LACP.org
 
.........
PA police mum on motive in disabled woman's death
UPDATED - A tragedy in middle America

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~


Greensburg, PA
  PA police mum on motive in disabled woman's death
UPDATED - A tragedy in middle America

by Dan Nephin

Associated Press

February 13, 2010

GREENSBURG, Pa. (AP) -- Jennifer Daugherty's mom and stepdad didn't press for details when she mentioned she had made some new friends. The 30-year-old had the mental abilities of an adolescent but wasn't the kind to get in trouble, and she was even thinking about getting her own place soon.

Police found her body Thursday stuffed into a garbage can in a school parking lot; they say she had been forced to consume detergent and urine -- and to write a fake suicide note -- before she was fatally stabbed by attackers who also shaved her head and painted her face with nail polish.

Six suspects have been charged, including her new "friends."

 

"She was exploited, and her kindness and her handicap made her very vulnerable," Daugherty's sister, Joy Burkholder, said. "She trusted everybody; she believed everyone was good, and no one would hurt her."

Daugherty's stepfather said she often traveled on her own by bus from her home in Mount Pleasant to Greensburg, about 10 miles away, for dental or counseling appointments. After she hopped onto a bus Monday, she called her folks later in the day seeking permission to spend the night at "Peggy's" house.

It was the last time she would talk to them.

Daugherty went willingly to the apartment where she was killed about 30 miles east of Pittsburgh, according to police, who wouldn't discuss a motive or details on how the visit turned deadly.

She was beaten with a towel rack, vacuum cleaner hose and a crutch, and her body was bound with Christmas decorations, an affidavit said. Police said she was fed vegetable oil, medications and spices in addition to soap and urine.

She was stabbed multiple times with an unknown weapon in the neck, chest and head, Westmoreland County Coroner Kenneth Bacha said. Authorities said they found the victim's belongings in the building's attic, as well as items that had been used to clean up blood.

"She was at the wrong place, at the wrong time, stumbled into a bad situation," said Greensburg Police Chief Walter Lyons.

Six people were charged with criminal homicide, kidnapping and other counts: Robert Loren Masters Jr., 36, Ricky Smyrnes, 23, Melvin Knight, 20, Amber Meidinger, 20, and Angela Marinucci, 17, all of Greensburg; and Peggy Darlene Miller, 27, of Mount Pleasant Township. All were being held without bond in the Westmoreland County prison. Prosecutors didn't know whether any of them had attorneys.

There was already a warrant for Smyrnes' arrest at the time of Daugherty's killing, according to a review Friday of criminal records available online. He was charged Jan. 30 with possessing instruments of crime, but the records don't detail the allegations. He was also awaiting trial on simple assault and harassment charges and pleaded guilty on four occasions to charges ranging from burglary to simple assault, theft and trespassing.

Lyons said he believed Daugherty had "some relationship" with Smyrnes.

Stepfather Bobby Murphy, 62, of Mount Pleasant told The Associated Press that Daugherty had the mental abilities of a 12- to 14-year-old.

Murphy said he was the last family member to see Daugherty alive, on Monday, when he took her to get on the bus to Greensburg. He was not sure with whom Daugherty had an appointment, but said that later that day, she called home and asked about going to her friend Peggy's. Murphy said his stepdaughter planned to return home Tuesday.

Daugherty had become involved in a community center in Greensburg where she met several people whose names she mentioned as friends, Murphy said -- including several whose first names share those of some of the defendants.

"I don't know them personally, but Jennifer mentioned some of their names as being her friends -- but evidently not," he said.

According to an affidavit of probable cause, Knight admitted stabbing Daugherty in the chest, side and neck, and he and Smyrnes carried her body to the parking lot. All six defendants admitted their involvement and implicated others, according to police.

A neighbor in a first-floor apartment reported hearing a "tussle upstairs and a 'heavy bam'" as though a body fell, causing the ceiling to shake before the apartment went quiet Wednesday night, the affidavit said.

Another resident of the first-floor apartment said Smyrnes and two women came to their apartment afterward, and that the man asked them to turn their television down, the affidavit said.

The neighbors, Floria Headen and Angela McGowan, said that people frequently came and went from the apartment and that they had called police about a half-dozen times to complain.

"They was coming in droves. You didn't know who was living there," McGowan said. "It was unreal. All the noise and the pounding and the fighting and the drinking, you thought the ceiling was going to come in on you."

A man found Daugherty's body Thursday morning when he saw the garbage can partly beneath his truck.

Headen has since learned that the Christmas lights police said were used to bind Daugherty had been taken from her porch. The garbage container in which her body was found belongs to Headen's daughter, who lives several houses away, she said.

"I'm in shock, and I'm angry," McGowan said. "I'm angry and it's like you want to cry because that poor child was tortured."

Burkholder described her sister as kind and said she liked scary movies, wrestling and college football.

Daugherty's family moved to Mount Pleasant from Mesquite, Texas, about two years ago to be closer to Murphy's mother-in-law, who is ill, Murphy said.

"One thing I can tell you is there is no reason for them to do what they did to Jennifer," Murphy said. "Jennifer was just a gentle, laid-back person.

"There wasn't a mean bone in her body."

EDITOR'S NOTE: Here is an
UPDATE on this story, along with links to several VIDEOS relateed to it"

Greensburg suspect's mental capacity uncertain

By Rich Cholodofsky and Bob Stiles
TRIBUNE-REVIEW

Wednesday, February 17, 2010

Pittsburg Tribune-Review

The attorney for one of six Greensburg residents charged with the torture and murder of a mentally challenged woman last week said his client doesn't have the mental capacity to understand what he was confessing to.

Ricky Smyrnes, 23, was in court Tuesday and detained on two outstanding arrest warrants in unrelated criminal cases during the last two years. Court-appointed defense attorney Scott Avolio said that now, four days after Smyrnes confessed to police, his client contends it was another defendant who killed 30-year-old Jennifer Lee Daugherty of Greensburg.

Police found Daugherty's body on Thursday, stuffed in a trash can that was left in the parking lot of Greensburg Salem Middle School on Main Street.

A day later, police charged Smyrnes; Amber Meidinger, 20; Robert Loren Masters Jr., 36; Melvin Knight, 20; Peggy Darlene Miller, 27; and Angela Marinucci, a 17-year-old Greensburg Salem High School senior, with criminal homicide and related offenses.

Police said Daugherty died after more than 33 hours of torture at the hands of "friends" she told her family she was visiting in Greensburg.

"He is portraying his innocence related to this crime and saying it was all Masters' doing," Avolio said. "I think with his mental health and mental retardation, he was possibly under the influence of other individuals and was easily coerced and confused into making statements to police."

Police said all six defendants gave statements in which all were implicated in Daugherty's torture and death in a North Pennsylvania Avenue apartment.

Smyrnes was in court yesterday for two detainer hearings. Westmoreland County Judges John Blahovec and Debra Pezze yesterday revoked Smyrnes' parole on a burglary conviction in 2008 for assaulting his wife with a furnace door and a 2009 burglary case in which he stole $530 and a laptop computer from a drop-in center for mentally challenged youths.

Court records indicate that in October Pezze revoked Smyrnes' parole from a two- to 23 month-sentence. He was in the Westmoreland County Prison until Jan. 21, when he was released to a halfway house in Mt. Pleasant for mental health patients. Court officials said yesterday they don't know when Smyrnes left the program and returned to Greensburg.

Meanwhile, a prosecutorial tug-of-war is developing between the U.S. Attorney Office and the Westmoreland County district attorney.

Acting U.S. Attorney Robert Cessar said yesterday his office is reviewing the case under a new federal law signed in October by President Obama under which federal prosecutors would have to prove that the violence was "directly related to the victim's disability" in order for it to qualify as a hate crime.

"But I want to stress, first and foremost, the prosecution of this case remains before Westmoreland County District Attorney John Peck at this point," Cessar said. "We're a long way off from making any such determination."

Under the federal act, sentences could include life in prison or even the death penalty.

Peck said he was contacted yesterday by federal authorities, but at this time he does not intend to turn over the case.

Peck said any decision about the death penalty will come after a detailed investigation is completed.

Police believe the six suspects shaved Daugherty's head and painted her face with nail polish; fed her urine, detergent, medication, spices and vegetable oil; and beat her with a towel rack, a vacuum hose and a crutch before Knight stabbed her in the chest, side and neck. Her wrists were cut, and her body was wrapped in Christmas lights before it was put in the trash can.

The brutal nature of the crime drew strong reaction from the public. Several people have called the district attorney's office to urge Peck to seek the death penalty.

"I think it's just such a horrible thing that has happened in a small community," said Courtney Kissell of Greensburg, who set up a Facebook page that had more than 2,200 members yesterday. "Nobody should go through that. It has horrified our little town. She was so helpless."

Kissell is organizing a candlelight vigil in memory of Daugherty outside the courthouse Saturday night.

Another Facebook page, "R.I.P. Jennifer Daugherty," had more than 14,000 members yesterday.

Stephen Smolleck of Greensburg has launched a Web site called "Justice for Jen." He and about five others marched outside the courthouse yesterday with signs supporting the death penalty. They hope to hold another rally Saturday.

Cesare Muccari, Greensburg Hempfield Area Library librarian, where the victim and all six suspects used computers to update their Facebook pages, said patrons can't stop talking about the crime.

"Everybody's horrified about it," he said.

Gary Baum, manager of Cook's Market, said people are talking about the brutality of the crime as they wait for sandwiches in his South Pennsylvania Avenue business. He said he recognized some of the suspects as customers.

The suspects frequented downtown Greensburg, visiting the library, thrift shops, a community center for the mentally ill and restaurants.

Amy Davis, an employee at Bortz Hardware, said many patrons discuss the murder at the cash register.

"Mostly it's about what a shame it is," Davis said

http://www.pittsburghlive.com/x/pittsburghtrib/news/westmoreland/print_667558.html


.

RELATED VIDEOS:

Here's a news broadcast ...
KTAE-TV News
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6LbLQS3tegQ

Comments from the family ...
KDKA-TV News
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=D7ta2QsMVuc&feature=related

Feds Review Greensburg Torture Death As Disability Hate Crime ...
KTAE-TV News
tp://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1dXat0g7s3M


http://www.miamiherald.com/news/nation/AP/story/1478205.html