~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

LOS ANGELES POLICE COMMISSION

NEWS BRIEFINGS

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

At the Police Commission Meeting on December 9, 2008

Report of the Chief - Chief William Bratton reported on recent crime statistics.  All crime is down compared to this time last year. Total violent crime is down by 4.8%.  Commissioner Ordin commented that she attended the Women's Recruitment Fair at the Ahmanson Training Center and was very impressed with the enthusiasm and professionalism displayed by all of the participants.

Report of the Executive Director - Richard Tefank reported that the October Commission Activity Report was included for Commissioner review. He also reminded all that there will be no Police Commission meetings on December 23rd or 30th.

Report of the Inspector General - Andre Birotte, Jr. was pleased to describe a presentation to his office from Pasadena Police Chief Bernard Melekian regarding how his department mediates complaints.  Mr. Birotte thanked Lt. I Valerie Thomas for her outstanding work as his Aide, and introduced Sgt. II Luis Bravo, who will be filling her position.

Commander Kirk Albanese reviewed how the LAPD deploys officers and how the plan will now include the two new stations, Topanga and Olympic. The “Patrol Plan” has worked for deployment purposes since the 1980's as it incorporates desirable goals such as a seven minute or less response time, and time allotment for community work. The plan uses 25 factors to determine the appropriate number of officers per area to achieve the goals.  It has been determined that each new station will require 75 new authorities to fill the fixed post positions.  Given the fact the entire City is not able to fill many positions due to budgetary issues, the positions are being filled with individuals from other Divisions and Areas throughout the City.  Chief Bratton added that while it is difficult to fill positions at this time, the Department has more than 600 officers than when he first arrived, and he expects full deployment by the end of 2010.

Police Administrator Maggie Goodrich and Chief Information Officer Tim Riley presented the six month update of the In-Car Video Camera System. At this time cameras have been fully installed in the patrol cars at Southeast Area and a successful test with 20 cars simultaneously downloading has been completed.  Ms. Goodrich stated that she will be returning with the needed policies regarding the cameras: how to use the system, and how to audit the use of the system.  The Commissioners asked that a calendar be submitted outlining the installation and activation plan for the cameras.

Deputy Chief Michel Moore presented how the LAPD responded and assisted with the recent Sylmar area fires.  He described the immensity of the fires and immediate and efficient response of the Department in evacuating thousands of people from their homes.  He noted that a reverse 911 system is would assist greatly.  Chief Moore was commended for his own heroic efforts in saving lives during the fires.

Commander Rick Webb presented the report relative to the Professional Standards Bureau, Biased Policing Protocols.  He discussed the fact that officers are now being asked to articulate their complete reasons for conducting traffic and pedestrian stops.  He is also working on the possibility of complaint mediation, however the cost of this process is a problem at this time. As this issue will be back to the Commission on January 13th meeting, Commissioner Saltzman suggested that all reports be available one week prior to the meeting and the community leaders be advised.

New Employees

Detective II Dollie Swanson has joined Commission Investigation Division.  She has 14 years with LAPD and has worked at  Harbor, Wilshire, Tactical Planning Section, Uniformed Support Division (where she worked the Noise Enforcement Team before it was absorbed by the Police Commission),  Planning and Research Division,  Central,  77th, and Gangs and Operations Support Division.

Management Assistant Marlene Morgenstern has been with the City since 2003.  She is now joining Charitable Service Section, and she has previously worked at Los Angeles World Airports (LAWA), Human Resources Division, and at LAPD's Training Division/Career Development Unit.

Sergeant II Luis Bravo has joined the Office of the Inspector in the position of Aide.  He has been with LAPD for 15 years and has worked at Wilshire Patrol, Van Nuys Patrol/CRASH, Rampart Patrol, Foothill Patrol, Metro Jail Section, Transit Bus, Newton Patrol, Newton Gangs, Newton Crime Surveillance Team, Newton Complaint Unit, and as Newton's Consent Decree Coordinator, Adjutant, and Training Coordinator.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

At the Police Commission Meeting on November 26, 2008

Commissioner Rob Saltzman commended the Department for the way in which the Proposition 8 demonstrations were handled.  He also felt that the recent GLBT Community Forum was very productive and addressed important, timely issues in a positive manner.

Report of the Chief - Assistant Chief McDonnell attended the Chaplain's Banquet, the LA LEY holiday party, the Department's SOAR retreat, and the LA BEST program at City Hall.  He also commented that more than 15,000 children attended the Children's Day celebration in the Valley, and he commended Deputy Chief Michel Moore for this event.  Crime statistics continue to decrease.  Total violent crime is down 5.2%, compared to this time last year.

Report of the Executive Director - Richard Tefank stated that there will be no Police Commission meetings on December 2nd, 23rd, or 30th.

Report of the Inspector General - Andre Birotte, Jr. attended the SOAR retreat, the GLBT Forum, and enjoyed the Children's Day celebration in the Valley.

Deputy Chief Charlie Beck presented an overview of Detective Bureau. Approximately 2,500 people work in this Bureau, and they are roughly divided in half between area detective sections and specialized units. The specialized units include Commercial Crimes, Detective Support Vice Division, Gang and Narcotics Division, Juvenile Division, RACR, Robbery Homicide, and Scientific Investigation Division. 

Deputy Chief Charlie Beck and Police Administrator Gerald Chaleff discussed the creation and status of the Scientific Investigation Division Task Force.  This group was formulated last month to address efficiency issues in all categories of SID, but will initially focus on the DNA backlog of rape kits and the accuracy of the latent fingerprinting process.  One of the initial findings show that the ratio of supervisors to employees is low in SID, which is a budgetary issue. A database is being developed of the rape kits which will allow a more comprehensive way of prioritizing their processing.  Status reports to the Commission from this task force will be ongoing.

The results of the Firearms Inventory Tracking Audit were generally positive with the exception of a time lag between when firearms are returned to the Department after there is an employee separation. Deputy Chief Sandy Jo MacArthur stated that this is being remedied as Personnel Division will now be returning the firearms on a regular schedule.

Captain Ann Young and Lt. Lionel Garcia presented a status report on the Mental Evaluation Unit.  Much progress has been made in terms of promoting individuals which has helped in retaining experienced personnel.  The operation is not yet available 24 hours per day as this move is a meet and confer item.  Commissioner Pacheco expressed his interest in assisting with this issue as he feels that MEU needs to operate on a 24 hour basis.

The Commission approved the report for the City Council on Hate Crimes. Commissioner Saltzman added that hate crimes remain a concern in the GLBT community, and suggested that the Chief's Community Forums be included in the dissemination of information from the Hate Crimes Unit.

The Inspector General's report and the Department's report relative to the Ethics Enforcement Section's Quarterly Report, Second Quarter 2008, were approved.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

At the Police Commission Meeting on November 18, 2008

This Police Commission meeting was devoted to the Safer Cities Initiative in the Skid Row area.  Commissioner Andrea Sheridan Ordin, who has been intricately involved with this issue, stated that she was thankful to all who have worked diligently in improving the quality of life for all residents in this area. 

Council Member Jan Perry spoke about some of the accomplishments in the area, as well as some of the challenges.  She stated that much remains to be done and that the only way to achieve success in this area is address all of the issues, not just the law enforcement aspect.

Deputy Mayor Arif Alikhan stated that there had been a 40% reduction in violent crime and that there are 1,200 less people sleeping on Skid Row since the beginning of the Safer City Initiative in 2006.  He also highlighted the need for additional assistance from federal, state and county governments.

Chief Assistant City Attorney Jeff Isaacs presented a status report on the Safer Cities Initiative.  He described one of the most disturbing situations, which was the occurrence of patient dumping into the Skid Row area by hospitals.  The City Attorney's Office has been successful in obtaining settlements with several hospitals to end this practice.

Several community organizations were invited by the Police Commission to speak at the meeting, including the American Civil Liberties Union, the Central City Association, the Central City East Association, the Downtown Women's Center, the Historic Downtown BID, LA CAN, LAMP Community, the Law Office of Carol Sobel, the Midnight Mission, Para Los Ninos, Project 50, Public Law Counsel, Skid Row Housing Trust, UCLA School of Law, Union Rescue Mission and the Weingart Center Association. Some organizations expressed serious concern over the impact of concentrated law enforcement in the area, and some organizations expressed appreciation for the increased law enforcement presence.

A number of people also spoke during the public comment portion of the agenda.  The majority of these individuals did not support the Safer Cities Initiative due to the increased law enforcement presence.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

At the Police Commission Meeting on November 4, 2008

Report of the Chief - Chief William Bratton reported that all crime categories are down compared to this time last year, including violent crimes, property crimes and gang-related crimes.  There was a crime up-tick in the South Bureau over the weekend and additional forces are being moved into the area to immediately address the issue. 

Commissioner Andrea Sheridan Ordin commended Assistant Chief Sharon Papa on her work in presenting the Annual Womens Conference. Commissioner Ordin noted that it has grown each year and has become a very popular and motivating event for all staff.

Report of the Executive Director - Richard Tefank noted that there will be no Police Commission meeting next week in observance of Veterans Day. He also noted a correction to agenda item #10A1.

Report of the Inspector General - André Birotte reported that the Office of the Inspector General actively participated in the National Association of Civilian Oversight for Law Enforcement (NACOLE) annual conference.  Mr. Birotte will serve as the President of NACOLE in the coming year.  He also announced the promotion of his adjutant, Sergeant Valencia Thomas to Lieutenant.

Police Officer III + I Deborah Nichols was named the Police Commission October 2008 Employee of the Month.  Officer Nichols is an outstanding employee who balances her numerous duties as Security Aide to the Police Commissioners along with assisting Commission Investigation Division in enforcement activities.  She is always willing to assist her co-workers and help out on any project.

The report on Unlawful Search Investigations was approved.  Eleven of the 51 cases reviewed raised some concerns during the investigation. The item will return in 90 days for additional review.

The first Racial Profiling Quarterly Report was rescheduled for December 9, however an overview was provided by Commander Rick Webb.  He stated that much of the specific protocols are complete, such as changing terminology and detailed allegations of discourtesy.  He added that the mediation component may be more difficult than initially thought due to the sheer number of complaints.  However, efforts are being made to continue with the mediation process for racial profiling complaints.

The Office of the Inspector General's and the Department's Discipline Reports for the Second Quarter of 2008, were approved.  For this report, the Inspector General's Office focused on two areas: false statements and out of statute cases.  In both reviews, the Department did well overall, with minor concerns.  Commander Rick Webb reported that the issue of statutes will be included in overall quarterly training on the discipline process starting in 2009. Commissioners expressed concern over the fact that some categorical use of force cases have not been noted on TEAMS II reports.  Mr. Birotte stated that he had spoken with Police Administrator Maggie Goodrich, and she believed this was an input issue.  The Commissioners asked that the entity responsible for the inputting of these cases present a report to the Commission on the corrective steps that are being taken.

Commissioner Rob Saltzman explained that he asked that item 8C, the Policy Against Discrimination in Employment Based on Sexual Orientation, Gender Identity or Gender Expression, be continued, so that he may work with the Department on suggestions he has for language for the policy.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

At the Police Commission Meeting on October 28, 2008

Report of the Chief - Chief William Bratton thanked the Police Commissioners for attending the 30 Year Pin Ceremony and expressed his appreciation to all of the recipients who have dedicated their career to the Los Angeles Police Department.  He reported on the crime statistics: total violent crimes are down by 4.7% compared to this time last year. Last week, Chief Bratton was in New York at the Homeland Security Roundtable, where strategies are being formulated for the next administration.  He was also pleased to announce the upcoming Women's Conference, which will be attended by several Police Commissioners.

Executive Administrative Assistant III Mary Helen Ayala was honored by the Police Commission and Chief Bratton for her 45 years of outstanding service.

Police Administrator Gerald Chaleff and Deputy Chief Charlie Beck outlined the creation of the Scientific Investigation Division Task Force.  While all of SID will be reviewed for efficiency and productivity, priorities will be placed on the issue of backlogged DNA sexual assault kits and latent fingerprinting.  Primary and secondary members have already met and have begun to strategize.  Council Member Jack Weiss thanked Chief Bratton and the Police Commissioners for their consistent emphasis on this issue.  He also advised that City Council would be meeting the following day to hopefully approve funding for 16 new employees to work in the Scientific Investigation Division Crime Lab.

The South Bureau and the Newton Area Gang Enforcement Detail Command Accountability Performance Audits were both approved, however the Commissioners expressed concern over the relatively low compliance rates.  New personnel was listed as one of the causes of the low compliance rates.  Staff assured that these issues would be resolved.

Captain Kevin McClure and Police Administrator Gerald Chaleff presented an in-depth report on the status of the Hunter-La Ley Consent Decree. Generally, the Department is making progress in terms of promoting minority and female officers, however the promotions do not exactly mirror the population of the City of Los Angeles.  And, more extreme disparities can occur within certain divisions for various reasons. Commissioner Pacheco asked that Police Commission meetings serve as a forum for the various employee organizations to express their thoughts, and that it would be helpful if more organizations attended the meetings when Hunter-La Ley is an agenda item.  Sgt. Ronnie Cato, from the Oscar Joel Bryant Association, suggested the possibility of making the Hunter-La Ley statistics part of the COMPSTAT process, and Chief Bratton agreed that the idea was intriguing. The item was received and filed.

Lt. Rick Dedmon presented an overview of training provided to outside law enforcement agencies by Force Investigation Division (FID).  This Division has gained national notoriety in the way it investigates officer involved shootings, which led to numerous inquiries from outside agencies.  A quarterly, POST-certified training program was developed by the staff of FID.  Officers from numerous local and national law enforcement agencies have participated in the 24 hour training.  FID staff was praised by the Police Commissioners and the Chief for the outstanding work that is produced there, and for sharing the expertise in the law enforcement community.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

At the Police Commission Community Meeting on October 20, 2008

Commission President Anthony Pacheco called the meeting to order and briefed the audience on some recent newsworthy events.  He commented on the issue of a small number of fingerprints being processed incorrectly in the past.  This is an extremely serious issue and Commissioner Pacheco outlined several steps which the Department is taking to remedy the problem, including the creation of a task force and obtaining advice and guidance from the Federal Bureau of Investigation.  Commissioner Pacheco stated that he learned of this issue in the media, but feels well-briefed on the issue now as Chief Bratton and command staff  have provided a great deal of information.

Commissioner Pacheco also discussed the release of City Controller Laura Chick's report on the status of the backlog of DNA rape kits. The Police Commission welcomed this report as this item has been a Commission priority for a long time.  That morning, Commissioner Pacheco met with a representative from Human Rights Watch to obtain that organization's input on the issue also.

Also occurring on this day, is the release of a report on racial profiling at LAPD by the American Civil Liberties Union.  Commissioners Anthony Pacheco and John Mack met with the ACLU to discuss the report. Both remain convinced that cameras in the patrol cars will assist greatly in determining if racial profiling is occurring, or not.

Commissioner Pacheco thanked Professor Chris Cameron and Events Manager John Kohler for their gracious hospitality in making the Southwestern Law School available for the meeting.

Council Member Herb Wesson welcomed the Police Commission and commended the Commissioners on the work they do.  He also welcomed the large number of people attending and thanked them for taking their time to come out and be a part of the meeting.

Report of the Chief - Chief William Bratton reported that total violent crime is down by 4.7% compared to this time last year.  He also reported on the newsworthy events previously mentioned and added actions that the Department is taking to address them.  He also discussed the allegation of Mr. Muira's attorney that his death was actually a murder, instead of a suicide.  Chief Bratton stated that he was confident that this allegation is not true.

Report of the Executive Director - Richard Tefank briefly outlined his role at the Los Angeles Police Commission and the responsibilities associated with the Commission including the issuance and enforcement of 53 Police Permits.  The Commission is also responsible for charitable giving regulation in the City of Los Angeles, along with the enforcement of parking lot permits.

Report of the Inspector General - André Birotte discussed the creation and growth of the Office of Inspector General.  At this time, his office investigates and audits complaints, conducts independent audits, and reviews and makes independent recommendations on use of force cases.

Captain III John Egan provided an overview of the Rampart Area.  The new station, which just recently opened, is considered to be a“green” building.  Part One Crimes have decreased by 44% in the last six years in the Rampart Area.  Captain Egan attributed this decrease to the station's area-specific approach of the “Broken Windows Theory.”  Rampart also embraces several community partnership programs including an active Community Police Advisory Board, a Police Activities League, an 18-week Juvenile Impact Prevention Program (for both teens and parents), an Explorer program, and a Clergy Council.

President Pacheco introduced the Police Commissioners: Andrea Sheridan Ordin, Alan Skobin, Vice President John W. Mack, and Robert Saltzman.

Public Comment - Several individuals spoke to the Police Commissioners. Topics ranged from concern, both positive and negative, over the recently released racial profiling report from the American Civil Liberties Union, praise for community policing efforts, and specific community issues.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

At the Regular Police Commission Meeting on October 14, 2008

Commission Comments: Commissioners commented on the upcoming Police Commission Community Meeting on October 20th at Southwestern Law School, praised the LAPD on the outstanding collaborative public safety work being accomplished in fighting the fires, and updated the audience on the approval and purchase of Astro radios.  City Council has now approved the purchase of 9,300 Astro radios.  On the same day, a purchase order was produced for 4,650 radios.  When those radios are in place, another purchase order will be made for the remainder. Commissioner Pacheco thanked Commissioner Skobin for his leadership on this issue.

Report of the Chief - Chief William Bratton reported that total violent crime is down by 4.7% compared to this time last year.  Chief Bratton was in New York last week and participated in several meetings and events, including the Police Executive Research Forum Crime Conference, the equivalent of a COMPSTAT presentation at the FBI, and briefings at the National Counter Terrorism Center.  Captain Joan McNamara will actually be stationed at that Center for the next few months, and return with the objective of setting up that kind of operation at LAPD.

Report of the Executive Director - Richard Tefank reported that in light of the Police Commission Community Meeting on Monday, October 20th, the regular Police Commission meeting on Tuesday, October 21st, is cancelled.

Report of the Inspector General - André Birotte reported that he pleased to participate in the Chief's Muslim Community Forum.

Both Command Accountability Performance Audits from Central and Devonshire Areas, were approved.  Devonshire Area was commended on receiving a 100% compliance rate.  Lt. Michael O'Donnell attributed this success to the staff, both civilian and sworn, who work in Devonshire.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

At the Regular Police Commission Meeting on October 7, 2008

Commission Comments: Commissioner Andrea Sheridan Ordin announced that there will be a Police Commission meeting devoted to issues related to the Safer Cities Initiative on Skid Row on November 18th, at Parker Center.  Commissioner John Mack noted the nice event presented by the La Ley Educational Foundation which honored Police Commissioner Alan Skobin and Mayor Antonio Villaraigosa.

Report of the Chief - Assistant Chief James McDonnell also commented on the La Ley event and on the Target America Exhibit.  Total violent crime is down by 4.8% compared to this time last year. 

Deputy Chief Mark Perez reviewed the disciplinary process.  He stated that there is no change whatsoever in the way in which complaints are accepted by the Department.  That aspect has not changed in 20 years. While the new process stresses strategy before penalty, it in no way means that discipline should be viewed as diminished or light.  When discipline is appropriate, it is administered.  He stressed that each case is reviewed with all factors, including background history, thoroughly.  Some of the changes include the creation of an “Official Conditional Reprimand,” which is signed by the Chief of Police, and the fact that Board of Rights members now know if an individual is being recommended for termination versus being sent to the Board for suspension. The results of the new approach are difficult to quantify, however changes in the Quarterly Discipline Reports should soon reflect some qualitative changes.  Deputy Chief Perez will return with regular status reports on this process.

The review of the follow-up report to the Hunter-La Ley Fiscal Year 2007-08 Fourth Quarter Report was continued to allow employee organizations to review the material also.

Captain Ann Young and Dr. Luann Pannell presented a status report on the Autism Awareness Training.  At this point, approximately 700 personnel have received the live roll call training and 8,000 have received the training through E-learning.  Through interest in this program and the topic, the Autism Support Group has been developed and is now meeting regularly.  The goals of the group are to provide education and support for employees who have family members with Autism, and to assist with the Department-wide training effort.  Commissioner Skobin acknowledged Commissioner Pacheco's efforts in expanding this important training.

Police Administrator Thom Brennan presented an update on all police construction projects.  The new headquarters facility will be ready for occupancy in July, 2009.

Police Administrators Gloria Grube and D'Anna Markley presented a status report on the Processing Time for Traffic Collision Reports.  The unfortunate length of time to process traffic reports is attributed to a lack of resources.  There is an increase of vacancies in this area and the overtime budget has been decreased.  Commissioner Pacheco and Skobin will continue to work with staff on this issue.

The Inspector General's and the Department's reports on both Categorical and Non-Categorical Use of Force Investigation Audits, was continued.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

At the Regular Police Commission Meeting on September 29, 2008

Commission Comments: President Pacheco invited all to join the Commission for the community meeting on October 20th at Southwestern Law School.

Report of the Chief - Assistant Chief Earl Paysinger reported on the weekly crime statistics.  Part I crime is down by 4.3% compared to this time last year.  Violent crime is down by 4.8%.   President Pacheco praised the men and women of the Department on the continued decrease in crime and Commissioner Ordin added her congratulations on the successful recruitment fair.

Report of the Executive Director - Richard Tefank reported that Commission Investigation Division's monthly activity report was submitted for review.

The Commission approved the Police Administrator II position for the COMPSTAT Group.  While the City is facing difficulties in terms of funding positions, it was agreed that this position was a public safety priority.

The correspondence was approved for transmittal to the Public Safety Committee regarding DNA grants.  Police Administrator Laura Filatoff explained that this correspondence reflected the presentation previously made to the Commission.  Since then, progress has been made in terms of fundraising toward eliminating the rape kit DNA backlog.

The Incidents Involving Persons Suspected of Suffering from Mental Illness Field Notebook Divider, was approved.  Captain Ann Young explained that this reference material will be presented on the LAN and in roll calls.  It creates a standard for all officers on how to work with individuals suffering from mental illness.

The Request for Proposals for the Valley Bureau Wireless Camera Surveillance System was approved.  The request includes 46 cameras for four Valley stations.  The cameras generally have a good history of reducing crime in installed areas.  These cameras would actually be movable allowing for crime reduction in various areas.  Commissioner Mack and Commissioner Skobin will be monitoring the progress of the cameras in terms of their success and also in terms of future uses and privacy issues.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

At the Regular Police Commission Meeting on September 23, 2008

Report of the Chief - Chief William Bratton  reported on the weekly crime statistics.  All Part I crime is down compared to this time last year.  Violent crime is down by 5.2%, and property crime is down by 4.4%.  Hiring of new recruits is continuing as scheduled to meet all goals.

Report of the Inspector General - André Birotte, Jr. reported that he was pleased to speak to a class at Loyola Law School regarding his role as Inspector General.

Mission Area Community Police Advisory Board Co-Chairs Melanie McShane and Captain Jorge Villegas presented the Area's annual report.  Mission Area is proud to maintain the lowest crime rates in the Valley. Ms. McShane reported that Mission CPAB is quite active and all members take pride in their accomplishments including the newly-developed Community Resource Guide for new officers, the active use of e-mail trees, the Sylmar Juvenile Task Force, Project Amigo and numerous youth programs.  As all CPABs have reported, the Mission Area would like to attract new members.  Ongoing education for all CPAB members has provided great experiences such as a bus tour of the area, a trip to the Police Historical Society, and a briefing on Anti-Terrorism efforts at LAPD.

Captain Kevin McClure and Police Administrator Gerald Chaleff presented the Audit Recommendation Status Report, First Quarter, 2008/2009.  They were pleased to say that the Consent Decree items continue to be closed out and that a great deal of progress has been made.  The audits are monitored constantly and only 43 items remain open.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

At the Regular Police Commission Meeting on September 16, 2008

The meeting was opened with a moment of silence in memory of Police Officer III Spree Desha, who perished in the Metrolink train crash.

Commission Business - All Police Commissioners expressed sadness and their deepest condolences to the families of the victims of the Metrolink train crash.  Praise was given to the responders who worked tirelessly to assist victims in the aftermath of this horrific tragedy.

Report of the Chief - Chief William Bratton announced the funeral arrangements for Officer Desha.  Her service will be held at Cathedral of Our Lady of Angels on the morning of September 18th.  Chief Bratton was on the east coast last week where he addressed a Congressional Committee on the topic of Weapons of Mass Destruction.  He also attended the Service America conference which highlights how Americans can, and do, give back to their communities.  He used the Explorer program at LAPD as an example of how Los Angeles teens give back to their city.  He also attended an evening concert at MacArthur Park and commented on the remarkable positive change that has occurred in the area due to focused efforts.

Assistant Chief Sharon Papa, Police Administrator Laura Filatoff, and Police Administrator Yvette Sanchez-Owens provided a verbal update on the DNA grants and DNA processing backlog.   At this time, there are 7,200 DNA rape kits that have not been examined.  Grants are used to supplement the needed funding to eliminate the backlog.  A recent Department of Justice grant was reduced because the previous year's grant had not been sufficiently used.  It was explained that work on the backlog cases had never stopped and that the funds were not spent because invoices for the work had not been received at that time.  It was proposed that the backlog could be eliminated by 2013 with $4.5 million.  Commissioner Ordin pointed out that the Police Foundation has expressed a specific interest in raising funds for this issue, which could help in reaching goal of elimination.  Councilmember Jack Weiss added his concern over this issue and has placed it on the Public Safety Committee agenda every week.  Chief Bratton stated that the entire Department is facing a difficult time because 700 civilian positions are authorized yet they are not funded.  The Commission asked that this item be brought back regularly for progress reports.

Deputy Chief Sandy Jo McArthur, Police Administrator Gerald Chaleff and Deputy Mark Perez presented the current status of personnel complaints relative to the May 1, 2007, MacArthur park incident, and the status of recommendations contained in the Department report “An Examination of May Day 2007.”   At this time, there are 320 plaintiffs against the City of Los Angeles related to this incident.  All 23 recommendations from the report “An Examination of May Day 2007,” have been implemented, including the creation of the Critical Incident Management Bureau, Mobile Field Force Training for the entire Department, identifiable helmet covers, and sound vehicles.  Deputy Chief Perez stated that twenty-nine officers were charged with one or more allegations, for a combined total of 80 allegations.  The Chief of Police sustained 31 allegations against 15 officers.  Among the officers disciplined, three will also receive a reduction in paygrade and four will be transferred from Metropolitan Division.   Three officers will receive Official Reprimands, five officers will be suspended for three days, two officers will be suspended for five days, one officer will be suspended for 10 days, and four officers were directed to a Board of Rights with a  recommendation for termination.  Commission members commended the Chief and command staff on the level of investigation into this incident.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

At the Regular Police Commission Meeting on September 9, 2008

Commission Business - Commissioner Robert Saltzman spoke with Carol Pankow from the Domestic Violence Task Force.  He and Commissioner Ordin met with Inspector General André Birotte to discuss specific cases. Commissioner Saltzman also met with Assistant Chief Paysinger to discuss various issues.  Commissioner Alan Skobin met with personnel from Motor Transport Division regarding the use of Harley Davidson motorcycles.  He also attended events sponsored by the La Ley Educational Foundation and the Los Angeles Police Protective League.  Commissioner Andrea Sheridan Ordin also mentioned the meeting with the Inspector General regarding specific cases.  She also met with Jeff Isaacs from the City Attorney's Office regarding the Safer Cities Initiative in the Skid Row area, and anticipates that issue to be on an upcoming Police Commission agenda. Related to the Skid Row issue, she had a conversation with Pete White from the Los Angeles Community Action Network.  She was pleased to attend the Hispanic National Bar Association meeting and see Chief Bratton participate in a panel entitled, “Gangs in LA.” Commissioner John Mack and Commissioner Ordin attended the grand opening of the new Rampart Area.  He was very impressed with the new building and the enhanced relationship with the community.  Commissioner Mack also participated in the press conference announcing the results of the Summer Night Lights program, which by all counts was a success. 

Report of the Executive Director - Senior Management Analyst II Eva Vega reported that items 7K and 7M have been pulled from the agenda and item 8C has been continued.

Report of the Inspector General -  André Birotte reported that he was pleased to meet with Commissioners Ordin and Saltzman to discuss some cases.

Report of the Chief - First Assistant Chief James McDonnell reported the opening of the new Rampart Area allows all Rampart personnel to work together again.  As the previous building was small, detectives worked at another location.  Recently, a group of children from the Sunshine Kids Foundation spent a day with LAPD.  They were made honorary police officers and a good time was had by all.  Chief McDonnell reported that the crime statistics continue to reflect decreases.  Overall violent crime is down by 5.6% compared to this time last year.

Captain William Scott and Detective Jose Ceja presented the follow-up information regarding the Foreign Language and TDD Audit.  Captain Scott stated that his staff inquired if locations, such as Traffic Divisions, receive calls that need TDD assistance, and the answer is no. Therefore, they do not recommend the installing TDD machines at these locations.  The Language Audit is consistently a part of the COMPSTAT process.  It is difficult to determine if any complaints have been either generated from TDD calls or have been about the equipment regarding TDD calls, as the complaint tracking system does not identity this category.  The Department is currently looking into the use of translation devices, yet there remains many concerns.  There are currently 170 languages identified in the “Language Bank,” which officers can refer to telephonically to assist individuals. Commissioner Saltzman commended the research that had been accomplished on this item and recommended that it be continued for 60 days to allow for a meeting with Richard Ray from the Department on Disability.

Employee News

Will Ortiz has promoted from Detective I to Detective II in the Commission Investigation Division. Congratulations, Will!

Detective I Kirk Kelley has joined Commission Investigation Division, Enforcement Section.  Detective Kelley has been with the Department for 10 years and has worked at Foothill, Hollywood, Mission, Devonshire, and Van Nuys Divisions.  Welcome, Kirk! 

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

At the Regular Police Commission Meeting on August 19, 2008

Commission Business - Commissioner Andrea Sheridan Ordin participated in a meeting with the Inspector General and command staff regarding the Safer Cities Initiatives and pro-bono groups in Skid Row.  Commissioner Alan Skobin met with personnel from Detective Support Vice Division regarding the hotel enforcement ordinance and crime issues related to it. He attended the “Twice a Citizen,” annual dinner honoring the Department's Reserve Corp.  He met with Antonio Sanchez from the Mayor's Valley Office, and attended the SWAT Family and Friends open house event, along with the retirement dinner for Captain Ron Eutsey. Commissioner Robert Saltzman was out of town last week, but found it helpful to have the extra time to thoroughly prepare for the agenda items today.  He also participated in discussions regarding the Domestic Violence Task Force as it relates to the Gay, lesbian, Bisexual and Transgender community.  Commissioner John Mack attended the funeral services for community member Bo Taylor and noted the many dignitaries at the service.  Commissioner Mack also asked that the issue which was raised last week regarding DNA grant applications, be brought to a future Commission meeting.

Report of the Executive Director - Richard Tefank reported that we are awaiting the report from the Public Works Office of Contract Compliance regarding the Explorer issue.  A report will be presented in September regarding the issues previously raised by Commissioner Skobin about the Reserves.  A report is also forthcoming regarding community relations issues raised by Commissioner Pacheco.

Report of the Inspector General -  André Birotte was out last week, yet he was pleased to speak at the Chief's African American Community Forum meeting regarding the role and responsibility of the Office of the Inspector General.

Report of the Chief - First Assistant Chief James McDonnell reported that he was pleased to be present at the recent recruit graduation which added 53 more officers to the Department.  He stated that recruitment is on track for hiring 780 additional officers for this fiscal year.   He stated that total violent crime is down by 6% compared to this time last year.

Senior Clerk Typist Yazmin Garcia was named the Police Commission Employee of the Month for July, 2008.Yazmin is instrumental in assisting the Advocates in presenting cases and is sought out by all Commission employees for her expertise and knowledge of permit issues.  She is always willing to assist fellow co-workers in all tasks.

The reports relative to the Department's Complaint, Form 1.28, Investigations Audit, Phase II (Fiscal Year 2007/2008), and the Commission request for management response to that audit, were both continued for 60 days.  The Commission expressed a desire for management exit interviews to be conducted on all audits before they are presented to the Commission, time permitting.

The Police Commissioners were pleased to approve the awarding of the Police Commission Distinguished Service Medal to Deputy Chief Michael Hillmann for his outstanding career at the Los Angeles Police Department.  The medal will be presented on a future date.

Deputy Chief Mark Perez, Commander Rick Webb, Executive Director Richard Tefank, and expert Dr. Lorie Fridell made presentations on aspects of racial profiling in law enforcement.  All presentations had similar conclusions in that this issue is nationwide and the agencies that were polled report no instances of racial profiling occurring mainly because it is virtually impossible to confirm.  However, all presenters concluded that it would be incorrect to believe that it is not happening.  Given that conclusion, the Commission approved the following recommendations:

?    That the Department provide a quarterly report to the Commission on complaints of racial profiling received and adjudicated by Bureau and Area. In that report, the Commission also expects a progress report of all items approved today on this issue.

?    That the Inspector General prepare an audit of racial profiling complaints that have been investigated and adjudicated since training has been provided to all Internal Affairs Investigators on the use and utilization of the Racial Profiling Investigation Protocol and Racial Profiling Investigation Check List.

?    That the Department include a review of the Digital In-Car Video System, if available, in the Racial Profiling Investigation Protocol and Racial Profiling Investigation Check List.

?    That a review of the New Jersey State Police “Model Investigative Plan: Racial Profiling,” be presented with the first quarterly presentation of complaints to the Commission.

?    That the Department revise the Alternative Complaint Resolution (ACR) process to allow some complaints of racial profiling to be resolved through mediation.

?    That the Department change the term from “Racial Profiling,” to “Biased Policing,” to be more inclusive of other biases including religion and sexual orientation.  Also, that the Department refine complaints of Discourtesy to the specific nature of the misconduct.

?    That the Department continue to rigorously apply the Racial Profiling Investigation Protocol and Racial Profiling Investigation Check List.

?    That the Department review the data capture process and recommend to either continue the process, or not, at the first quarterly presentation.

All Commissioners agreed that this was a very good beginning in aggressively addressing an issue which has been illusive to all law enforcement agencies.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

At the Regular Police Commission Meeting on August 12, 2008

Commission Business - Commissioner Robert Saltzman commented that he downloaded the most recent Police Commission meeting from Channel 35's web site and was pleased that this option is available to the public. He thanked the Department for the prompt report on the donations made to the Explorer program.  While this report does not address the fundamental policy issue of the Explorer program, it does assist greatly in analyzing the issue.  Commissioner Alan Skobin participated in the West Valley National Night Out and a meeting of the Los Angeles Police Emerald Society where author James Ellroy was the keynote speaker. Commissioner Skobin also attended a Foothill Roll Call where he had the opportunity to observe the Autism Awareness Training.  He was very impressed with the presentation of this valuable material and thanked Commissioner Pacheco for his participation in this program.  In addition, Commissioner Skobin, along with Commissioner Ordin, met with Deputy Chief Paysinger, Captain Scott, and Commander Grey to discuss the Crime Reduction and Enforcement Warrant (CREW) program.  Commissioner John Mack participated in the Wilshire National Night Out event and commended Sgt. Eric Mollinedo who actually returned to Wilshire Area that evening to ensure the event's success.  Commissioner Anthony Pacheco introduced two summer interns from his firm, Wendy Cervantes and Will Kuffle, who are high school students associated with the Constitutional Rights Foundation.  Commissioner Pacheco attended the National Night Out events for both Newton and Central Areas.  He thought they were both outstanding examples of community relations.  He also spoke and fielded questions at the Junior Statesmen Symposium along with attending the Wilshire Area and West Traffic Bureau Open House.

Detective Alex Arredondo was presented with a certificate of appreciation for his outstanding effort in taking pictures of Newton employees, framing the photos and placing them throughout the Newton facility.  This action has resulted in not only beautifying Newton, but has served as a great morale booster.

Co-Chairs Captain Sean Kane and Mr. Larry Stearn presented the Devonshire Area Community Police Advisory Board (CPAB) status report. Captain Kane outlined the format for each CPAB meeting which consists of a crime briefing, round table discussion, and various presentations. Items of concern at this time are group homes, where school children live together with little supervision, and copper theft issues.  Mr. Stearn reported on some of the highlights of the Devonshire CPAB, such as the outstanding Police Appreciation Day, the urban mural project, and the new Police Activity League facility.  He added that there is a need to attract new, and possibly younger members from diverse backgrounds. He also stated that periodic background checks on all CPAB members is a good way to maintain the momentum of the program.

Deputy Chief Mark Perez provided an update on the status of Personnel Complaint Investigations arising from the May 1, 2007, MacArthur Park incident.  At this time, all investigations are complete.  A team of adjudicators have received the cases, reviewed them, and presented them to the involved officers.  On August 25th, the cases will be presented to Chief Bratton for final disposition.  Deputy Chief Perez stated that he will return with another update in September when the process should be near completion.  There are a total of 29 involved officers.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

At the Regular Police Commission Meeting on August 5, 2008

Commission Business - Commissioner Alan Skobin attended a reception for Los Angeles District Attorney Steve Cooley, met with the Devonshire Area Community Police Advisory Board Co-Chair, and met with a senior official from the DEA regarding issues of mutual interest.  Commissioner Andrea Sheridan Ordin continued her review of grievances and also met with the Inspector General regarding policing issues on Skid Row and the Safer Cities Initiative.  Commissioner John Mack attended the National Urban League Annual Conference in Orlando, Florida where he observed presentations by presidential candidates McCain and Obama.  Commissioner Anthony Pacheco attended the Ninth Circuit Judicial Conference in Sun Valley, Idaho, where he met Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals Chief Justice Alex Kozinski and United States Supreme Court Justice Anthony Kennedy.

Report of the Chief - Chief Earl Paysinger was pleased to report on the crime statistics as they reflect some of lowest levels of crime since 1970.  He commended men and women of the LAPD who are responsible for this extraordinary accomplishment.  He added that in March of this year, homicides were up by 40% compared to the same time last year, and now, homicides are in the negative.

Report of the Executive Director - Richard Tefank reported that the Public Safety Committee approved the contract with Motorola for the Burglar Alarm and Police Permit Management System.  He also attended the first meeting of Paparazzi Task Force on behalf of the Police Commission.  He added that the Commission Investigation Division activity report for June was included for the Commissioners' review, and agenda item 7F is continued so that the Chief may be present for discussion.

Report of the Inspector General - Andre Birotte, Jr. reported that he met with Commissioner Ordin to discuss the Safer Cities Initiative in the Skid Row area.  He also was a keynote speaker at a dinner of the African American Attorneys of Downtown Firms.

The Adjudication of Categorical Use of force Incidents - Completion of Training Status Report for June 2008, was received and filed, and the Mandatory Training Update Subsequent to a Categorical Use of Force, was approved.  Captain Sargent stated that the new procedures, including automatic training all individuals involved in categorical uses of force would begin with cases now being boarded, or being heard and adjudicated by the Commission.

Captain McClure presented the Hunter - La Ley 4th Quarter Report for Fiscal Year 2007-08.  Commissioners expressed some concern with some of the findings and asked what more can be done to promote individuals of color and females.  Mr. Chaleff stated that a great deal is being done to encourage individuals to take promotional examinations, yet they cannot be forced to do so.  The report was approved, however the Department was asked to return with a breakdown of the statistics by Area and a more complete look at the advanced pay grade and coveted positions.  In addition, employee organizations such as La Ley and the Oscar Joel Bryant Association, will be part of the next presentation.

The Inspector General's review of the Department's Discipline Report for the First Quarter of 2008, was approved.  Areas of concern included the increase in sustained false statements.  Commissioner Pacheco asked that Commissioner Ordin be provided updates on further investigations into these complaints.  Commissioner Mack expressed concern over the fact that the categories of discrimination, racial profiling and unlawful searches have no sustained complaints.  Commander Rick Webb responded that the discrimination complaints are mainly internal employee-generated complaints and a comprehensive report is forthcoming regarding the racial profiling complaints on August 19th. He did not have information regarding the unlawful searches and would return with that information.

The meeting was adjourned in honor of Los Angeles Sheriff Deputy Juan Abel Escalante.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

At the Regular Police Commission Meeting on July 22, 2008

The first order of business was the annual Police Commission election of officers.  President Anthony Pacheco and Vice President John Mack were re-elected to serve in these respective positions for an additional year.  Both expressed appreciation to their fellow Commissioners for the honor and were looking forward to another year of service.

Commission Business - Commissioner Robert Saltzman was present at the Department's response to a homicide in the Wilshire Area and was impressed with the professional yet sensitive manner in which it was handled.  He also asked that the Department prepare a listing of donations, including donor, amount and designation.  In addition, he noted that it has been eight months since the Department was asked some rather specific questions regarding the Explorer program.  He asked for an update on when this presentation would be made.  Commissioner Andrea Sheridan Ordin attended the Oscar Joel Bryant Association's reception for recently promoted command staff.  She also attended and spoke at the recent recruit graduation and commented that it was a lovely day, yet would like to see more African American and women in the recruitment pipeline.  She added that her firm recently sponsored a $10,000 scholarship to a Roosevelt High School student through the Los Angeles County Bar Association.  Commissioner Alan Skobin attended the Chief's Religious Community Forum meeting, the Police Protective League's Eagle and Badge Gala, the Oscar Joel Bryant event, and he also spoke with City Controller Laura Chick regarding the Reserve program and stipends for uniforms.  Commissioner John Mack attended the Oscar Joel Bryant event and a breakfast sponsored by the Association of Black Law Enforcement Executives.  Commissioner Anthony Pacheco participated in a briefing with staff from the Inspector general's Office at the Anti-Terrorism Intelligence Section.  He found that their ability to balance constitutional policing with aggressive homeland security measures was impressive.  Commissioner Pacheco also attended the Eagle and Badge Gala.

Report of the Chief - Chief William Bratton reported that for the first time this year, homicides are down compared to this time last year. Total violent crime is down by 7.2%.  He was pleased to announce that the first class of students going through the Counter Terrorism Academy Pilot Program, were to graduate today.    

Report of the Inspector General - Andre Birotte, Jr. reported that he was pleased to attend the Anti-Terrorist briefing with Commissioner Pacheco.  He also met with, and provided a review of the Inspector General's Office for members of the Muslim community with Assistant Chief James McDonnell.

Commander Rick Webb outlined a recommended change to the adjudication of Categorical Use of Force cases.  Commander Webb and others, including Police Commissioners, had identified the negative connotation related to training which is often received after the adjudication of a Categorical Use of Force.  In an attempt to remove that stigmatism, and bring the handling of these cases more in line with the Department's newer disciplinary approach of “think strategy before penalty,” the Commission approved the recommendations.  The changes include the implementation of a Tactical Debriefing which will be held for all officers involved in a Categorical Use of Force.  This debriefing may include issues as outlined by the Use of Force Review Board, the Chief of Police, or the Police Commissioners, for each particular case.  If either the tactics, drawing and exhibiting the firearm, or the use of force during an incident, are deemed Out of Policy - Administrative Disapproval, the involved officer is subject to one or more of the following actions: extensive retraining, notice to correct deficiencies, or a personnel complaint.  Findings of Administrative Disapproval shall no longer result in the automatic initiation of a personnel complaint. All Categorical Use of Force cases will continue to be presented to the Police Commission for their review and adjudication.  In addition, the new policy will require the Police Commissioners to provide a written rationale if they do not agree with the Chief's findings, and the Police Commission findings shall be considered final.


Co-Chairs Captain Sharyn Buck and Mr. Eric Reuveni presented the North Hollywood Area Community Police Advisory Board (CPAB) status report. Captain Buck provided an overview of North Hollywood.  The diverse area is home to numerous celebrities, studios, and four Council Districts. She reported that Part One Crimes are down by 4.1% and gang-related homicides are down by 80%.  Mr. Reuveni reported that the partnership with the community is based on crime prevention.  The North Hollywood CPAB has continually focused on getting crime prevention tips out to the community. The Police Assistance Surveillance Team has been very successful in being the eyes and ears of the police on numerous occasions. Problem solving success stories included the “tunnel of trouble,” which attracted a transient community creating filth, graffiti, and crime.  Through the CPAB's efforts, this tunnel has been sealed and no longer poses a community risk.  The availability of mass transit has been both good and bad in the fact that it creates an opportunity for suspects to travel into the area easily.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

At the Regular Police Commission Meeting on July 15, 2008

Commission Business - Commissioner Robert Saltzman attended the recent Chief's Gay Lesbian Bisexual Transgender (GLBT) Community Forum meeting.  He noted that the relationship between the GLBT community and the LAPD has improved greatly through enhanced communication.  Some of the questions raised at the meeting were related to the intake of hate crime complaints and the Explorer issue.  Commissioner Saltzman also participated in the Mayor's quarterly GLBT breakfast for Los Angeles City gay appointees.  Along with Commissioner Pacheco, Commissioner Saltzman met with Deputy Chief Charlie Beck to discuss audits within the Detective Bureau. Commissioner Alan Skobin attended the Devonshire Police Activities League's luncheon benefitting their new youth center.  He also attended a luncheon with the North Hollywood Jeopardy program participants, and met with the La Ley Educational Foundation members.  Commissioner Andrea Ordin reviewed several reports and participated in various phone meetings.  Commissioner John Mack attended Judge Gary Feess' hearing regarding financial disclosure.  While no decision was reached, Commissioner Mack felt that the hearing raised important issues.  Commissioner Anthony Pacheco stated that along with the previous items, he participated in a briefing on “Policing in Los Angeles,” to associates at his law firm, Proskauer Rose.

Report of the Chief - Chief William Bratton reported that compared to this time last year, Part One, or serious crimes, are down by 6.5%.  Gang-related crime is down by 14.2%.  He commented on the individual who was booked for murder when he led police on a chase through Hollywood and hit a pedestrian.  Chief Bratton added that the Department's pursuits are down by 35% compared to last year, and that DUI arrests are up by 19%.

Report of the Inspector General - Andre Birotte, Jr. reported that he attended the Department's Audit School last week and felt that it was very helpful and informative.

Captain Michael Moriarty presented the Department's report on the Legal Defense Program administered by the Los Angeles Police Protective League.  He stated that the League maintains a trust fund for the purpose of defending officers involved in discipline matters and also for providing payroll reimbursement in the event that an officer is suspended and chooses not to appeal the decision.  The Department's belief is that this program does not mitigate the impact of discipline. Chief Bratton added that it is a good program that has been in place for a number of years and that it essentially does not impact the Department's disciplinary system, however, what is being presented is a subjective opinion.  The Commission asked that the Department return with a stated methodology detailing a study comparing other law enforcement agencies with similar programs, more information on the history and inception of the program, and additional quantitative information.  The Commissioners also asked the Los Angeles Police Protective League and the American Civil Liberties Union be invited to that meeting to participate in the discussion.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

At the Regular Police Commission Meeting on July 1, 2008

Commission Business - Commissioner Robert Saltzman attended the CPAB Summit during the previous week, along with a meeting with community members and Sgt. Lisa Phillips from Northeast Vice Unit to discuss various lewd conduct issues.  He was impressed with some of the creative ways to address the issue which cannot be adequately controlled through law enforcement alone. Commissioner Saltzman also attended an event at the Getty House with the Mayor benefitting the Getty House Youth Programs.  He also participated in the City Council's recognition of Gay and Lesbian Pride Month, where both he and Chief Bratton honored Captain Tina Nieto from Hollenbeck Area. Additionally, Commissioner Saltzman attended a weekend event with the Mayor and members of the Gay and Lesbian community.  Commissioner Andrea Sheridan Ordin attended a retirement event honoring Deputy City Attorney Wilma Pinder, along with a celebration for the beginning of service for Deputy District Attorney D'Annette Meyers as the President of the County Bar Association.  At this event, retiring County Supervisor Yvonne Brathwaite Burke was also honored.  Commissioner Ordin also attended the Chief's Clergy Summit and felt that the meeting was productive.  In addition, she attended the press conference announcing the results of the Northeast Area multi-agency gang sweep.  Commissioner Alan Skobin attended two retirement dinners, one for Detective McConnell and one for Lt. Jones. He participated in the dedication ceremony for the new Operation Valley Bureau and Valley Traffic facility.  He was very pleased to see the much improved accommodations for the employees.  In attending the Chief's Clergy Summit, he was impressed with the job opportunities tied in with the clergy community.  Commissioner Skobin also met with Council Member Zine to discuss gang issues.  Commissioner John Mack, along with Commissioners Pacheco and Skobin, attended the promotional ceremony for one commander and several captains, the welcoming ceremony for Captain Eric Davis to Wilshire Area,  He also introduced Mayor Villaraigosa at the Mayor's Urban Business Summit, along with attending the memorial service for Los Angeles public relations pioneer Pat Tobin.  Commissioner Anthony Pacheco observed the gang sweep in Northeast Area.  He was very impressed with the effectiveness of the multi-agency task force and commended all who participated.  He commented that a command post will stay in the area to provide continued safety.

Report of the Chief - Chief William Bratton reported that compared to this time last year, Part One, or serious crimes, are down by 6.4%.  Chief Bratton relayed the statistics reflecting the ethnic composition of the Department, which closely resembled that of the City's.  He stated that re-training will begin on Special Order 40 in the near future so that all officers are clear on its meaning. He outlined the chain of events that occurred the previous afternoon once the Department had learned of a judge's decision to dismiss a case once a video provided evidence that contradicted the officers' account of the incident.  The involved officers have been assigned to home and the matter will be fully investigated.

Report of the Executive Director - Richard Tefank reported that the Commission Investigation Division Activity Report for the month of May was included for review, and that staff from Charitable Services Section has been making presentations regarding the guidelines for charitable organizations to Council District offices.

Report of the Inspector General - Andre Birotte, Jr. reported that he has attended many of the same events previously mentioned.  He also stated that he had been quickly notified of the incident involving the LAPD officers and will be following the investigation closely.

Acting Commission Executive Assistant Donna Basulto was named the Police Commission Employee of the Month for June, 2008.  Donna eagerly stepped in and assisted during vacancies in the Executive Section, ensuring that all functions proceeded seamlessly.

The Commission approved the donation from Lockheed Martin Corporation of the Hydra and Minerva Simulation System.  Chief Bratton described this system that will allow command staff to communicate critical information in real time. A demonstration of this system will be provided to the Commission in the future.

The Foreign Language and Telecommunications Device for the Deaf (TDD) Telephone Calls Audit was received and filed until this item returns in 60 days. Commissioner Saltzman raised some questions regarding the report and expressed concern over the relatively low compliance rate. When the Department returns to discuss this issue, the following items will be discussed:  how this item is handled in COMPSTAT, the number of complaints related to this issue and how they are handled, the need for TDD machines in the Traffic Bureaus and at Airport Field Services, and the training provided on how to handle these calls.

The Department's Complaint, Form 1.28, Investigations Audit, Phase II (Fiscal Year 2007/2008), was continued for 45 days so that management's response to the audit may be included in the review.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

At the Regular Police Commission Meeting on June 24, 2008

Commission Business - Commissioner Andrea Sheridan Ordin attended the historic promotion ceremony for Deputy Chief Sandy Jo MacArthur, the third woman in the LAPD to be named Deputy Chief. Commissioner Alan Skobin attended and spoke at the recent LAPD recruit graduation, previewed the Commissioners' Gallery at the Los Angeles Police Museum, attended the Peace Officers Association of Los Angeles County Board Meeting, attended the Shomrim Brunch, visited the recently injured Valley Traffic Division motor officer in the hospital, and participated in the interactive experience of the Force Options Simulator.  He noted that the simulator provides excellent real time training to officers in the options they have to control a volatile situation.  Commissioner John Mack met with Commissioner Pacheco and Executive Director Tefank to discuss several issues.  Commissioner Mack, along with Commissioner Pacheco, Commissioner Saltzman and Commissioner Skobin attended the Chief's Community Forum Summit, and felt that the dialogue was very constructive.  He was intrigued with the notion of the use of anger management techniques with gang members.  Commissioner Anthony Pacheco was also interested in that approach and will pursue the issue. Commissioner Pacheco also met with Deputy Mayor Jeff Carr to discuss gang issues.

Report of the Chief - Chief William Bratton reported that compared to this time last year, all violent crime is down by 6.1%, and gang-related crime is down by 14.8%.  The Department is keeping up with the goal of hiring 60 new recruits per month.  He announced that the first of three meetings with members of the clergy will be held this Saturday morning at the Ahmanson Recruit Center.  The dedication ceremony for the Valley Operations Bureau/Valley Traffic Division Facility will also be held this Saturday.

Co-Chairs Captain Joe Hiltner and Pat Karasic presented a status report on the Pacific Area Community Police Advisory Board.  Captain Hiltner described the Area's traits and challenges including Venice Beach and Los Angeles International Airport.  Part One Crime in Pacific Area is down by 10% compared to this time last year.  Ms. Karasic stated that the Pacific Area is becoming quite active again and has recently renovated the officers' break room and has providing landscaping for the station.  In addition, the dialogue created by CPAB members has been very effective in crime solving.  Pacific Area CPAB is currently looking for new members to continue the positive work they are accomplishing.

Commander Kirk Albanese and Lt. Doug Miller presented the Department's Community Relations Efforts.  He stated that the Community Relations Unit provides the framework for the Department's efforts, and that all programs function on an understanding of diversity.  Each station now has a minimum of a Sergeant II, Police Officer II, and two Youth Services Officers to run various community programs.  A new approach is being tried in recruit training which emphasizes life-long learning skills in terms of diversity.  A manual is being developed for each station which will provide specific community information to each new employee of that station.  Deputy Chief MacArthur and Dr. Pannell will return in 60 days with an update on the progress of the Area-specific manuals.

The Audit Recommendation Status Report, Fourth Quarter, 2007/2008 was approved.  Commissioner Skobin asked that the feasibility of providing the Peace Officers Legal Source Book on-line be examined.

The Department's Response to the Complaint Investigations Audit, Fiscal Year 2007/2008, was approved.  Commander Rick Webb stated that several improvements have been made such as the use of direct quotes through hyperlinks.  Challenges still remain in the use of summarized statements, yet the general quality is much improved.

The Grant Application for the 2008-2009 Forensic Casework DNA Backlog Reduction Program was approved.  Chief Forensic Chemist Greg Matheson also provided a status report on the current condition of the DNA backlog.  He said that there is a current backlog of 7,621 cases waiting to be processed.  The majority of those cases, 7,324, are sexual assault kits.  Mr. Matheson stated that this grant will assist with the backlog.

The Command Accountability Performance Audits for Rampart, Southwest and Wilshire Areas were approved.  All audits showed marked improvement from previous audits

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

At the Regular Police Commission Meeting on June 17, 2008

Commission Business - Commissioner Robert Saltzman attended the recent West Bureau Command Officers meeting and also participated in ride-alongs in the area.  He introduced his niece and her friend in the audience, both of whom are recent Yale graduates. Commissioner Andrea Sheridan Ordin attended a Mexican American Bar Foundation meeting.  This foundation provides scholarships for Hispanic law students.  She also worked on grievance cases and will be participating in the next Pro Bono Law Clinic on Skid Row.  This particular clinic will service the 50 individuals who were identified as the most in need of assistance. Commissioner Anthony Pacheco stated that Blair Taylor, the President of the Los Angeles Urban League, made a presentation regarding the League to Commissioner Pacheco's colleagues at his law firm. Commissioner Pacheco also attended the Mexican American Bar Foundation meeting and added that the Foundation has given out $500,000 since its inception. He will be meeting with Council Member Bill Rosendahl to discuss various issues, and will also be attending the Chief's Community Forum Summit.

Report of the Chief - Chief William Bratton reported that compared to this time last year, all violent crime is down by 6%, and gang-related crime is down by 14.3%.  With the upcoming graduating class of recruits, the total number of sworn employees will exceed 9,700.

Report of the Executive Director - Richard Tefank reported that the system which allows individuals to view and retrieve computerized reports from Police Commission meetings will be up and running by August.   The Department's Community Relations report will be presented to the Commission next week.

Report of the Inspector General - André Birotte, Jr., reported that officials from the New Wales Police Department visited the Office of the Inspector General this week as they are researching the various forms of civilian oversight.

Sgt. II Roland Fogel was presented with a certificate of appreciation for his leadership and concern for his fellow officers by bringing the need of digital cameras in cars to the Commission's attention. Through his effort, and that of Rhonda Sims-Lewis and her staff, 20 cameras were distributed to each Division, and 20 for each Traffic Division.

Police Administrator Thom Brennan provided a status report on all of the current construction projects.  All projects are on, or ahead of schedule, including Rampart, Olympic, Hollenbeck, Harbor, Topanga, Operations Valley Bureau, Metropolitan Detention Center, Emergency Operations Center, and Metropolitan Bomb Squad facilities.  The new Police Administration Building is 70% complete.

Captain Ann Young presented a status report on the Autism Awareness Training Program.  This program, which was initiated by Mental Evaluation Unit, provides roll call training to officers on how to identify and effectively work with Autistic individuals.  Captain Young stated that Dr. Luann Pannell has agreed to make this training part of the standardized roll call training program.  A video will also be produced to assist in the training effort.  All roll calls shall have received this training by the end of the year. Commissioners Pacheco and Ordin praised Captain Young for this important work that greatly enhances officers' ability to work effectively in the community.

The Office of the Inspector General's Training Evaluation and Management System II Audit, Phase II, as presented by Inspector General André Birotte, Jr., was approved.  Inspector General Birotte recommended more automatically generated action items.  Police Administrator Maggie Goodrich added that simplification of the process and eliminating duplication of efforts, will further improve the system.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

At the Regular Police Commission Meeting on June 10, 2008

Commission Business - Commissioner Robert Saltzman reported that he participated in the Gay Pride Parade in West Hollywood and was very impressed with the positive response to LAPD by the many attendees. After the parade, he spoke to many individuals and was reminded of the urgency to address the Explorer contract issue.  To that end, Commissioner Saltzman asked Executive Director Richard Tefank to check on the status of the Explorer issue with the Bureau of Contract Management under the Department of Public Works.  Along with Commissioner Mack, Commissioner Saltzman met with Deputy Chief Perez and Commander Webb to discuss the complaint process.  He also received an update on the Safer Cities Initiative from Mr. Tefank and participated in the command staff breakfast prior to the Commission meeting. Commissioner Alan Skobin chaired the recent Public Safety Oversight Committee meeting and attended the Chief's Muslim Community Forum where he learned of a very useful video being produced to assist officers on understanding Muslim customs when interacting with individuals in a law enforcement setting, and vice versa.  Commissioner Skobin also attended the Police Protective League's Annual Delegates Conference and felt that there were several “take-away” items, including the need to advise officers of the many benefits of the in-car video cameras during training, in addition to the mechanics of the equipment.   Commissioner Skobin visited with the officer who was hospitalized last week with a gun shot injury. Commissioner Andrea Sheridan Ordin attended the Women Against Gun Violence annual brunch where Chief Bratton was honored.  She was impressed with the many stories of personal loss due to gun violence. Commissioner Ordin also attended and spoke at the press conference announcing the new in-car video cameras.  She felt that the message of the numerous benefits was emphasized at the conference, however the coverage of the Hollenbeck SWAT incident may have received more media coverage. She was very pleased to be part of the Community Police Advisory Board (CPAB) Summit. Commissioner Anthony Pacheco also participated in the CPAB Summit, the Gay Pride Parade, and visited with the recently injured officer. 

Report of the Chief - Chief William Bratton reported that while homicides are up by 10.7% compared to this time last year, all violent crime is down by 6%, and gang-related crime is down by 13.4%.  He commented on the nine homicides over the weekend stating that they represent a spike, not a trend.  Los Angeles was again named the second safest large city in the country according to Federal Bureau of Investigation statistics.  Chief Bratton announced the promotion of Commander Sandy Jo MacArthur to Deputy Chief, and Captain Kyle Jackson to Commander.  Five new Captains will be named next week.  He thanked the Commissioners for their visits and concern for the injured officer. One of the lessons learned from the tragic Officer Simmons event was the need for the Bomb Squad to roll out with SWAT. At the recent Hollenbeck SWAT incident, this procedure proved very effective as the robot actually went into the home first and relayed real time video back to the officers waiting outside. 

Co-Chairs Vickie Burch and Captain Joseph Curreri presented the Foothill Community Police Advisory Board annual report.  All Basic Car Areas are represented in Foothill's 43 CPAB members.  They meet monthly and feature a guest speaker at each meeting.  Among the popular topics right now are abandoned vehicles, street vendors, graffiti, and shopping cart retrieval.  A Foothill Teen CPAB has also been launched. In both the CPAB and Teen CPAB, there is an effort to gain new members. Captain Curreri added that while Foothill has the largest number of gang members residing within its borders in the valley, it also has the second lowest number of Part One crimes of the 19 Areas.

Deputy Chief Mark Perez provided a status of Personnel Complaint Investigations arising from the May 1, 2007 MacArthur Park incident.  He stated that the investigations went to Chief Bratton for his review last week.  Chief Bratton asked for more insight into some of the rationales presented.  That work is now being done and the investigations will go back to the Chief in a minimum of three weeks.  After the Chief approves them at that time, they will be given to the involved officers.  Deputy Chief Perez will be back in approximately four weeks to provide another update.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

At the Regular Police Commission Meeting on June 3, 2008

Commission Business - Commissioner Robert Saltzman reported that he met with Assistant Chief Paysinger and representatives from the University of Southern California Department of Public Safety regarding issues of mutual concern.  He was also pleased to attend the recruit graduation on May 23rd.  Commissioner Andrea Sheridan Ordin thanked all who attended the Police Commission's community meeting in Hollenbeck and stated that she enjoyed hearing from the community members.  She, and Commissioners Pacheco, Mack and Skobin attended the 2008 Medal of Valor Ceremonies.  She added that the ceremony was greatly enhanced this year with the addition of video clips of the award recipients which allowed the audience to see the more personal side of these heroes. Commissioner Ordin also attended several fundraisers including that of the Inner City Law Center and the Constitutional Rights Foundation. In addition, she participated in several phone conferences and reviewed grievances. Commissioner Alan Skobin attended the Z Awards Public Safety Luncheon sponsored by Council Member Dennis Zine, the Hollenbeck Police Activity League Supporters Dinner, and a fundraiser for the Hispanic American Police Command Officers Association.  He also participated in a La Ley Foundation Board Meeting.  Commissioner John Mack met with Mayor Villaraigosa and several African American and Latino community leaders to discuss various issues.  He also traveled to San Francisco to participate in Police Executive Research Forum's Commissioners' Retreat, which was a meeting of national and international Police Commissioners.  Commissioner Anthony Pacheco also attended Commissioners' Retreat and was impressed with the information shared by all attendees.

Report of the Chief - Chief William Bratton reported that the month of May is Police Memorial Month, and therefore many annual activities wrapped up last week, including the Medal of Valor Ceremony and the Memorial Run.  He was pleased to join the Mayor at the  announcement of the City's gang initiatives.  The multi-jursdictional plan focuses on prevention, intervention, and suppression.  This plan will assist the Department in apprehending gang members on the street, in their cars and at home.  He reported that while homicides are up by 7.7% compared to this time last year, all violent crime is down by 6.5%, and gang-related crime is down by 13%.

Report of the Executive Director - Richard Tefank reported that the Department will be hosting the Community Police Advisory Board Annual Summit at the Ahmanson Training Facility this Saturday, June 7th, from 7:30 am to 2:00 pm.

Report of the Inspector General - André Birotte, Jr. stated that he did not have any additional items to report other than the items already mentioned.

Management Analyst I Orestus Valenzuela was named the Police Commission Employee of the Month for May, 2008.  Orestus has done an outstanding job in monitoring and regulating the permit process for charitable bingo games and carnivals in Los Angeles.  He consistently provides outstanding service to all permitees and is always ready to assist his colleagues as well.

Captain Kevin McClure presented the Hunter - La Ley Third Quarter Report for Fiscal Year 2007 - 2008.  He stated that the challenge for the Department remains in actually getting individuals from all ethnicities to take promotional exams.  A large amount of effort has gone into making the exam process as accessible as possible including working with the Los Angeles Protective League to provide bibliographies online.  Commissioner Ordin commented that the numbers are actually reflecting great improvements.  Commissioner Pacheco stated that the numbers reveal that the Department has a true focus on diversity.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

At the Special Police Commission Community Meeting on May 27, 2008

Police Commission President Anthony Pacheco opened the meeting by welcoming all and introducing each Commissioner.  He stated that the Police Commission holds meetings in the community to hear from community members directly, and in turn, better serve them.

Council Member Jose Huizar welcomed the Police Commission to Boyle Heights.  He was pleased to discuss the new Hollenbeck Station opening in October, and the coming of the new Gold Line, a new City Library, and a new High School.  While work still needs to be done, he feels that the crime reduction in the Hollenbeck Area is significant.

Captain Blake Chow provided a complete report on the Hollenbeck Area including logistics, current crime trends, programs, and future goals. While crime does continue to decline at Hollenbeck, gangs continue to be a focus for Hollenbeck officers.  He stated that an excellent Crime Analysis Detail Unit, gang suppression, gang injunctions, and outstanding community partnership programs are some of the things that have led to Hollenbeck's success.  He mentioned that officers are anxious to serve in Hollenbeck and there is a 3 ½ year waiting list.  He is honored to be part of such a vibrant community.

Joe Correa discussed the outstanding service accomplished by White Memorial Hospital.  This hospital is a true member of the community providing child care and offering intervention services to gang members when they are admitted. 

Nineteen members of the public spoke regarding various issues including successful CLEAR projects in the neighborhood, excessive use of force in the Ramona Gardens area, and community praise and support for Captain Blake Chow and Captain Tina Nieto.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

At the Police Commission Meeting on May 20, 2008

Commission Business - Commissioner Robert Saltzman, along with Commissioner Pacheco, attended the South Bureau Command Officers meeting.  He commented on the outstanding job done by LAPD officers who assisted in the University of Southern California Commencement Ceremonies.  In addition, conversations continue regarding the Explorer issue.  Commissioner Andrea Sheridan Ordin attended a celebration sponsored by the City Attorney's Office honoring Asian-American art and newly-promoted Deputy Chief Terry Hara.  She also participated in on-going Commission projects.  Commissioner Alan Skobin met with a representative from the Taxi industry to discuss law enforcement efforts regarding Bandit Taxi Cabs. He attended the Chinatown Public Safety Association annual dinner honoring Deputy Chief Terry Hara and fallen SWAT Officer Randal Simmons. He also visited the West Valley Station, and finally, along with Commissioner Pacheco, he attended the LAPD Police-Celebrity Golf Tournament, benefiting the Los Angeles Police Memorial Foundation.  Commissioner John Mack was in Washington D.C. participating in activities related to his responsibility as a National Urban League Board Member.  Commissioner Anthony Pacheco participated in a tour of White Memorial Hospital in East Los Angeles.  He commented on the hospital's extensive community work including providing a quality childcare facility and more than 3,500 free health screenings each year. Commissioner Pacheco was so impressed with the facility that he asked representatives to come to the Police Commission Community Meeting on May 27th to make a presentation on the relationship between the hospital and LAPD.  Commissioner Pacheco asked the Department to report back on reimbursement provided through insurance claims for officers who receive suspension time as a form of discipline.

Chief's Report - Assistant Chief Sharon Papa reported that the newest class of recruits consists of 50 individuals, however the new budget authorizes 60 recruits per class.

Executive Director's Report - Richard Tefank reported that the Commission Investigation Division activity report for April, 2008, was included in the Commissioners' materials for review, and that item number 7D is being pulled from the agenda.

Commander Rick Webb presented the update on the Internal Affairs investigative protocols for Racial Profiling investigations.  Since the protocols began in November, 2007, 76 cases have been reviewed, and all have been in compliance.  Two reports on this issue are anticipated by July 1st.  The Department is preparing a report which will answer the Commissioners' previous questions, and Commission staff is preparing a report comparing and contrasting the LAPD and other law enforcement agencies in terms of racial profiling complaints.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

At the Police Commission Meeting on May 13, 2008

Commission Business - Commissioner Robert Saltzman attended a meeting at the University of Southern California regarding terrorism.  He also participated in several discussions regarding the Explorer issue and other topics.  Commissioner Andrea Sheridan Ordin reported that she participated in numerous meetings and also worked on several grievances. Commissioner Alan Skobin met with Captain Young and Lt. Pat Shields from Detective Support and Vice Division, to discuss the City Hotel Ordinance and enforcement, attended the 999 for Kids dinner, participated in the Board Meeting and Retreat for the Peace Officers Association of Los Angeles County, attended the Valley Vote meeting, and attended a luncheon for the Task Force for Regional Auto Theft Prevention.  Commissioner Anthony Pacheco was on the east coast last week but announced that all Commissioners received confidential correspondence from the City Attorney's Office regarding the Department's ongoing affiliation with Learning for Life and the Explorer program. The matter is now with the Department of Public Works, Bureau of Contract Compliance for examination and findings, as that is the entity charged with enforcing the City's social policy ordinances, including discrimination.  When the Bureau of Contract Compliance makes a determination on this issue, it will then be placed on a Police Commission agenda.

Chief's Report - Assistant Chief Earl Paysinger stated that the Department is currently comprised of 12.2% African Americans, 40% Latinos, 6.6% Asians, and 39% Caucasians, reflecting one of the most diverse law enforcement agencies in the nation.  He also reported that gang crime is down by 13% compared to this time last year.

Inspector General's Report:  André Birotte, Jr., introduced Special Investigator II Gary McGaskill, a new addition to the Office of the Inspector General.

Executive Director's Report: Richard Tefank reported the he, Lt. Dawson, and Detective Ben Jones met with representatives from the Controller's Office for an exit interview for the Official Police Garage audit.

Deputy Chief Mark Perez  provided the status of Personnel Complaint Investigations arising from the May 1, 2007 MacArthur Park Incident.  He stated that the complaints are in the process of adjudication and should be ready for presentation to the Chief of Police in two weeks.  After presentation to the COP, the accused officers will have the opportunity to provide a response, and the complaints will then be returned to the Chief for final disposition.  Commander Perez stated the cases have been presented to the District Attorney and a determination is not expected for at least two months.  Deputy Chief Perez will return in four weeks with another update.

Captain Ann Young provided a status report on the Autism Awareness Training Program.  She stated that the Department is leading the way with Autism training and has trained over 500 officers and civilians this year.  The program consists of Mental Evaluation Unit personnel, Autism of America - Los Angeles volunteers, and members of the Autistic community, attending roll calls and discussing ways to recognize the different spectrums of Autism.  She also stated that they are in the process of putting together a video to be played at roll calls.  Emily Iland and Caroline Wilson from Autism Society of America and Detective III Gil Escontrias were presented with certificates of appreciation for their outstanding work in creating, developing, and implementing this valuable program.

The Timekeeping and Fair Labor Standards Act Audit, March 2008, was approved.  The audit revealed that the Department could support payroll documents 94% of the time.  Commissioner Skobin commented that this audit was reflective of a sampling and may or may not be an accurate picture.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

At the Police Commission Meeting on May 6, 2008

Commission Business - Commissioner Andrea Sheridan Ordin attended the pre-meeting breakfast with command staff, participated in several preparatory events for the May Day demonstrations, and worked on grievances.  Commissioner Alan Skobin met with Captain Baca and Lt. Carlton to discuss the Bandit Taxi Enforcement program, which is a joint effort with the Department of Transportation.  He also met with a senior official from the Drug Enforcement Agency, and separately with the Los Angeles Police Foundation Board to discuss issues of mutual concern. Commissioner Robert Saltzman participated in another portion of the Mobile Field Force Training; the classroom training, which he found very informative.  Commissioner John Mack attended the retirement celebration for Lt. Fred Booker, observed May events both at First and Broadway, and at the command post, and he also attended the Department's Annual Memorial Ceremony. 

Chief's Report - Chief William Bratton overall crime statistics continue to reflect decreases compared to this time last year.  He commented on the success of the Department's work with the May Day demonstrations, and stated that training will now focus on the Department's response in the event of a natural disaster.

Inspector General's Report:  André Birotte, Jr., just reurned from paternity leave and reported that he and his staff were pleased to observe the Department's work on May Day.

Executive Director's Report: Richard Tefank reported a correction on Item 8E, as it should be the “Inspector General's  Report,” not the “Department's Report.”  He added that item 8I has been pulled from the agenda, and item 8J has been moved to the beginning of the agenda.

Hollenbeck Community Police Advisory Board Co-Chairs Captain Blake Chow and Mr. Sal Martinez presented their annual status report to the Commission.  The Hollenbeck CPAB has been successful in several areas of community outreach.  Captain Chow discussed the “Captain's Table” meetings with representatives from Ramona Gardens and the newly formed Teen CPAB, both of which have been very effective ways to enhance community interaction.  The Hollenbeck CPAB is also responsible for a monthly newsletter and a new Web site which provides numerous resources for the community along with up to date information.  With 21 members, the Hollenbeck CPAB is very active, and always looking for new members. Community members spoke on behalf of the tremendous work of Captain Chow and his willingness to communicate and work directly with all community members.

Commissioner Mack expressed appreciation to Captain Chow and Mr. Martinez for the outstanding work they do and noted that the Police Commission will be holding a community meeting in the Hollenbeck Area on May 27th, at 6:30 pm, at Hollenbeck Middle School, 2510 East Sixth Street.

The Adjudication of Categorical Use of Force Incidents - Completion of Training Status Report for March, 2008, was approved.  Commissioner Skobin added that these reports have been very helpful and have shown great improvement.  To that end, the Commissioners agreed that future reports should include trend analysis and should be submitted quarterly instead of monthly.

The Inspector General's Non-Categorical Use of Force Investigations Audit, Fiscal Year 2007/2008, was approved.  Inspector General Birotte stated that the audit revealed overall favorable results.  He did mention that further clarification could be made regarding the handling of complaints that rise from non-categorical use of force incidents.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

At the Police Commission Meeting on April 29, 2008

Commission Business - Commissioner Robert Saltzman attended the West Bureau COMPSTAT meeting along with the Central Bureau Area Command Officers Meeting.  He found both to be very informative.  Commissioner Andrea Sheridan Ordin participated in a meeting regarding the Safer Cities Initiative in the Skid Row Area.  She was very pleased to attend and address the recent recruit graduation ceremony.  She noted that she personally knew a graduate and his family, and it was especially nice to see such a large class becoming police officers. Commissioner Alan Skobin attended a La Ley Foundation meeting where scholarships were discussed for both LAPD officers and young people looking to the LAPD for a career.  Another item that was mentioned was the desire for La Ley to sponsor an award at the Cadet graduations, along with the Explorer graduations.  He feels that the other employee organizations would also like to sponsor awards, and he would like to see the Department look into this possibility.  Commissioner Skobin also attended the Sheriff's Youth Foundation meeting and the recent Explorer graduation.  Both were very well-attended events.  In addition, he toured the new Operations Valley Bureau and Valley Traffic facility. Finally, he discussed with Deputy Chief Beck the possibility of using Reserves in Detective Bureau.   Commissioner Anthony Pacheco commented that he participated in a fly-along with Air Support, which turned out to be a very short fly-along due to an unexpected sense of air sickness! Commissioner Pacheco also met with Chief Paysinger and Office of Operations staff, and discussed the backlog of DNA kits with Crime Lab personnel.  He also announced that he would be participating in Autism Awareness training for a Metropolitan Division roll call on Tuesday afternoon.  This program is the result of a collaborative effort between the Los Angeles Police Department and the Autism Society of America - Los Angeles, to provide officers with the information on how to recognize the signs of Autism, and how to communicate effectively with these individuals.

Chief's Report - Chief William Bratton reported that total violent crime is down by 4.2% compared to this time last year.  He also commented that the Department is well-prepared for May Day activities.

Executive Director's Report: - Richard Tefank reported item 8L has been pulled from the agenda.

Inspector General's Report - Assistant Inspector General Django Sibley introduced Special Investigator II Gary Bushman, who has joined the staff of the Office of the Inspector General.

Deputy Mayor Arif Alikhan outlined the Mayor's proposed fiscal year 2008 - 2009 budget for LAPD.  He made it clear that public safety is the Mayor's priority, and to that end, this year's budget includes an increase in sworn overtime allotment, which is essential in law enforcement work, and an appropriation for in-car video cameras.  All Commissioners thanked Mr. Alikhan, the Mayor, and the members of the Budget and Finance Committee for their assistance in approving a favorable budget for the Department during a challenging fiscal year.

Commander Pat Gannon and Carol Tantow provided the annual report from the Domestic Violence Task Force.  Ms. Tantow explained that an outside company has been retained to evaluate the DART Teams and that report should be complete by the end of the year.  Commissioner Ordin commented that she was pleased to participate in last year's annual Domestic Violence Awareness event.  This year's theme will be Domestic Violence Among Adolescents.

Captain Dave Baca presented the report relative to the Photo Red Light Program.  At this time, there is a dispute between the City and Nestor Traffic Systems due to contract non-compliance.  Deputy City Attorney Terry Martin Brown advised that this issue could result in litigation and future discussions should be held in closed session.

Commander Rick Webb presented the Annual Complaint Report for 2007. Commissioner Mack, along with other Commissioners, expressed concern over the fact that out of 320 complaints filed pertaining to racial profiling, none were sustained.  Chief Bratton stated that his staff would provide an analysis of other law enforcement agencies throughout the country, including the Los Angeles Sheriff's Department, to provide a comparison for the Commission.

Employee News

Special Investigator II Gary Bushman has joined the Office of the Inspector General.  He has more than 30 years of law enforcement experience with Riverside County Sheriff's Department, Tustin Police Department, Santa Ana Police Department, and Orange County District Attorney's Office.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

At the Police Commission Meeting on April 22, 2008

Commission Business - Commissioner Robert Saltzman and Commissioner Mack both received an extensive briefing and participated in a tabletop exercise in preparation of this year's May Day event.  He feels that the Department is well-prepared to assist the community in safely celebrating this day.  Commissioner Saltzman, along with Commissioner Ordin, also participated in a conference call regarding the Safer Cities Initiative in the Skid Row area.  He also met with Executive Director Tefank on various issues, and held meetings regarding Force Investigation protocol, and Use of Force protocol.  Commissioner Andrea Sheridan Ordin noted that the conference call regarding Safer Cities Initiative was very informative and that this discussion is ongoing. She also reported that “Project 50,” a collaborative effort to house the 50 most needy individuals on Skid Row, is now approximately half complete.  In addition, she attended the reception for the new Los Angeles Mexican Consul General.  Commissioner Alan Skobin attended the Shomrim Society's Annual Luncheon where Assistant Chief McDonnell and Department Chaplain Kolodny were honored.  He also mentioned two quality of life issues that do not always receive attention, yet they are very important to public safety in Los Angeles: the Hotel/Motel Ordinance and the Bandit Taxi Cab issue.  Commissioner Skobin has been working on both of these issues and will be placing them on a Police Commission agenda soon.  Commissioner John Mack was pleased to participate in the May Day briefing and agrees with Commissioner Saltzman that the Department is well-prepared for the day.  He also met with Captain Eric Davis at Wilshire Division to discuss area issues.  He joined Chief Bratton, Assistant Chief Paysinger, Deputy Chief Diaz, Deputy Chief Beck and a number of Los Angeles clergy members to discuss the increase in homicides, and the question of racially motivated crime.  Commissioner Anthony Pacheco met with Council Member Jose Huizar to discuss area issues, and attended the reception for the new Los Angeles Mexican Consul General.  He has prepared numerous questions for his meeting with Office of Operations Command Staff, which will occur later in the afternoon. He was pleased to serve as a judge in a mock trial at the University of Southern California.

Chief's Report - Assistant Chief Earl Paysinger reported that Part I Crimes are down by 7.1% compared to this time last year.  He also commented on the success of the Command Mentoring Sessions, which are meetings where new Command Staff members interact with more tenured members.

Executive Director's Report: Richard Tefank reported that he has been working with the Controller's' Office regarding two Official Police Garage (OPG) audits.  Commission staff is currently working on OPG related projects that will be presented to the Commission shortly.

Officer Richard Russell was named the Police Commission Employee of the Month for March, 2008.  Officer Russell has done an outstanding job in developing a power point presentation which is shown to officers to inform them of the police permit process.  He is a valuable asset to the Commission Investigation Division team.

Police Administrator Thom Brennan provided an update on police facilities currently under construction.  Staff is now moving in to the Operations Valley Bureau.  All new stations, Rampart, Hollenbeck, Olympic and Topanga, will be complete this year, however, due to budget restraints, they will not all be open until early 2009.  The new Metropolitan Jail will be complete in February, 2009, and the new Emergency Operations Center will be complete in June, 2008, but will require 9 -12 more months for the required equipment to be installed. The Police Administration Building is 65% complete.  The Department is addressing the issues raised in the Controller's recent audit of the project.  Mr. Brennan commented on the extremely positive working relationship of all City entities involved.   

Senior Management Analyst II Wanda Bell presented the Report for Supplemental Funding for the 2007-08 and Award of Funding for the 2008-2009 Juvenile Justice Crime Prevention Act Program.  The item was approved.  As $90,000 of this funding is designated for the Explorer program, Commissioner Saltzman reminded all that it has been five months since the Commission asked for a response if the Explorer program is in compliance with the City's Nondiscrimination Policy.  Commissioner Pacheco agreed with importance of this fact and noted that the Commission is awaiting legal advice on the matter from the City Attorney's office.

Assistant Inspector General Beth Kennedy and Police Auditor Erin Kenney discussed the Warrant Applications and Supporting Affidavits Audit Second Quarter, 2007.  Police Commissioner Alan Skobin stressed the necessity for clear guidelines for the officers and requested an update from staff in the future on how this need was being addressed.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

At the Police Commission Meeting on April 15, 2008

Commission Business - Commissioner Robert Saltzman attended portions of the Los Angeles Joint Regional Intelligence Conference held at USC.  He was very impressed with the cooperative efforts of all law enforcement agencies that were involved, and the level of presentations. Commissioner Alan Skobin attended many events and specifically mentioned attending the Formal Inspection at Mission Area, the Centurions' Reunion Dinner, and the Peace Officer Association of Los Angeles County luncheon where seven LAPD officers were  honored. Commissioner John Mack attended and participated in the Mobile Field Force training and found it very informative.  He also attended the Los Angeles Joint Regional Intelligence Conference.  Commissioner Andrea Sheridan Ordin tended to various administrative duties and also attended the Phoenix House fundraising event honoring Chief William Bratton and Rikki Klieman. Commissioner Anthony Pacheco also attended the Phoenix House event.  He and Commissioner Skobin attended the Asian Pacific Islander Community Forum meeting and he also met with Deputy Mayor Arif Alikhan to discuss various police issues.

Chief's Report - Chief William Bratton provided an update on weekly crime statistics. Homicides are up by 9.6% compared to the same time last year, however total violent crime is down by 5.2%.  He reported that officers continue to be trained in preparation for May Day events. He also commented on the national media attention that was earned by the Los Angeles Joint Regional Intelligence Conference, specifically related to the LAPD's Anti-Terrorism training program.

Executive Director's Report: Richard Tefank noted that he may be leaving during the meeting as he could possibly be called to testify on a matter in City Council.

Deputy Chief Charlie Beck and Detective Jeff Godown provided additional requested statistics relative to current crime trends.

A presentation of the Special Weapons and Tactics Board of Inquiry Panel was given by Chief William Bratton, Assistant Chief Sharon Papa, Attorney Richard Aborn, Deputy Chief Richard Roupoli, Captain Jeff Greer, and Lt. Michael Albanese.  Chief Bratton explained that this Board of Inquiry was in keeping with the Department's approach of continual review of specialized units to achieve best practices. Assistant Chief Papa reviewed the timeline of the Panel's work and introduced the Panel members.  Richard Aborn reiterated his, and the Panel's, respect for the members of SWAT and commented on their high level of professionalism and expertise.  He stated that the Panel does not recommend lowering the selection criteria for SWAT in any manner, but does recommend opening the opportunity for all members of the Department to apply, as opposed to just members of Metropolitan Division.  He clarified that some of the testing procedures had not been validated for 10 to 20 years, and that they needed to be reviewed. Among other recommendations were additional training for working with individuals with mental impairments, possible rotation in SWAT, and recertification.  Captain Jeff Greer outlined some of the items that have already been implemented.  An interim plan is in place to begin allowing all Department personnel to apply for SWAT, an additional Lieutenant and Captain have been added to the Unit, and officers now have take-home cars, among other changes.  In addition, Chief Bratton has requested that a report on rotating personnel in all specialized units be prepared.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Police Commission Meeting on Tuesday, April 8, 2008

Commission Business: Commissioner Robert Saltzman attended the Mobile Field Force training and was very impressed with entire process of preparing officers for all circumstances.  Commissioner Andrea Sheridan Ordin participated in a meeting regarding the complaint process, as did Commissioner Mack.  She also attended the Central City Association Treasures event and other fund raisers.  Commissioner John Mack met with Lt. Fred Booker regarding the recent spike in homicides in the African American community.  In addition, he attended the Urban League's Annual Whitney Young Awards along with the promotion ceremony for Deputy Chief Terry Hara.  Commissioner Anthony Pacheco also attended the ceremony for Deputy Chief Hara, the 25-Year Pin Ceremony, a promotion celebration for soon-to-be Captain Rick Wall, and the Central City Association event.  Commissioners Pacheco and Mack also received a briefing on the SWAT Board of Inquiry report.

Chief's Report:  Chief William Bratton reported that homicides are up by 9.4% compared to this time last year, however, overall violent crime is down by 4.8%.  Chief Bratton has met with African American political leaders and members of the media to discuss perceptions and realities of homicide statistics.  He plans to meet with African American clergy in the very near future.  He stated that much effort has been placed on reaching out to the Latino community to ensure a safe celebration of May Day this year. The Commission was thanked for the continual attention given to placing cameras in patrol cars, and Commissioner Skobin was thanked for his assistance in securing funding for new Astro radios. Both Commissioners Pacheco and Ordin praised Chief Bratton for his work in shattering glass ceilings in the Department and for addressing different realities in different communities.

Executive Director's Report:  Richard Tefank met with Council Members Zine and Greuel, and Controller Chick regarding false alarm processing. The new computer system will be in place soon to alleviate some of the false alarm billing issues.  He also commented that the Commission Investigation Division Activity Report for the month of February was included for review. 

Inspector General's Report:  Assistant Inspector General Django Sibley reported that Office of the Inspector General staff had attended two community meetings in the Wilmington area.

Deputy Chief Mark Perez reported that all investigations related to the MacArthur Park incident on May 1, 2007, are now complete.  All complaints are now in the adjudication process.  Deputy Chief Perez will continue to provide the Commission with monthly updates.

Police Performance Auditor IV Erin Kenney and Deputy Chief Charlie Beck discussed the Gang Enforcement Detail Selection Criteria Audit, Third Quarter, Fiscal Year 2007/2008.  The audit revealed that performance evaluations were delivered late and that officers who were on loan to the GEDs did not always meet the same requirements as those who were permanently assigned.

Captain Kris Pitcher provided an overview of trends in Officer Involved Shootings.  While the actual number of Officer Involved Shootings is comparable to previous years, the number of suspects who have died in these incidents, has doubled in 2008.  Captain Pitcher also provided a myriad of related statistics and breakdowns.

Lt. Rick Wall provided a status report on the Mental Evaluation Unit. MEU continues to provide training programs for the entire Department, including SWAT and Communications, on how to deal with individuals who suffer mental illness.  MEU has also been providing training on how to work with Autistic individuals.  The Commissioners commended Lt. Wall on his outstanding work in MEU and his promotion to Captain.  Commissioner Ordin asked that status reports to the Commission continue with the new Lieutenant in MEU.

Commander Kirk Albanese presented the report regarding the increasing aggressiveness of freelance photographers.  The Department does not recommend changing the City Ordinance to allow for a minimum “personal safety zone.”  There are existing state and municipal codes which, if applied correctly, can effectively and sufficiently mitigate the hazards posed by aggressive photographers.

Employee News

Commission Executive Assistant II Isabel Rosas has joined Commission staff. Isabel began her career with the City of Los Angeles in 1978 in the CETA program as a Clerk Typist.  Promoting regularly, Isabel has worked at Personnel Department, the Department of Water and Power, the Fire Department, Cultural Affairs Department, and the Board of Fire and Police Pensions Commission.  Isabel is very active in various City associations including the Los Angeles Affirmative Action Association for Women, the Los Angeles City Employees Chicano Association, and AFSCME.  She has also been active in several campaigns including March of Dimes, WalkAmerica, Aids L.A. Walk, and  American Heart Association fund raisers.  Welcome, Isabel!

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

At the Police Commission Meeting on April 1, 2008

Commission Business - Commissioner Robert Saltzman met with Assistant Chief Paysinger regarding several items including recent public safety issues at USC.  He also held several meetings regarding the Explorer issue.  Commissioner Alan Skobin attended the Hispanic Forum and he was also contacted by the American Foundation for the Prevention of Suicide following last week's discussion of suicide by police officers. Commissioner Skobin arranged that the representative contact Dr. Kevin Jablonski to coordinate efforts within the Department. Commissioner John Mack also attended the Hispanic Forum along with the Wilshire Community Police Council's Spring Salute which honored Wilshire Area police officers. Commissioner Anthony Pacheco attended the Police Assessment Resource Center's working group meeting to draft guidelines for independent monitors throughout the country. Commissioner Andrea Sheridan Ordin attended the retirement event for Police Officer Terri Lincoln who was one of LAPD's first female helicopter pilots.

Chief's Report - Chief William Bratton provided an update on weekly crime statistics. Once again, gang-related crime is showing a decrease, yet homicides are still up by 20.2% compared to the same time last year. He reported that recruitment is going well and two classes of 70 recruits began their careers in March.

The Commission presented a Certificate of Appreciation to Reverend Zedar Broadous who has been steadfast supporter of the Los Angeles Police Department.  For years, Rev. Broadous has provided extensive printing services to the Department at little or no charge.

All agenda items were approved including the Grant Application for an Electronic Traffic Citation System from the Office of Traffic Safety, the Categorical Use of Force Investigations Audit, Third Quarter, Fiscal Year 2007/2008, the Initiation of Complaints Audit, Third Quarter, Fiscal Year 2007/2008, Gang Awareness Training Audit, Third Quarter for Fiscal Year 2007/2008, the Adjudication of Categorical Use of Force Incidents - Completion of Training Monthly Status Report - February 2008, the Training Evaluation and Management System (TEAMS) II Audit, Phase 1, 2007/2008, the Supplemental Audit of Arrest, Booking, and Charging Reports, First Quarter of Fiscal Year 2007/2008.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

At the Police Commission Meeting on March 25, 2008

Commission Business - Commissioner Robert Saltzman met with Chief Bratton on a variety of issues including some of the recent crime statistics. He also met with Captain Sargent and Commander Webb regarding categorical use of force incidents.  Commissioner Andrea Sheridan Ordin participated in a meeting regarding complaints generated from the Safer Cities Initiative program on Skid Row.  She anticipates this issue being agendized in a future meeting.  She was also pleased to attend and represent the Police Commission at the Public Safety Committee when the In-Car Video contract was presented and approved. This item will now go directly to City Council as it has been waived by the Budget Committee.  Commissioner Alan Skobin attended the LAPD College Fair where 75 - 80 colleges and universities were represented. In addition, representatives from the federal government were there to advise on GI benefits for officers interested in advancing their education.  He also attended an event presented by the Mission Area CPAB, which was a bus tour of the area.  He felt that it was very unique and informative.  He also met with Assistant Chief McDonnell and representatives from Film LA to discuss rumors related to off-duty officers working on movie locations. Commissioner John Mack met with Commissioner Pacheco and Executive Director Tefank and others to discuss the Explorer program.  Commissioner Anthony Pacheco, along with Commissioner Ordin, met with representatives from the Kennedy School of Government at Harvard, who are conducting an analysis of the Consent Decree.

Chief's Report - Chief William Bratton provided an update on weekly crime statistics.  He also shared Chief Information Officer Tim Riley's impressions, and his own, of the outstanding job Police Administrator Maggie Goodrich did on preparing and presenting the facts related to the In-Car Video contract. He reported that Captain Kris Pitcher will be providing a review of recent Officer Involved Shooting incidents to the Commission on April 8, 2008.  Chief Bratton also announced that he will be presenting a public version of the SWAT Board of Inquiry report to the Commission on April 15th.  Commander Scott Kroeber will be holding a press availability this week to describe the new selection process for SWAT, which he designed.

Executive Director's Report - Richard Tefank reported that Item #8A, the update from the Harbor Area Community Police Advisory Board, will be heard at a future meeting.  He introduced Isabel Rosas, who will be the new Commission Executive Assistant II, starting on April 1.

Inspector General's Report -  Andre Birotte, Jr., attended the Safer Cities Initiative meeting with Commissioner Ordin.  He stated that there is some delay related to the hiring of the two new Special Investigators, due to the hiring freeze.

The Commission presented certificates of appreciation to Donna Muñoz upon her promotion to Management Analyst II in the Detective Bureau, and to Clerk Typist Catherine Taylor, who has accepted a position in the Chief's Office.  Both have done an outstanding job in Commission Investigation Division.

All agenda items were approved, including the Executive Director's report recommending that the 2710 West Temple Street Facility be renamed in honor of Police Officer Randal D. Simmons.

Department Psychologist Kevin Jablonski presented his report on suicide among law enforcement personnel and the efforts the Department is undertaking to educate employees regarding suicide risks and prevention. He stated that the California average for suicides is 9 per 100,000, however the rate of LAPD officers who commit suicide is 21 per 100,000. It is four times more likely that an officer will die by his or her own hand, than by violence on the job.  While the Department has the highest number of psychologists working in the most diverse settings than any other national law enforcement agency, there has not been a well-coordinated suicide prevention campaign, until now.  The goal of the new Department-wide campaign is to improve the psychological health and wellbeing of Department employees by reducing the rate of suicides to zero and dramatically reducing the associated mental health problems. Commissioners Saltzman and Skobin will be following this issue.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

At the Police Commission Meeting on March 18, 2008

Commission Business - Commissioner Alan Skobin attended the retirement for Deputy Chief Gary Brennan.  Commissioner Andrea Sheridan Ordin also attended Deputy Chief Brennan's retirement, and worked with staff from the Office of the Inspector General on a variety of issues including enforcement on Skid Row.  In addition, she worked on grievances. Commissioner John Mack was also in attendance at the Deputy Chief Brennan retirement.  Commissioner Anthony Pacheco held several meetings with command staff, Commission staff, and staff from the Office of the Inspector General on numerous topics.

Chief's Report - Assistant Chief James McDonnell commented on Deputy Chief Brennan's retirement and the fact the five generations of Brennans have served the Los Angeles Police Department.  He reported that there are currently 418 recruits in the Police Academy and the Mayor has given his full support to continue hiring police officers.

Executive Director's Report - Richard Tefank reported that the In-Car Video project will be heard in Public Safety Committee on Monday, March 24th.  Commissioner Ordin has graciously agreed to attend the meeting. Lt. Doug Miller and Lt. Fred Booker will present the  community relations report next week.

Deputy Chief Charlie Beck and Detective Jeff Godown presented a Homicide Analysis Report.  Homicides are up 34.8% compared to this time last year.  The Department is not suggesting that there is one particular reason for this current spike, yet there are numerous factors to look at to get a complete picture.  Last year, homicides were at a relatively low level in comparison to the proceeding 10 years, so comparing to last year only is not a comprehensive analysis.  Deputy Chief Beck reiterated that the statistics do not support any form of hate crimes related to these homicides.  In practically every incident, the victim and the suspect are of the same ethnicity.  He also stated that while homicides are up, shots fired and aggravated assaults are down. In addition, gang-related crimes, including gang-related homicides, are down. Each incident receives complete attention and analysis as the Department continues to try and lower the homicide statistics.

Assistant Chief James McDonnell provided a status report on the recommendations provided in the “Rampart Revisited,” report and the“Blueprint for 21st Century Policing.”  He stated that all recommendations are proceeding and Commissioner Pacheco asked that regular, future updates be provided.

The Office of the Inspector General's status of their review of the MacArthur Park incident investigation was given by Inspector General André Birotte.  Special Investigators Julie Buchwald and Teresa Magula have been actively following this investigation.  A public report will be prepared by the Office of the Inspector General in the future.  Mr. Birotte stated he would ideally like more resources to handle this investigation, however he feels that it can be adequately handled at current staffing levels. 

The Commission approved the Office of the Inspector General's report relative to the Gang Enforcement Detail Work Product Assessment Summary, Fiscal Year 2007/2008.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

At the Police Commission Meeting on March 11, 2008

Commission Business - Commissioner Alan Skobin met with Executive Director Richard Tefank, Lt. Andre Dawson, and Detective Ben Jones to discuss Official Police Garage issues.  He also attended the Centurions football game last Saturday.  The halftime ceremony was a touching tribute to Police Officer Randy Simmons who was a former Centurion. After meeting with Valley Bureau reserve officers and reserve coordinators, Commissioner Skobin asked the Department to report back on 1) improving the timeliness with which the City pays reserves the $50 per month expense stipend, 2) paying reserves for their time spent in court or depositions when subpoenaed, and 3) the possibility of allowing full time and reserves the opportunity to purchase and carry LAPD approved Tasers if the officers desire to do so, similar to the Department's policy on shotguns.  Commissioner Andrea Sheridan Ordin reviewed grievances and she also attended the National Organization of Black Law Enforcement Executives (NOBLE) annual dinner.  This year, NOBLE honored Captain Kyle Jackson, along with fellow Police Commissioner John Mack and Inspector General Andre Birotte. Commissioner John Mack thanked Deputy Chief Earl Paysinger for his kind introduction at the NOBLE awards.  Commissioner Mack spent most of the week at the Weingart Foundation Board retreat, which was held out of town. Commissioner Robert Saltzman was ill most of last week and he thanked Commissioner Pacheco for taking over the interviews for the Commission Executive Assistant II position. Due to his illness, he regretted to miss some events, including the NOBLE event, and the Saturday roundtable discussion.  He did manage to meet with Captain Kevin McClure, Officer Kristie Nielson, and Officer Carol Davis to discuss the Hunter-La Ley Consent Decree and the Department's relationship with the Gay Lesbian Bisexual Transgender community.  The Chief has a GLBT Community Forum and Commissioner Saltzman plans to attend the next meeting.  Commissioner Saltzman also met with Deputy Chiefs Beck and Perez, and others, to discuss the procedures and protocols related to the Board of Rights process. He also met with former County Supervisor Ed Edelman.  Commissioner Anthony Pacheco met with the Director of Los Angeles Urban League, Blair Taylor regarding gang issues.  He also stated that Police Commission community meetings are being planned in the near future. 

Chief's Report - Assistant Chief Earl Paysinger reported that violent crime is down by 4.6% compared to the same time last year.  Violent crime is down in all Bureaus with the exception of Central Bureau, where it is up by 5.8%.  Currently, there are 417 recruits in the Police Academy.  At a press conference on Tuesday morning, Chief Bratton and Mayor Villaraigosa announced that the Department is half way to reaching the goal of increasing the number of officers by 1,000.

Executive Director's Report - Richard Tefank reported that a status report on the recommendations in the “Rampart Revisited” report will be presented next week. The interviews for Commission Executive Assistant II were completed with Commissioner Pacheco.  The In-Car Video issue is scheduled to be heard by Public Safety Committee on March 24th. Commissioner Pacheco stated that a Commissioner should also attend the Public Safety Committee meeting.  Commissioner Pacheco added that he would like to invite individuals who are experts on crime trends to address the Commission at a future meeting regarding the recent spike in homicides.

Inspector General's Report - André Birotte, Jr. reported that two Special Investigator II positions will soon be filled.  He was also honored to be an award recipient at the NOBLE awards dinner. Commissioner Pacheco asked Inspector General Birotte to provide a status report on the MacArthur Park investigation next week.

Co-Chairs Bertha Woolridge and Captain John Egan presented the 2008 Rampart Area Community Police Advisory Board report.  The extremely active Rampart CPAB maintains a committee structure.  Their core committee is the Crime Prevention Committee which focuses on public education of crime trends in the area and graffiti abatement, among other issues.  There is also a Traffic Committee and a Youth Committee. Following the Harbor Area program, Rampart is looking into creating a Teen CPAB.  There are currently 37 Rampart CPAB members and there are 9 individuals with approved applications coming in.  It is anticipated that membership will grow even larger when the new Rampart station is complete.

The Northeast Area Gang Enforcement Detail Command Accountability Performance Audit was approved, as presented by Police Performance Auditor IV Erin Kenney and Captain Lance Smith.

The Mission Area Gang Enforcement Detail Command Accountability Performance Audit was approved, as presented by Police Performance Auditor IV Erin Kenney and Captain Bill Scott.

Assistant Chief Sharon Papa discussed the Special Weapons and Tactics Board of Inquiry report which is a confidential document that was presented to the Chief at the beginning of the year.  A public version of that report will be presented to the Commission in 60-90 days. Assistant Chief Papa mentioned that some recommendations are already in place, such as the addition of a Captain in Metropolitan Division and a Lieutenant in SWAT.  Commissioner Pacheco asked if the rotation of Metropolitan officers was addressed in the report.  Assistant Chief Papa said that it is, but in a broader scope, therefore that issue will be presented to the Commission separately.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

At the Police Commission Meeting on March 4, 2008

Commission Business - Commissioner Alan Skobin attended a meeting of the Police Officers Association of Los Angeles County, with officials from a Countywide Emergency Preparedness  program to discuss resources that are available to use in the event of a disaster, and he met with Council Member Parks to discuss the need for Astro radios.  He also discussed the issue with Council Member Cardenas. Commissioner Andrea Sheridan Ordin worked closely with the Inspector General's Office in the preparation and release of abridged summaries of categorical uses of force to be posted on LAPDOnline.org.  Commissioner John Mack met with Maggie Whelan from the Personnel Department and Assistant Chief Sharon Papa, and others, to discuss concerns related to recruitment of African Americans.  Commissioner Anthony Pacheco thanked staff and his fellow Commissioners for their work while he was in trial on the east coast for a two month case which is now complete.

Chief's Report - Assistant Chief Earl Paysinger reported that violent crime is down by 5.1% compared to the same time last year.  There were nine retirements last week, one of which was Deputy Chief Gary Brennan. Chief Brennan represented the third generation of his family to serve the LAPD.  Commissioner Ordin commented that unbeknownst to the Commissioners, Deputy Chief Brennan was present to speak on an agenda item last week, on his last day, showing his true dedication up to the last moment.  Chief Paysinger also visited the Police Magnet at Reseda High School, and he was very impressed with the talented students in the program.

Executive Director's Report - Richard Tefank reported that the In-Car Video issue is scheduled to be heard by Public Safety Committee on March 24th.  In addition, the Department had requested that item 8b be continued for one week, and item 8c be pulled.  Lt. André Dawson introduced Detective III Sandra Betancourt, who is new to Commission Investigation Division. 

Commissioner Pacheco inquired on the status of five projects.  1) Commissioner Skobin provided an update on the purchase of Astro radios. He stated that 600 have been purchased and are being distributed, and 10,000 more are in the budget process.  Commissioner Skobin has also been speaking with Council Members regarding this issue, and all have been supportive and recognize it as an officer and public safety issue. 2) The New Officer Orientation aspect of Community Relations will be presented to the Commission on March 18th.  3) An update on the“Rampart Revisited” report will be presented next week.  4) The SWAT Board of Inquiry update will be presented to the Commission next week. 5) Regular reports have been presented to the Commission regarding the May Day incident at MacArthur Park.  The investigation is now complete and has been presented to adjudicators.  Deputy Chief Hillman continues to present status reports on the recommendations as outlined in the October 9, 2007 report.

Inspector General's Report - André Birotte, Jr. participated in a review of “Guidelines for Federal and Local Monitors,” in Denver last week.  The document will be presented publicly in the near future. He also met with Chief Ramona Prieto from the California Highway Patrol to discuss oversight issues.

Police Performance Auditor III Jennifer Litchfield was named the Police Commission Employee of the Month for January, 2008.  She works in the Audit Section of the Office of the Inspector General and was honored for her outstanding work on large and detailed projects.

Police Performance Auditor IV Erin Kenney and Captain Phil Trotter presented the West Valley Area Gang Enforcement Detail Command Accountability Performance Audit.  While the audit did not reveal perfect results, much improvement has been made.  The Commissioners expressed their appreciation for the format which reflected “high” and “low” risk factors.  All agreed that enhanced communication has led to improved audits.  The audit was approved.

The follow-up report to the Complaint Investigations Audit for Fiscal Year 2006/2007, as presented by Deputy Chief Mark Perez and Commander Rick Webb, was approved.  Items were discussed such as the documentation of presentations made to the District Attorney, improvements made to recording procedures and devices, documenting rationale and interviewing the accused officer, and verbiage for response letters for unfounded complaints.

Employee News

Detective III Sandra Betancourt has joined Commission Investigation Division.  She has been with LAPD for nearly 20 years, and has served at Newton Division, Gangs Operation Support Division, Fugitive Warrant Section, Central Bureau, and Major Crimes Division, Criminal Conspiracy Section, She has served as the Department's Hate Crime Coordinator and as a Bomb Threats/Explosives investigator.  She also worked at the Threat Management Unit, investigating Stalking and Workplace Violence cases for 3 years. Welcome, Sandra!

Management Analyst II Vicky Castro has joined the Alarm Section of Commission Investigation Division.  She transferred into the City from the MTA in 1997 and has worked in Transit Services, Metropolitan Division, the Office of the Inspector General, and Air Support Division. Welcome back, Vicky!

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

At the Police Commission Meeting on February 26, 2008

Commission Business - Commissioner Robert Saltzman had lunch with Director Brian Johnson from the Police Protective League to discuss various issues.  He was also pleased to attend and participate in the Department's annual Black History Month Recruitment Expo at the Crenshaw Christian Center.  He was very impressed with the ongoing effort and detailed organization it takes to continually recruit high caliber individuals.  He reiterated his support for the continuous hiring of officers in light of current budget limitations. Commissioner Alan Skobin agreed that the momentum of hiring officers cannot be lost at this point.  Commissioner Skobin attended a fundraiser for the family of slain Officer Randy Simmons at Miceli's restaurant, the first Chief's Muslim Community Forum, the Police Historical Society Chief's Circle Luncheon, and the appreciation luncheon at Mission Station for supporters of the LAPD San Fernando Valley Toy Giveaway.  He also discussed with Council Member Tom LaBonge the importance of funding replacement ASTRO radios, met with officers from the Van Nuys Area and Valley Traffic Division regarding a number of issues that were important to them, and he toured the Van Nuys Station to inspect the cot room conditions and possible alternatives.  Commissioner Andrea Sheridan Ordin also agreed that funding for radios and hiring officers will remain a priority for this Commission. She participated in a meeting regarding workplace environment issues with several department leaders with a goal of continuing the efforts to improve LAPD as a premier place to work. Commissioner John Mack attended to personal matters this week.

Chief's Report - Assistant Chief James McDonnell commented on the magnificent scale of the funeral service for Officer Randy Simmons.  He also attended the funeral service for Police Officer Samuel Williams, which was equally moving.  He commented on the first Chief's Muslim Community Forum, and thanked Commissioner Skobin for his attendance. All crime categories are down with the exception of homicides, which are up 20% compared to this time last year.  Gang-related crime is down by 15.3%.  There are currently 371 recruits in the Academy.

Executive Director's Report - Richard Tefank reported the Police Commission has received correspondence from the Mayor requesting that the Rampart station be named in honor of Officer Randal Simmons.  Chief Bratton has also mentioned this desire as it would be a perfect match considering the Rampart Station will be the new home of SWAT. Commission staff is working with Council Member Garcetti's office to draft a motion to that effect.  Mr. Tefank met with planners of the move to the new Police Administration Building to discuss the Commission's needs.  He also reported that Commissioner Pacheco will be returning next week and that the Commission Investigation Division Monthly Report was included in the Commission packages for review. 

A certificate of appreciation was presented to Commission Executive Assistant II Julie Walters for her more than five years of outstanding service to the Police Commission. Julie is promoting to Management Analyst II at Civil Rights Integrity Division.  Congratulations, Julie!

Co-Chairs Captain Clay Farrell and Gary Minzer presented the 2008 Hollywood Community Police Advisory Board Status Report.  Captain Farrell described the dynamics of the Hollywood Area and the significant changes and improvements that have recently occurred.  It is a very densely populated area that is home to significant Los Angeles tourist attractions along with a booming night club industry that can attract as many as 30,000 individuals per night.  Goals for 2008 include focusing on crime areas and gang activity, and enhancing community partnerships. Mr. Minzer outlined the general belief that Hollywood CPAB has always held, and that is that the police cannot do everything in a community by themselves.  To this end, the Hollywood CPAB has been very effective in coordinating efforts with other City entities, community groups, business improvements districts, and others.  The fires in the fall emphasized the fact that communication during emergencies needs to be improved.  They believe that the e-policing program is a good start, yet it needs to be enhanced.  The Hollywood CPAB works closely with the Neighborhood Prosecutor Program.  Captain Farrell stated that there are 250 youth involved in the Hollywood PALs program and 35 in the Explorer program.  He also thanked Mr. Minzer for his years of work as a CPAB member and leader.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

At the Police Commission Meeting on February 19, 2008

Commission Business -  All Commissioners attended different portions of the services for Officer Randal Simmons, including President Anthony Pacheco who obtained permission to attend from a trial on the east coast.  All Commissioners commented on the extraordinary outpouring of community support for all members of the LAPD over this tragic loss of a truly remarkable human being. Commissioner Andrea Sheridan Ordin attended the interment portion of the service and was overwhelmed with the beauty of the ceremony and the number of people showing their respect.  Commissioner Alan Skobin remembered sharing dinner with Officer Simmons just weeks before his death at the SWAT banquet. Commissioner Skobin also had the opportunity on two occasions to visit with the officers at West Valley Area to talk to about the loss of an officer.  Commissioner Skobin wears a black wristband from LAPD Family Support Group as a reminder of fallen officers.  Those bracelets are available through the Memorial Foundation.  He also met with Motor Transport and Administrative and Technical Support Bureau regarding the motorcycle safety and maintenance issues.  Commissioner Robert Saltzman thanked all staff who participated in the coordination of the Simmons funeral.  He also noted the additional support received from former Police Commissioners Shelley Freeman and David S. Cunningham, III. Commissioner Saltzman also met with Council Member Bill Rosendahl to discuss various issues and he attended the Chief's African American Community Forum meeting.  Commissioner John Mack also commented on the tremendous outpouring of sympathy from so many different sources regarding the loss of Officer Simmons. Commissioner Mack also met with Torie Osborne from the Mayor's Office regarding the Explorer issue, with Steve Olivas from the Mayor's Office, with Mark Morial from the National Urban League, and he also attended the Chief's African American Community Forum meeting.

Chief's Report - Chief Bratton thanked the Commissioners for their time, attendance and genuine concern during this difficult time. Officer Simmons' name will be remembered on memorial monuments in several locations, including Washington D.C.  It is also a possibility that an LAPD facility will be dedicated in Officer Simmons' name. The Department passed “with flying colors” an FBI audit that analyzed the way crime is reported.  Chief Bratton reported that violent crime is down by 9.1%, compared to this time last year.

Executive Director's Report - Richard Tefank reported that the In-Car Video project is with the Public Safety Committee, and is expected to be heard within 30 days.

Inspector General's Report - Andre Birotte, Jr., reported that he also attended the Chief's African American Community Forum meeting and the National Association for Civilian Oversight of Law Enforcement conference in Cincinnati.  

Police Performance Auditor Erin Kenney presented the Gang Enforcement Detail Command Accountability Performance Audit for both Harbor Area and Hollenbeck Area. Both audits were approved, and in general, reflected improved communication and coordination.  There were items that reflected clerical errors or perhaps lack of judgement, yet no intentional omissions were detected.  These audits were conducted in mid-2007, allowing the Department to respond back to Audit Division with a dialogue to create improvement.

Police Administrator Gerald Chaleff and Lt. Lopez presented the Hunter La-La Ley Second Quarter Report, Fiscal Year 2007-2008.  While progress is being made in the hiring of all employee groups, the statistics still do not reflect a perfect balance throughout the Department.  Mr. Chaleff described the Hunter-La Ley Consent Decree as an instigator to create the feeder pools necessary for equal opportunity promotions.

Captain Scott Sargent described the necessity of protocols of Miranda warnings to suspects who are interviewed in administrative investigations.  A committee is being created to develop such protocols and a proposal will then be presented to the Commission at a future date.

The Department's and the Inspector General's reports relative to the Ethics Enforcement Section Quarterly Report, Third Quarter, 2007, were approved.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

At the Police Commission Meeting on February 12, 2008

The meeting began with a moment of silence for fallen SWAT Officer Randal Simmons.  All Commissioners expressed their deepest sadness over this significant loss in the LAPD family.

Commission Business -Commissioner Robert Saltzman visited Officer James Veenstra, and his wife, Captain Michele Veenstra, in the hospital along with attending a press conference with updates on the SWAT stand off. He was also pleased to join the Inspector General at a meeting of the Los Angeles Urban Round Table regarding the Office of the Inspector General. Commissioner Alan Skobin attended the Anti Defamation League's Sherwood Awards, and the installation luncheon for the Police Officers Association of Los Angeles County.  He stated that all activities were greatly overshadowed by the tragic SWAT stand off. During the past three weeks, Commissioner Skobin has been on SWAT call-outs and remarked of the officers outstanding focus on safety. Officer Simmons was an extremely dedicated and talented member of SWAT. Commissioner Skobin described him simply as, “a beautiful person.” Commissioner Skobin also visited the Veenstra family in the hospital and commented that Captain Veenstra asked him to, “please keep working to get equipment for our cops.”  Commissioner Andrea Sheridan Ordin expressed similar experiences with comments from Captain Veenstra when she visited with her.  She commented that Captain Veenstra is an eloquent spokesperson for the many needs of the Department. Commissioner Ordin also attended the second press conference regarding the SWAT stand off and remarked that Officer Simmons was clearly an outstanding individual both professionally and personally.  As there are many LAPD officers with similar characteristics, Commissioner Ordin enjoys reading the Blue Line portion that describes the personal triumphs and occurrences in officers' lives.  Vice President John Mack attended the first press conference following the SWAT stand off and viewed the crime scene.  He commented on the fact that Officers Simmons was truly a role model in the way in which he conducted his life, as he was a mentor for many children.  Commissioner Mack was touched when he visited the Simmons family over the weekend and acknowledged that they are in the midst of a very traumatic and difficult time.  He also had the opportunity to visit Officer James Veenstra, along with his wife, Captain Michelle Veenstra in the hospital.  Commissioner Mack shared information regarding the services for Officer Simmons:

Funeral
Friday, February 15, 2008, 11:00 am
Crenshaw Christian Faith Dome
7901 S. Vermont Avenue, Los Angeles

Interment
Immediately following the funeral services
Holy Cross Cemetery
5835 West Slauson Avenue, Culver City of Los Angeles

Chief's Report - Chief Bratton reported on Officer James Veenstra's upcoming release from the hospital, and the good possibility that he will not need any more surgeries. Crime statistics continue to reflect a decrease compared to this time last year, with the exception of homicides.  Gang-related crimes are down by 20%.  Chief Bratton thanked the Commissioners for their time and concern given following the SWAT stand off.

Executive Director's Report - Richard Tefank reported that the In-Car Video project has left the Mayor's Office and is now in the Public Safety Committee.

Inspector General's Report - Andre Birotte, Jr., reported on the success of the information session with the Los Angeles Urban Round Table at the Lucy Florence Coffee Shop.

Police Administrator Thom Brennan reported that the new Police Administration Building will be completed by May, 2009, and staff is expected to move in during the summer and fall.  All other construction projects are either on schedule or ahead of schedule.

Captain Philip Fontanetta, Leslie Evans, and Johnny Rains presented the 2008 Community Police Advisory Report for the Southwest Area.  Violent Crime was reduced by 14% in 2007 with the assistance of several programs including the Safer Cities Initiative,  a CLEAR program, and Safe Passage.  Southwest has active youth programs including Explorers, Project Elementary, and Boot Camp.  The Southwest CPAB has now developed a Web site and has been very active in assisting others in creating Block Clubs.  Working with the Los Angeles Urban League, the CPAB has been effective in creating a “Safe Passage” program for youths going to and from school.

The Commissioners approved all candidates considered for the Medal of Valor award.

Assistant Inspector General Beth Kennedy Alonso presented the Inspector General's Complaint Investigations Audit for Fiscal Year 2007/2008. Out of 60 complaint investigations reviewed, 29 had areas of concern. The areas of concern included information being omitted, problematic paraphrasing, lacking effort in identifying and/or interviewing accused and witnessing officers, and not all necessary questions being asked during interviews.  The Commissioners expressed disappointment and concern over these findings and asked the Department to report back in three weeks with a status report on previous recommendations intended to address these issues, and in six weeks to report on the status of the 29 questioned cases.

Employee News

Community Police Aide Joaquin Trujillo has joined both Commission Investigation Division, Alarms Unit, and the Executive Section.  Joaquin is working on his Bachelors Degree in Criminal Justice at California State University Los Angeles. He plans on becoming a police officer, and later, a detective.  Welcome, Joaquin!

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

At the Police Commission Meeting on February 5, 2008

Commission Business -Commissioner Andrea Sheridan Ordin reviewed grievances and several litigation reports while preparing for her upcoming meeting regarding workplace issues.  She had a good report from the third Pro-Bono Legal Clinic on Skid Row.  Fifty individuals were assisted by 38 lawyers for both short and long-term legal issues. Commissioner Alan Skobin attended the first ever Citizens' Academy provided by the Drug Enforcement Agency.  This 10 week program provides individuals with a good understanding of DEA operations and the joint efforts with many local law enforcement agencies, including the LAPD. Commissioner Skobin also attended a La Ley meeting, met individually with Council Member Zine, and with the President of La Ley. Commissioner Rob Saltzman met with former County Supervisor Ed Edelman who is also a current Board of Rights Hearing Examiner.  Commissioner Saltzman also received many supportive calls regarding the Financial Disclosure issue.  He commented that the Vice President for Student Affairs at USC outlined some of the reasons, which were not related to LAPD's response, for the disturbance at USC a few weeks ago.  Vice President John Mack stated that he and Executive Director Tefank met with the Court-appointed independent monitor.  He was also very pleased to attend and speak at the recent recruit graduation and he commented that Commander Lou Grey's son was one of the recruits.

Chief's Report - Assistant Chief Sharon Papa reported that the incident at USC is being thoroughly reviewed.  She stated that the recent news reports of a barricaded suspect actually being a former LAPD officer, were misleading.  The individual was actually a recruit for one month in 1994.  Commissioner Skobin was present at that incident and he commented about the professionalism and safety focus of the SWAT officers involved.  While Part One crimes are down by 13.7% compared to this time last year, there has been a 20% increase in homicides. Recruitment continues to go well.

Executive Director's Report - Richard Tefank reported that he met with Lt. Doug Miller regarding the upcoming Community Relations report which will be presented to the Commission upon President Pacheco's return.  The In-Car Video contract is still in the Mayor's Office.

Inspector General's Report - Assistant Inspector General Django Sibley stated that the Office of the Inspector General will be holding an informational session for the community at the Lucy Florence Coffee Shop on Saturday, February 9th, at 10:00 am.  The coffee shop is located at 3351 West 43rd Street.

Deputy Chief Michael Hillmann and Commander Sandy Jo MacArthur reported on the recommendations contained in the MacArthur Park Incident report, “An Examination of May Day 2007.”  All 23 recommendations are either in place, soon to be in place, or on-going.  Some recommendations, such as the Incident Management Team, have already proven to be very useful. Commissioner Skobin noted that while many line officers have gone through the now required training, some staff officers have not. Commissioner Saltzman asked generally what is different now than before MacArthur Park.  Chief Hillman stated that there is now a coordination of planning, a unity of command, enhanced communications with the media, and a technique that allows for isolated arrests.

Transportation Director Larry Tagawa outlined some of the issues related to the Department's Harley Davidson motorcycles.  He was asked to return in 30 days with a more detailed analysis of the Harley Davidson motorcycles compared to the BMW and Kawasaki models that match LAPD speculations.  

Police Administrator Yvette Sanchez-Owens discussed Scientific Investigation Division's current ability to process the backlog of evidence - fingerprint, blood, urine, DNA, etc.  There are significant backlogs in these areas and they are related to budget issues.  There is a current need for more supervisors, criminalists, support staff, and vehicles.  To address these shortages, Ms. Sanchez-Owens has restructured the Field Unit, switched from analog to digital, introduced robotics to the analysis process, and sought grants and donations, among other things to improve the situation.

The Consent Decree/Gang Enforcement Detail Status Report - Fourth Quarter, as presented by Captain Regina Scott, was approved.

The Consent Decree Quality Assurance Assessment Cadre Police Commission Update Report, as presented by Commander Lou Grey, was approved. 

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

At the Police Commission Meeting on January 29, 2008

Commission Business - Commissioner Robert Saltzman was out of town, however, yet he spoke to the Inspector General regarding several Use of Force cases and attended the Command staff breakfast.  Commissioner Alan Skobin attended the SWAT banquet, the League of Women Voters meeting, the Metropolitan News Person of the Year Awards, and he met with Commander Rick Webb and staff regarding the Use of Force adjudication process.  Commissioner Skobin played a major role in the Department's acquisition of new Astro XTS 5000 portable radios, stated that the Department has received its first shipment of 697 of the much-needed radios.  He also indicated that efforts are under way to complete the project and provide 10,000 radios.  Commissioners Mack and Ordin each commended Commissioner Skobin for his efforts in shepherding this matter to its fulfillment, however Commissioner Skobin gave credit to the focus and teamwork of Chief Bratton, the Mayor's Office, the Fire Department, and Chief Information Officer Tim Riley and his staff. Commissioner Andrea Sheridan Ordin worked on grievances which were presented to her, and discussed several matters with the Inspector General.  She also participated in planning meetings in preparation for the third pro bono homeless clinic this Thursday, providing legal services to Skid Row residents through downtown law firms. In addition, she attended an event at Garfield High School sponsored by the Los Angeles County Bar Association's Diversity Committee.  More than 50 lawyers were on hand to discuss law careers with high school students. Commissioner John Mack met with several people, including Khalid Shaw from Stop the Violence, Keep the Peace, Randy Archibald from the New York Times, and Police Administrator Gerald Chaleff.  He also had the opportunity to attend a Watts Gang Task Force meeting along with Deputy Chief Charlie Beck and Kenny Garner.  He was impressed with the productivity of the group but noted that the overriding tone was one of sadness and frustration due to the significant gang killings over the weekend.

Chief's Report - Chief William Bratton reported that overall Part One crime is down by 15.6%, even though there has been an increase in homicides and rapes compared to this time last year.  Last week, Chief Bratton attended the ongoing Policing in the 21st Century conference in Boston.

Executive Director's Report - Richard Tefank reported that the Commission Investigation Division's Activity Report was included in the Commission package for review, the In-Car Video contract is still in the Mayor's Office, and the Department has requested that Agenda Item 8H be continued.

Inspector General's Report - André Birotte, Jr. stated that his office has extended offers to two Special Investigator candidates.


Captain III Richard Wemmer was presented with a Police Commission certificate of appreciation for his 37 years of outstanding service to the Department and to the people of Los Angeles.

Co-Chairs Captain III Jodi Wakefield and Blair Beston presented the 2008 Central Area Community Police Advisory Board (CPAB) Update. Captain Wakefield provided an overview of issues that are unique to Central, including Skid Row, a transient gang influence, the emerging community of downtown property owners, and the coming LA Live! facility. While the Central Area does not have a large youth population, it does have active youth programs that provide for the Area's youth as well as other Areas'.  This year, the Central Area Children's Holiday Party was attended by 3,100 children.  The Safer Cities Initiative on Skid Row has created a positive impact on Skid Row in terms of crime and quality of life.  Captain Wakefield acknowledges that there may be complaints regarding the enforcement of Safer Cities Initiative, but they are far outweighed by the safety that is now afforded for people who reside on Skid Row.  Given the difficult nature of the job, officers who work the Safer Cities Initiative detail in Central do so on a volunteer basis.  The officers who are there want to be, and thus, they provide an excellent service to the community.  The Central CPAB has been responsible for many area improvements such as trash removal programs, the painting of sidewalks and various community events including “Art Walks.”

Commander David Doan presented the response to a City Council inquiry regarding Department policy on participation in Drug Enforcement Agency raids of permitted Medical Marijuana Dispensaries in Los Angeles.  He reiterated that the DEA does not recognize local or state law and will continue to uphold federal law.  Therefore, the DEA will continue aggressive law enforcement action by enforcing all federal laws, including asset forfeiture proceedings.  The LAPD does assist in the DEA Task Force raids when asked.

Employee News

Commission Executive Assistant I Darlene Goya has joined the Police Commission, Executive Section.  She has been with the City for 27 years and I worked for the Department of Building and Safety and the Office of the City Clerk.  Welcome Darlene!

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

At the Police Commission Meeting on January 22, 2008:

Commission Business - Commissioner Andrea Sheridan Ordin attended the conference on homelessness in Los Angeles presented by the Manhattan Institute for Policy Research.  She also participated in other meetings and discussions regarding the Skid Row issue.  In addition, she attended a breakfast meeting with command staff prior to the Commission meeting. Commissioner Alan Skobin attended a banquet honoring Mayor Park, Mayor of Gwangju Metropolitan City, sponsored by the Congress of Racial Equality, the World Cultural Sports Foundation and the Martin Luther King Day Los Angeles Committee. Mayor Park was also the International Grand Marshall for the Kingdom Day Parade.  Commissioner Skobin was honored to accept an award on behalf of Chief Bratton at this event for his effort on bridging cultural roles in Los Angeles.  Commissioner Skobin also attended the Chief's Religious Community Forum and joined Commissioner Mack in a meeting with the Mayor to discuss the Department's proposed budget.  Commissioner Robert Saltzman joined Commissioner Mack in participating in the Kingdom Day Parade.  He was impressed with the large crowd despite the rain.  Commissioner Saltzman also commented on the popularity of Chief Bratton driving a “T3” for the duration of the parade.  Lately, there has been interaction between the University of Southern California's Department of Public Safety and the LAPD.  Commissioner Saltzman stated that he was again impressed with the professionalism of the LAPD's personnel.  Commissioner John Mack, as stated previously, participated in the Kingdom Day parade and met with the Mayor to discuss the proposed budget.  In addition, he met with the Los Angeles Civic Alliance to discuss the Consent Decree and other issues before the Commission.

Chief's Report -  Chief  William Bratton commented that the Department has eight “T3” vehicles and is working on getting more as they are proving to be effective in the community.  He reported that the crime statistics are up in some categories and down in others, however, overall Part One crime is down by 16.4%.  Chief Bratton announced the promotion of Commander Terry Hara to Deputy Chief of West Bureau, and the reassignment of Deputy Chief Beck to Detective Bureau, and Deputy Chief Garner to South Bureau. He also stated that he would be speaking at two upcoming conferences: “Policing Los Angeles in the 21st Century,” at USC, and part of a series of conferences on innovative policing theories at Harvard University.

Executive Director's Report - Richard Tefank reported that Public Safety Committee will be reviewing the Financial Disclosure issue on January 24th, and the item will return to full Council on January 30th. The In-Car Video contract is currently with the Mayor's Office.

Inspector General's Report - André Birotte, Jr. stated that he also attended the conference regarding homelessness in Los Angeles.  In addition, he has been conducting interviews for an opening in his office.

Secretary Silvia Torres was named Police Commission Employee of the Month.  In addition to being an outstanding employee throughout the year, Silvia recently accomplished three tasks which have significantly contributed to the productivity of the Police Commission: she revised the Consent Decree audit tracking system, she developed a system to monitor the services provided by the Hearing Examiners, and she created a database to track the permitted parking lots in the City of Los Angeles.

Captain Jeri Weinstein presented an update on the current status of the personnel complaint investigations relative to the MacArthur Park incident occurring on May 1, 2007.  She stated that approximately 11,000 hours have been spent investigating this incident thus far.  Next week, the investigation will be presented to the District Attorney and the City Attorney.  There are 72 allegations against 29 known officers, and 139 allegations against unknown officers.

The monthly Adjudication of Categorical Use of Force Incidents - Completion of Training Status Report, was approved, as well as the Inspector General's and Department's report relative to the Discipline Report, Third Quarter 2007.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

At the Police Commission Meeting on January 15, 2008:

Commission Business - Commissioner Robert Saltzman attended and spoke at the dedication of the Valley Bomb Squad facility.  As a new Commissioner, he has become quite aware of the poor condition of many of the police facilities, and was pleased to see the opening of a new state of the art building.  He also attended and spoke at the citywide Community Relations Officers quarterly meeting.  Commissioner Alan Skobin, along with Commissioner Saltzman, met with staff from Personnel Group to discuss the Essential Duty Functions.  He also met with staff to discuss the Adjudication of Categorical Use of Force incidents.  It is Commissioner Skobin's desire to take away the stigma of training related to these incidents. This item will be presented to the full Commission in the near future.  Commissioner Andrea Sheridan Ordin participated in several meetings with staff on various issues.  She also attended the reception for outgoing Mexican Consul General in Los Angeles, Roberto Beltran.  Commissioner John Mack attended and spoke at the press conference announcing the drop in gang-related crime during the year of 2007.  He also outlined the Police Commission's objectives for the coming year to a Xi Boule gathering, and he met with Assistant Chief Sharon Papa to discuss the Department's Proposed Budget. 

Chief's Report -  Chief  William Bratton reported on the crime statistics, which reflect a 20% drop in Part One crimes compared to the same time last year.  He also stated that the Department is on track for meeting hiring goals thus far.

Executive Director's Report - Richard Tefank reported that the In-Car Video contract is currently with the Mayor's Office.  This item will be updated weekly in the Commission meetings.

Inspector General's Report - André Birotte, Jr. stated that he has been working with Deputy Chief Garner and Lt. Fred Booker on community outreach issues and the outcome will be an “Office of the Inspector General Day.”  This day will be announced soon and it will serve as an opportunity for the community to learn of the functions of the Inspector General.

Council Member Janice Hahn described the creation and accomplishments of the Watts Gang Task Force.  Since its inception in 2006, this Task Force has become an influential voice throughout the City and has encouraged entities to work together to create solutions to the gang violence in South Los Angeles.  The Task Force has met every Monday, and often with very distinguished guests.  The Task Force has proven that pulling numerous resources together to work for a common goal works.  Gang murders have dropped by 50% in this area. 

Co-Chairs Captain Steve Zipperman and Jeanette Capaldi presented the Annual West Valley Community Police Advisory Board Report.  Captain Zipperman described the West Valley in terms of geographic size, number of sworn and civilian employees, and recent crime statistics for the Area.  West Valley has many active programs including Boosters, Police Activities League (PALs), Jeopardy, Explorers, a Volunteer Mounted Patrol, a Volunteer Surveillance Team, and an e-policing registration of more than 3,000.  Ms. Capaldi described some of the CPAB successes of 2007, including a National Night Out with 3,000 participants, the PALs Golf Tournament, the West Valley 50th Reunion, and an Open House with 3,000 people visiting the station. This year's toy drive at West Valley was so successful, that there were more toys than requests.  The additional toys were given to other organizations for distribution.  All Commissioners praised Captain Zipperman and Ms. Capaldi for their outstanding work.  Commissioner Ordin captured their presentation by saying, “These reports and stories are the best things we hear, and we thank you.”

Commander Kirk Albanese presented the Department's report on the“suicide by cop” phenomenon.  He stated that of the 90 Officer Involved Shootings during the period studied (January , 2006 to January, 2007), 11% fell into this category.  Some of these cases involve individuals with mental issues that place them in situations allowing the involved officers no other option but to use their firearm. Additional training is being offered for officers to better understand individuals with mental disorders.  The Crisis Intervention training is given on a voluntary basis to officers who want to better prepare themselves for these encounters.  Commissioner Skobin asked that the Department also analyze the suicide of officers phenomenon.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

At the Police Commission Meeting on January 8, 2008

Vice President John Mack began the meeting by announcing that President Anthony Pacheco will be away from Commission service for two months as he is in trial.  Commissioner Mack will be presiding over the meetings until Commissioner Pacheco's return.

Commission Business - Commissioner Andrea Sheridan Ordin spent much of her break during the holidays with family and friends but spent time on Christmas Eve at Central Area observing interviews with Skid Row residents.  She also attended the recent Recruit Graduation along with 1,000 other family and friends of the recruits, participated in discussions with the Police Protective League, and worked on the Abridged Summaries of Categorical Uses of Force. In addition, she continued her efforts on the homeless issue in the downtown area. Commissioner Alan Skobin met with representatives from the Official Police Garage Association and discussed the boundaries of the new stations, met with Deputy Chief Diaz and Commander Cansler regarding various issues.  Commissioner Skobin noted that police officers are often the first emergency personnel at dangerous building and vehicle fires, and in many cases have performed heroic actions by entering a burning dwelling or vehicle to save the lives of the public. He also noted that many awards that have been received by Department personnel, including numerous Medals of Valor awards, have been for acts of bravery involving fires. However, he indicated that the Department provides no training in basic fire science beyond brush fires. Commissioner Skobin requested that the Department to look into the possibility of basic fire science training for officers, to include such things as back draft, flashovers, and other basic areas. He suggested that the Department look at areas including, but not limited to, e-learning and roll call training.  Commissioner Robert Saltzman welcomed the opportunity to work with Commissioner Mack as President.  Commissioner Saltzman continued his orientation to LAPD with a meeting with Captains Rob Hauck and Jeff Greer regarding the Metropolitan Division.  He also met with Deputy City Attorney Julie Raffish and Commander Stuart Maislin regarding litigation issues.  He has been contacted by several community leaders regarding the Explorer issue and he is looking forward to working on this issue with Commissioner Mack.  Commissioner John Mack attended the retirement luncheon for Wilshire Captain Rich Wemmer.  He asked that a recognition be arranged for Captain Wemmer at an upcoming Police Commission meeting.

Chief's Report -  Chief  William Bratton reported on the crime statistics, which are somewhat misleading as they represent only the first few days of the new year, however all categories of crime were drastically decreased, with an overall 28.5% drop in Part One crimes. The overall 2007 crime statistics reflected expected decreases, yet Chief Bratton was hesitant to set crime reduction goals for 2008 until budget issues are known, specifically the outcome of the vote for City Proposition S, the proposed communication users tax.  Commissioner Ordin added that the main factor in the crime reduction effort is the men and women of the LAPD.

Executive Director's Report - Richard Tefank reported that the In-Car Video contract is currently with the City Legislative Analyst and the City Administrative Office for processing.  Commissioner Mack asked that the Commission be updated weekly on this topic.  Mr. Tefank also met with Captain Dave Baca and staff regarding the Photo Red Light project. He announced that Commission Executive Assistant II Julie Walters has accepted a Management Analyst II position in Civil Rights Integrity Division, however she will be on loan to the Commission for some additional time.  The  Commissioners expressed their appreciation to Julie for her outstanding work and dedication.

Inspector General's Report - André Birotte, Jr. stated that he is in the process of filling two vacancies in his office.

Deputy Chief Mark Perez provided the current status of the personnel complaint investigations relative to the MacArthur Park incident occurring on May 1, 2007. The investigation is expected to be presented to the District Attorney by the end of the month.  Approximately 10,000 hours have been spent on this investigation thus far.  A follow up report will be presented to the Commission in two weeks.

The report regarding the Graffiti Tracker program was continued. Department staff was asked to return with a definitive recommendation regarding the program's feasibility in the City of Los Angeles.

The Department's report relative to the status update and a basis for Status of Recommendations - Audit of Fiscal Operations of the Los Angeles Police Department, was approved. 

The Hunter-La Ley Quarterly Report covering deployment periods 7 through 9, for Fiscal Year 2007/2008, was accepted.  Commissioner Saltzman questioned the narrow list of classifications within the Hunter-La Ley Consent Decree and was pleased to learn that categories have been, and can be, added.  Police Administrator Gerald Chaleff stated that the ultimate goal of the Hunter-La Ley Consent Decree was to create an ethnically diverse “feeder pool” of employees and push those ethnic groups up through the promotion process.

The Inspector General's report relative to discipline imposed on Categorical Uses of Force adjudicated as administrative disapproval/out of policy by the Board of Police Commissioners, was approved.  Assistant Inspector General Bershon stated that this report was challenging because the information is quite difficult to retrieve and located in several offices.  Of the 86 cases reviewed, six had fallen out of statute, and discipline had not been administered.  Commander Rick Webb stated that these cases were results of human error, and nothing more. To address this issue, now all cases of discipline, including admonishment, will be reviewed by the Chief of Police.  The Commission asked for this report to also be completed for the year of 2007.

The Department's and the Inspector General's reports relative to the Confidential Informant Control Package Audit, First Quarter 2007/2008, were approved.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~