen to write or e-mail their opinions.

Employee News

Special Investigator II Daysi Ibanez returns to the Office of the Inspector General.  She has worked for the City of Los Angeles since 2003 in several capacities. Daysi is a Navy veteran having served six years.  She recently completed her Master of Business Administration Degree in a problem solution program.

Management Analyst II Sonia Sanchez has joined Commission Investigation Division as the new Adjutant.  She has been with the City for seven years and has worked at the Personnel Department as a Workers Compensation Analyst and also as a Liaison to Cambridge Integrated Services.  As a Management Analyst, Sonia served as an Adjutant at Hollenbeck.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

At the Police Commission Meeting on April 17, 2007

Commission Business: Commissioner Shelley Freeman participated in various personnel-related matters.  Commissioner Anthony Pacheco worked closely with the City Attorney*s office in the presentation of the Gang Injunction Guidelines.  He and Commissioner Mack also participated in the press conference to announce the guidelines.  Alan Skobin attended the Police Officers of Los Angeles County luncheon, the Valley Dispatch Center for a 10:00pm roll call, the Davis Academy for a Police Foundation event as well as a Use of Force meeting, and the West Valley and Foothill stations. Commissioner John Mack, along with Commissioner Ordin, met with Deputy Mayor Arif Alikhan.  Also with Commissioner Ordin, he met with the Independent Monitor for the Consent Decree.  In addition, he attended an Executive Employee Relations Committee meeting, and participated in the Gang Injunction Enforcement Guidelines press conference.

Chief*s Report:  Chief William Bratton reported that total violent crimes are down by 5.7% compared to the same time last year.  In the futue, he will also be presenting gang-related crime statistics monthly at Commission meetings.  Hiring goals are being exceeded as recruit classes are now topping out at 60 and 70 recruits. The inspection and recognition of bike units was well-attended with more than 500 officers from several law enforcement agencies.  While the new taser guns were not approved in the budget, the Department is now looking at video tasers and will be asking for a mid-year budget request.  Chief Bratton expressed his concern with an LA Times editorial that suggested that he is not keeping up his promise of transparency because he is not officially supporting Senate Bill 1019.  He reminded the audience of the Mayoral Directive which prohibits his position from such activity.

Executive Director*s Report:  Richard Tefank reported that item 7a is being continued.  Commissioner Pacheco asked that Mr. Tefank schedule the community relations training presentation.

Inspector General*s Report: André Birotte Jr. participated in a UCLA Law Fellows Program on a *law and government* panel.  He also introduced a new employee: Special Investigator II Teresa Magula.

The Commission presented a certificate of appreciation to Sr. Management Analyst II Saul Romo for seven years of dedicated service to the Police Commission.

The report regarding Flyer Parties was approved.  The Department proposed working with the school district in an effort to educate youth of the dangers of such parties.

The report on decriminalizing the registration process for hotel/motel workers was continued for three weeks.  Several individuals representing the hotel/motel industry spoke stating that it is difficult to maintain employees due to the enforcement of ordinance requirements for guest information.  Department staff stated that this kind of enforcement actually prevents abatement issues later on.

The Commission approved the report on prohibiting the improper disposal of guns and ammunition for transmittal to City Council.  If approved by City Council, this motion would clearly state that guns and ammunition cannot be thrown in the trash.

The report relative to Professional Standards Bureau protocol on racial profiling investigations was continued for one week so that additional concerns could be addressed.  While it is impossible to fully understand what an officer thinks when he or she stops an individual, the Commission felt that the pro